Beauvoir or NPS?

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Exactly! So every kid who gets into BVR at 3 or 4, is a sure fit for STA/NCS?!? Not!


Exactly! So every kid who gets into sidwell or gds at 4 is a sure fit for the upper schools?!? Not!

Great analysis.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:]It comes down to what you and your family need (I.e faid, commute, earlier vs later outplacement). The schools are somewhat similar. The BVR kids get preference to STA/NCS but then again, NPS students seem to have no problem getting into NCS/STA when they outplace. BVR is nothing like STA/NCS so as your child matured, you may decide on a different route. Either way, BVR and NPS will support your family choices during outplacement. Go where the child feels more comfortable or where as parents you feel more accepted into the community.


This is not necessarily true. There is a limit on the number of NPS kids they will take every year, so in a since, if you really want STA/NCS, you're competing against your classmates for the spots.


Well if that’s the case, I need someone to make sense of the 7 boys to STA and 5 girls to NCS 2020. I can’t wait to see this years outplacement for NPS.


NPS had 0 admitted to STA in 2019. Make sense of that.


Not PP but according to page 3 at https://issuu.com/nationalpresbyterianschool/docs/nps_curriculum_guide_2019-2020 There were 3(out of 31) kids went to STA in 2019.


The key here is that just because they were accepted does not mean they attended. Some opt for other schools even if admitted to NCS/STA...


Nice try. The only NPS kids who got into NCS/STA that year were those with hooks.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison


85-90% of BVR kids are accepted to NCS/STA most years. The Cathedral Foundation charter requires that NCS/STA give BVR kids priority for admissions as long as they apply early decision. The schools will accept the BVR kids unless there is an academic mismatch, behavioral issues, or some other reason why the child would not be a good fit for the school.

The percentage of kids vary by year, because the two schools test applicants. Some years, fewer BVR kids make the cut-off, some years more.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:]It comes down to what you and your family need (I.e faid, commute, earlier vs later outplacement). The schools are somewhat similar. The BVR kids get preference to STA/NCS but then again, NPS students seem to have no problem getting into NCS/STA when they outplace. BVR is nothing like STA/NCS so as your child matured, you may decide on a different route. Either way, BVR and NPS will support your family choices during outplacement. Go where the child feels more comfortable or where as parents you feel more accepted into the community.


This is not necessarily true. There is a limit on the number of NPS kids they will take every year, so in a since, if you really want STA/NCS, you're competing against your classmates for the spots.


Well if that’s the case, I need someone to make sense of the 7 boys to STA and 5 girls to NCS 2020. I can’t wait to see this years outplacement for NPS.


NPS had 0 admitted to STA in 2019. Make sense of that.


Not PP but according to page 3 at https://issuu.com/nationalpresbyterianschool/docs/nps_curriculum_guide_2019-2020 There were 3(out of 31) kids went to STA in 2019.


The key here is that just because they were accepted does not mean they attended. Some opt for other schools even if admitted to NCS/STA...


Nice try. The only NPS kids who got into NCS/STA that year were those with hooks.


This is often the case. Lots of legacy kids running around.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison


85-90% of BVR kids are accepted to NCS/STA most years. The Cathedral Foundation charter requires that NCS/STA give BVR kids priority for admissions as long as they apply early decision. The schools will accept the BVR kids unless there is an academic mismatch, behavioral issues, or some other reason why the child would not be a good fit for the school.

The percentage of kids vary by year, because the two schools test applicants. Some years, fewer BVR kids make the cut-off, some years more.


This is good to know. So how many kids graduate from bvr every year? And how many kids do STA/NCS take in total? I'm trying to see the chance of getting into these two schools from somewhere other than bvr.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:]It comes down to what you and your family need (I.e faid, commute, earlier vs later outplacement). The schools are somewhat similar. The BVR kids get preference to STA/NCS but then again, NPS students seem to have no problem getting into NCS/STA when they outplace. BVR is nothing like STA/NCS so as your child matured, you may decide on a different route. Either way, BVR and NPS will support your family choices during outplacement. Go where the child feels more comfortable or where as parents you feel more accepted into the community.


This is not necessarily true. There is a limit on the number of NPS kids they will take every year, so in a since, if you really want STA/NCS, you're competing against your classmates for the spots.


Well if that’s the case, I need someone to make sense of the 7 boys to STA and 5 girls to NCS 2020. I can’t wait to see this years outplacement for NPS.


NPS had 0 admitted to STA in 2019. Make sense of that.


Not PP but according to page 3 at https://issuu.com/nationalpresbyterianschool/docs/nps_curriculum_guide_2019-2020 There were 3(out of 31) kids went to STA in 2019.


The key here is that just because they were accepted does not mean they attended. Some opt for other schools even if admitted to NCS/STA...


Nice try. The only NPS kids who got into NCS/STA that year were those with hooks.


How are those grapes tasting?
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:]It comes down to what you and your family need (I.e faid, commute, earlier vs later outplacement). The schools are somewhat similar. The BVR kids get preference to STA/NCS but then again, NPS students seem to have no problem getting into NCS/STA when they outplace. BVR is nothing like STA/NCS so as your child matured, you may decide on a different route. Either way, BVR and NPS will support your family choices during outplacement. Go where the child feels more comfortable or where as parents you feel more accepted into the community.


This is not necessarily true. There is a limit on the number of NPS kids they will take every year, so in a since, if you really want STA/NCS, you're competing against your classmates for the spots.


Well if that’s the case, I need someone to make sense of the 7 boys to STA and 5 girls to NCS 2020. I can’t wait to see this years outplacement for NPS.


Not PP but according to page 3 at https://issuu.com/nationalpresbyterianschool/docs/nps_curriculum_guide_2019-2020 There were 3(out of 31) kids went to STA in 2019.


The key here is that just because they were accepted does not mean they attended. Some opt for other schools even if admitted to NCS/STA...


Nice try. The only NPS kids who got into NCS/STA that year were those with hooks.


How are those grapes tasting?


NPS had 0 admitted to STA in 2019. Make sense of that.


You all are the idiots trying to justify a spot at a school when your kid is 3 or 4! Living through your child because you went to a mediocre public school growing up. My kid is in kindergarten and I’m not trying to secure a spot for 4th grade. . I’ll cross that bridge when I get there when I know best fit for my kid.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison


85-90% of BVR kids are accepted to NCS/STA most years. The Cathedral Foundation charter requires that NCS/STA give BVR kids priority for admissions as long as they apply early decision. The schools will accept the BVR kids unless there is an academic mismatch, behavioral issues, or some other reason why the child would not be a good fit for the school.

The percentage of kids vary by year, because the two schools test applicants. Some years, fewer BVR kids make the cut-off, some years more.


This is good to know. So how many kids graduate from bvr every year? And how many kids do STA/NCS take in total? I'm trying to see the chance of getting into these two schools from somewhere other than bvr.


PP no one can tell you that. There are no statistical odds because it changes every year. Just know that if you want STA/NCS eventually, B is your best bet. Every other school will be more of a gamble, no matter how many a cathedral school happen to take from that school in any given year.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison


85-90% of BVR kids are accepted to NCS/STA most years. The Cathedral Foundation charter requires that NCS/STA give BVR kids priority for admissions as long as they apply early decision. The schools will accept the BVR kids unless there is an academic mismatch, behavioral issues, or some other reason why the child would not be a good fit for the school.

The percentage of kids vary by year, because the two schools test applicants. Some years, fewer BVR kids make the cut-off, some years more.


This is good to know. So how many kids graduate from bvr every year? And how many kids do STA/NCS take in total? I'm trying to see the chance of getting into these two schools from somewhere other than bvr.


PP no one can tell you that. There are no statistical odds because it changes every year. Just know that if you want STA/NCS eventually, B is your best bet. Every other school will be more of a gamble, no matter how many a cathedral school happen to take from that school in any given year.


+1. Honestly it’s not terribly dissimilar to how the k-12s work. Most kids who start in the lower school keep going all the way through, and therefore your best best for the upper school is to get in at pk or k. Sure, kids get in at later grades, but the majority still are coming from that lower school. There’s a more formalized process before 4th to move from bvr to sta/ncs, but bvr is still the lower school in the cathedral system, and the large majority of kids want to go to ncs/sta and then do so. They are separate, but much more similar to a pk or k-12 than, say, a two totally disconnected schools (say, st Pats and Sidwell, Maret, ncs, gds, etc; nps and Sidwell, Maret etc)
Anonymous
Yes, getting in early is the best strategy. Kids admitted at 4 or 5 can continue through the system without having to really compete for spots in higher grades.
Anonymous
This board has went left. The question wasnt “What’s the best route to NCS/STA”. IMO, academically they’re pretty equal. Do you have any to leave at 3rd or 6th.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:So by that logic no one gets WL from BVR or fails to get in at all. Sure.


Not as many as from other schools, no. At least as percentage as Beauvoir classes are larger by comparison


85-90% of BVR kids are accepted to NCS/STA most years. The Cathedral Foundation charter requires that NCS/STA give BVR kids priority for admissions as long as they apply early decision. The schools will accept the BVR kids unless there is an academic mismatch, behavioral issues, or some other reason why the child would not be a good fit for the school.

The percentage of kids vary by year, because the two schools test applicants. Some years, fewer BVR kids make the cut-off, some years more.


This is good to know. So how many kids graduate from bvr every year? And how many kids do STA/NCS take in total? I'm trying to see the chance of getting into these two schools from somewhere other than bvr.


important distinction that keeps getting lost: 85 to 90 percent of kids who APPLY to STA/NCS are accepted. In absolute terms, about 25 percent of the class does not go on to Cathedral schools either because of preference, fit, etc.
Anonymous
I heard through the grapevine that 100% of the BVR kids who applied early decision @ both NCS/STA this year were accepted. My son graduated years ago when parents had the option to apply early (November) or regular (Jan. with other applicants). If this process is still in place, then kudo-ramo to BVR. Those families who know they want one of the Cathedral schools can make a commitment early on so the 2 schools then know how many spaces are left to other applicants. Those who want co-ed, or are counseled to look elsewhere, or just aren't sure have time to look at other great schools in the DMV. Smart process IMO
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:I heard through the grapevine that 100% of the BVR kids who applied early decision @ both NCS/STA this year were accepted. My son graduated years ago when parents had the option to apply early (November) or regular (Jan. with other applicants). If this process is still in place, then kudo-ramo to BVR. Those families who know they want one of the Cathedral schools can make a commitment early on so the 2 schools then know how many spaces are left to other applicants. Those who want co-ed, or are counseled to look elsewhere, or just aren't sure have time to look at other great schools in the DMV. Smart process IMO


Bvr is a well-oiled school these days. Great leadership and great teachers.
post reply Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools
Message Quick Reply
Go to: