German family who sought asylum for homeschooling faces deportation after 15 years in US

[Anonymous]

Thoughts on this? I just don't understand how after 15 years they are getting deported even though they came legally.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/german-family-who-sought-asylum-for-homeschooling-faces-deportation-after-15-years-in-us/ar-AA1hutLn?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=5f815bbf3514499a925e917f2a8134ed&ei=21

[Anonymous]

They have no status. They can't stay forever.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote: Thoughts on this? I just don't understand how after 15 years they are getting deported even though they came legally.

https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/german-family-who-sought-asylum-for-homeschooling-faces-deportation-after-15-years-in-us/ar-AA1hutLn?ocid=msedgntp&cvid=5f815bbf3514499a925e917f2a8134ed&ei=21

Did you read the whole article?

[Anonymous]

The oldest kids are married to Americans and the youngest kids are citizens, since they were born here. They could either stay with their older siblings or they could move to Germany with their parents and go to an American school there (although that might also expose them to undesired concepts).

The problem of avoiding damaging German schooling is solved, one way or another. They waited long enough.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:They have no status. They can't stay forever.

Really? Since when?

[Anonymous]

Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

Literally the petition was weitten because these racist southerners are mad that “The Biden Admin” is deporting them but “not” mexicans. Which is totally clueless.

[Anonymous]

It occurs to me that we should offer EU countries and the UK the easy option to emigrate from their country to ours. Republicans are worried about "replacement", fine let's invite some of their European counsins.

Wonder how many would take us up on it? No free health care, little vacation, no disability, poison food, free education, and don't forget mass shootings. yay us

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It occurs to me that we should offer EU countries and the UK the easy option to emigrate from their country to ours. Republicans are worried about "replacement", fine let's invite some of their European counsins.

Wonder how many would take us up on it? No free health care, little vacation, no disability, poison food, free education, and don't forget mass shootings. yay us

Estimates indicate there are 50,000 undocumented Irish immigrants living here already.
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-40332646.amp

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

They are absolutely being persecuted because of their beliefs.
They have much more valid asylum claims than the majority of migrants who have entered illegally.

"The government’s sudden upending of the Romeike family’s life has come more than a decade after Uwe Romeike and his wife, Hannelore, fled Bissingen, Germany with their then-five children for violating the country’s strict education laws, which effectively bans homeschooling."

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

They are absolutely being persecuted because of their beliefs.
They have much more valid asylum claims than the majority of migrants who have entered illegally.

"The government’s sudden upending of the Romeike family’s life has come more than a decade after Uwe Romeike and his wife, Hannelore, fled Bissingen, Germany with their then-five children for violating the country’s strict education laws, which effectively bans homeschooling."

That’s like saying that if I believe in rape then I am being persecuted when the state sends me to prison. You guys have lost the plot.

[Anonymous]

They came 15 years ago to homeschool their kids. If the children are grown up then why do they still need to stay?

[Anonymous]

I like the sense of proportion here. Don’t get distracted by fentanyl and a crush of migrants here to collapse our system; that would be a junior varsity mistake.

No, keep your eye on the ball.

German homeschoolers are the real threat.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

They are absolutely being persecuted because of their beliefs.
They have much more valid asylum claims than the majority of migrants who have entered illegally.

"The government’s sudden upending of the Romeike family’s life has come more than a decade after Uwe Romeike and his wife, Hannelore, fled Bissingen, Germany with their then-five children for violating the country’s strict education laws, which effectively bans homeschooling."

Really? A likely death sentence in El Salvador versus inability to homeschool?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Deferred action is not a status. They are also not persecuted/lives in danger because of their beliefs. They have no status. People are supporting them because they are white Germans. I’m sure that had they been black Africans no one would give a shit.

They are absolutely being persecuted because of their beliefs.
They have much more valid asylum claims than the majority of migrants who have entered illegally.

"The government’s sudden upending of the Romeike family’s life has come more than a decade after Uwe Romeike and his wife, Hannelore, fled Bissingen, Germany with their then-five children for violating the country’s strict education laws, which effectively bans homeschooling."

Really? A likely death sentence in El Salvador versus inability to homeschool?

A likely death sentence? For what reason? Violence?