It mirrors what’s happening in the workforce so makes sense. |
How do you know it isn't true? I was sharing my actual experience of talking to real people who are hiring partners in their relative fields. How can you as a parent of a random ivy league college kid know that what my friends have told me about their actual thoughts about hiring ivy kids are wrong? You weren't in the room when I had these real conversations. This is what they said behind closed doors to me without you in the room. I did characterize it as my information as anecdotal (based on personal accounts told to me, an involved survey or research study), but that doesn't make it true. I went to an ivy myself, as did at least one of the hiring partners who I referenced having actual conversations about this with. |
* Typo: I did characterize it as my information as anecdotal (based on personal accounts told to me, an involved survey or research study), but that doesn't make it not true. Excuse the typo. I pressed submit too quickly. I meant to add the word not before true. (I probably need reading glasses it seems. Middle age is not a picnic.) |
UMD is obviously not on this list. And I am not surprised. Are you? |
don't worry about a typo! my nearsight is getting blurry too. agree on middle age lol. |
|
My kid goes To one of these schools and I'm embarrassed by this.
The students are great, the school is great, I don't need people to force this odd categorization. It feels like it's trying too hard. |
Yes, I am surprised as UMD with all the research resources and higher STEM rankings, I would think that it is at least as good if not better than UVA. |
Why do you say that? |
|
Lots of defensiveness from Ivy parents. Don't be. Your kid still has enough privilege and opportunity coming their way. It's ok if there are also numerous hiring execs out there now who prefer other top school graduates because as a whole they are just as smart and capable but appear to be less entitled about opportunities. There's more than enough jobs for strong performing grads from the top 50 or 60-ish schools who have initiative and hustle.
As a hiring manager myself, I wouldn't care if the grad was impressive and went to Emory, Northwestern or Tufts versus Dartmouth, UChicago or Yale. But that's just me. |
The schools aren't doing this. Forbes is doing this, and created this nomenclature 3 years ago. These lists are being celebrated in state press as a win for their states's best schools, and also I saw it mentioned proudly by UF, UVA, Purdue and Vandy in their own school press. Other schools haven't mentioned it yet but all schools should be proud that they are being embraced by employers and better aligned curriculum and career readiness for AI realities. I do agree "new Ivy" is silly term since the term refers to their sports league, not any mark of quality. And I'm old enough to remember the schools in the ivy league that were considered easier to get into in 80s/90s and not as impressive (Cornell, Dartmouth, Penn, Brown). These schools have since come up, as have all the schools on this list. |
You were responding to a post that characterized hiring for all Ivy graduates across all industries. Nobody is saying your anecdote isn't true for your one specific instance, but those of us with kids at both types of schools know that neither is starved for opportunity. They are just different types of opportunity with call it 65% overlap. |
This! Thats really what the hate is about. They seen on ivy privates making strides, like Emory having the number 1 nursing program for 5+ years now. And it makes them nervous. Accolades like that were only reserved for ivy+. Which begs the question which new ivys will be ivy + in the future. |
I actually think Emory is a great school...but other than UPenn (which admittedly has a highly ranked but very small nursing school) and Duke (also very highly rated), what Ivy+ would care about a #1 nursing program? |
Most of the top nursing undergrads will get a higher degree after college like NP or pivot into something else healthcare related. They are not ordinary nursing school graduates. |
I basically agree with the above but when I was referring to +40 I meant in addition to ivy+ and new ivies. We like to see good schools, including state flagships—so maybe 70 to 75 schools fit the bill. As to recruiting, it’s mostly online although we’ve recruited at local schools and, occasionally, schools attended by one of our key principals (all in the 70 to 75 mentioned above). |