This was such beautiful good faith reasoning. Well done. |
^^agree. Thank you. |
Sweetie, there are more than one of us replying to you. Why on earth would you deny virtual speech therapy and virtual classes for your child? That's crazy. You would completely achieve your goal of your child being able to see the mouth and face. And above about the IEP. Self-contained classrooms are known to be better than inclusion for virtually every special education student because the student gets one-on-one treatment. Many parents like you don't want your children in self-contained classrooms, you want inclusion, so that you feel better about your child's disability. Oddly you and the school systems are aligned even if the reasoning is diametrically opposed. If you read the literature it is all very carefully couched. School systems, you're right, would prefer all students in inclusion settings because it is significantly cheaper. You get to save face and the school district gets to save money. ~SPED Teacher (for another district) |
What a bunch of hooey. ACPS distributes free surgical-grade masks and KN95s to every student and staff member. My kid has scads of them. They were handed out in advisory and then he gets more any time he goes to the office to ask for more. He says no one is wearing cloth masks at school. |
Aww, sweetie, I hope you get Covid. |
LOL. ![]() |
Your position seems to be that the status quo is no big deal, but that's not responsive to the point being made. The original point wasn't that high-quality masks don't exist, it was that making them effective in a school environment would require a draconian and self-defeating effort. But since you're not actually committing to a specific policy, perhaps you could clarify your position by answering some questions: 1. Do you think your child's mask (and that of everyone else) was worn with an airtight seal for the whole day? Because that's the only way to make it effective. Otherwise you're just breathing around the filter medium. That would also mean that no one in school has a beard or stubble. 2. Do you think the KN95 should be mandatory and cloth masks disallowed? If not, why not? If so, what is your plan to provide 2-3 per week per student and for how long? 3. If you do think they should be mandated, would you require they be worn with an airtight seal at all times? If not, why would you mandate something you know won't be effective? If so, how do you plan to ensure that students don't have beards or stubble that would render the masks useless? 4. Do you think indoor lunch should ever be permitted? I am of the opinion that policies should be designed to work, not just appear to work in order to satisfy a general feeling that something should be done. If those in favor of a policy retreat from the very things that would make it effective, it is incumbent upon them to explain why ineffective half-measures are somehow worth the effort. Otherwise the policy should be discarded. |
Do you not understand that the masks are being provided already? Do you not understand that there is no shortage of masks and that ACPS has enough to continue with its current coverage through the end of the school year? Do you not understand that all of your counterarguments have already been addressed and that they are not germane to the discussion? |
I am the PP. That’s fair and I am sorry. I think the general mask requirement is appropriate but public schools are still required to provide a free and adequate education despite the masks. For your child, I would presume that would require a good deal of outside the box thinking. I am sorry for you since I know first ACPS fails to do that and really failed special needs students. |
Thank you, Lord, Baby Jesus you do not teach here. |
Except she's right. Your insistence on inclusion quite actually condemns your child to not achieving full potential. If that's what you want then you should be happy because that's what you're getting. |
And the school system keeps saving money. Everyone's happy. ![]() |
The only germane point to the discussion is if they are being worn properly, with an airtight seal around the face, consistently. It's telling that you'll focus on every point but that one. |
You are disgusting. |
HFS you're talking about a kid with a speech impediment, right?? |