Can't it be both? A little column A a little column B. It's all good and totally legit. |
Read the thread. SUVs are much more deadly, take up space, use more gas, emit more polution. I watch school pickup every day, and the height & length of SUVs, coupled with selfish driving, make the whole thing 10x worse. |
SUVs have much worse visibility - roads aren’t designed for them. https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/suvs-other-large-vehicles-often-hit-pedestrians-while-turning |
|
What? Not in DC. Where are you posting from? Are you suggesting that the roads in DC aren’t normal sized? Where are you driving in DC where the lane is abnormally small such that it cannot accommodate a standard size vehicle? I’ve lived here for decades and haven’t encountered any such roads. NP--yes, roads in DC are not normal sized. I live and work in Capitol Hill neighobrhood and the side streets are quite narrow. When a car is coming one direction, if it is wider than normal, you need to pull over close to the parked cars and stop and let them go by. OR they do the same when they see me. I don't mind this much as it requires drivers to drive extremely slowly. The streets were laid out before cars were invented. |
OMG! DC politicans would LOVE LOVE LOVE to tax VA and MD commuters! But isn't that something that Congress forbids DC from doing? Part of the whole DC not being a state and not having the authority to do that. A great argument for DC Statehood-- sounds like something that you would get behind? |
|
Wouldn't all of the arguments about SUVs apply equally to minivans? They're larger than normal cars, reduced visibility which means more danger to pedestrians, etc. Yet mini vans aren't subject to the increased registration fee because they fall just under the weight limit.
So, if it's really about safety and improved roads, then mini vans would be included and subsidies for oversized electric vehicles wouldn't be permitted. |
That’s not true. Several minivans are over 3,500 lbs. |
NP--yes, roads in DC are not normal sized. I live and work in Capitol Hill neighobrhood and the side streets are quite narrow. When a car is coming one direction, if it is wider than normal, you need to pull over close to the parked cars and stop and let them go by. OR they do the same when they see me. I don't mind this much as it requires drivers to drive extremely slowly. The streets were laid out before cars were invented. Roads in DC are not “normal sized”. That’s just not credible. |
What? Not in DC. Where are you posting from? Are you suggesting that the roads in DC aren’t normal sized? Where are you driving in DC where the lane is abnormally small such that it cannot accommodate a standard size vehicle? I’ve lived here for decades and haven’t encountered any such roads. NP--yes, roads in DC are not normal sized. I live and work in Capitol Hill neighobrhood and the side streets are quite narrow. When a car is coming one direction, if it is wider than normal, you need to pull over close to the parked cars and stop and let them go by. OR they do the same when they see me. I don't mind this much as it requires drivers to drive extremely slowly. The streets were laid out before cars were invented. Is it that the roads are actually too small or that parking is allowed on one or both sides of the street thereby reducing the size of the drive lane? There wouldn't be a problem if parking wasn't allowed on those side streets. |
The extra price of the gas isn't proportional to the extra costs that you place on every other road user |
It looks like the fee is just for vehicles over 6,000 lbs; it is not specifically excluding minivans. If your minivan is more than 6,000 lbs you would have to pay the higher fee. I agree that the electric vehicle carve-out is lame but maybe it wouldn't have passed without it? |
As if $41,485 is within budget for the working poor. Get out of your bubble. Also, if you can shell out $42k for a big new truck, what's another few hundred dollars in fees? Just for gas you will be paying thousands and thousands more. |
Are you suggesting that the roads in DC aren’t normal sized? Where are you driving in DC where the lane is abnormally small such that it cannot accommodate a standard size vehicle? I’ve lived here for decades and haven’t encountered any such roads. NP--yes, roads in DC are not normal sized. I live and work in Capitol Hill neighobrhood and the side streets are quite narrow. When a car is coming one direction, if it is wider than normal, you need to pull over close to the parked cars and stop and let them go by. OR they do the same when they see me. I don't mind this much as it requires drivers to drive extremely slowly. The streets were laid out before cars were invented. Is it that the roads are actually too small or that parking is allowed on one or both sides of the street thereby reducing the size of the drive lane? There wouldn't be a problem if parking wasn't allowed on those side streets. Off topic, but I recently saw Murder at 1600, came out around the same time as Absolute Power. At one point, Diane Lane escapes from the White House by jumping out a bathroom window and landing in a small alley. |
Why are you so specific that it has to be affordable to “working poor”. Certainly a family at the median income can afford it, which is the point that the policy targets and punishes blue collar workers. |
Most people lease nowadays. The F series truck is the one of the most popular vehicles in the entire country and averages around 800,000 sold every year. They're also just release an electric version that is sold out and is one of the heaviest vehicles on the road. |