Troll |
|
[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Free Christian nation[/quote]
That is self-contradictory[/quote] NP I am a conservative. I am NOT MAGA, as I consider Trump to be in opposition to most conservative positions. I am also a Christian. I agree with the PP that ideally, I would like America to be a free Christian nation. I think the reason that seems self-contradictory is that too often, the media talks about “Christian Nationalists” who want to force everyone to become Christian. I support freedom of religion (including the freedom to be atheistic, agnostic, or otherwise non-religious). In fact, I believe that faith can’t be forced and that God has given everyone free will, so it’s certainly not my place to take ir away. I think the simplest way to explain how America can be both a free nation and a Christian nation is to compare Christianity (for the sake of this discussion) with exercise. I think it is commonly agreed that exercise has many benefits for both an individual (longevity, physical health, mental wellbeing, etc.) and for the larger community (lower health are costs, greater productivity, etc.). Ideally, it would be great if America were a free, physically fit country where everyone (including my couch potato self) exercised according to medical guidelines. Does that mean I’m going to start prioritizing fitness? Not likely. Does it mean I want the government to force anyone (especially me) to start doing daily calisthenics or any other type of exercise? Heck no. While I think it would be great if we all freely chose to exercise, it should be a choice. Similarly, I believe Christianity is something every person needs and would greatly improve their lives. I also think that if everyone freely chose to be Christian and tried to follow the Bible (something I should point out that even the most devout Christians sometimes fail at and many self-professed Christians don’t even try), the Country would be much better off. However, I don’t think a single person should be forced to change their beliefs or how they practice (or don’t) whatever they do believe, much less should it be compelled on a national level. In other words, I think the government’s official policy should be freedom of religion, but that Christians should freely choose to live their lives so that everyone can see the benefits of Christianity (peace, love, hope, etc.) and thus be motivated to choose to follow Christ so they might be similarly blessed. |
|
[quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous][quote=Anonymous]Free Christian nation[/quote]
That is self-contradictory[/quote] NP I am a conservative. I am NOT MAGA, as I consider Trump to be in opposition to most conservative positions. I am also a Christian. I agree with the PP that ideally, I would like America to be a free Christian nation. I think the reason that seems self-contradictory is that too often, the media talks about “Christian Nationalists” who want to force everyone to become Christian. I support freedom of religion (including the freedom to be atheistic, agnostic, or otherwise non-religious). In fact, I believe that faith can’t be forced and that God has given everyone free will, so it’s certainly not my place to take ir away. I think the simplest way to explain how America can be both a free nation and a Christian nation is to compare Christianity (for the sake of this discussion) with exercise. I think it is commonly agreed that exercise has many benefits for both an individual (longevity, physical health, mental wellbeing, etc.) and for the larger community (lower health are costs, greater productivity, etc.). Ideally, it would be great if America were a free, physically fit country where everyone (including my couch potato self) exercised according to medical guidelines. Does that mean I’m going to start prioritizing fitness? Not likely. Does it mean I want the government to force anyone (especially me) to start doing daily calisthenics or any other type of exercise? Heck no. While I think it would be great if we all freely chose to exercise, it should be a choice. Similarly, I believe Christianity is something every person needs and would greatly improve their lives. I also think that if everyone freely chose to be Christian and tried to follow the Bible (something I should point out that even the most devout Christians sometimes fail at and many self-professed Christians don’t even try), the Country would be much better off. However, I don’t think a single person should be forced to change their beliefs or how they practice (or don’t) whatever they do believe, much less should it be compelled on a national level. In other words, I think the government’s official policy should be freedom of religion, but that Christians should freely choose to live their lives so that everyone can see the benefits of Christianity (peace, love, hope, etc.) and thus be motivated to choose to follow Christ so they might be similarly blessed. [/quote] I'm glad you found value in your religion. As far as our country goes, or any nation for that matter, we're much better off as an agnostic nation with a tolerance of all believers from every religious walk of life. Christianity is no more important than any other religion in the world. |
What the heck? The chair of my graduate dept was Muslim. Is that power? I had several Muslim professors (btw this was a STEM field), is that power? What happens if a Muslim police officer stops you for failing to use your turn signal? What about that Muslim surgeon who does your emergency appendectomy? If a Muslim in your workplace is made a manager over you, do you quit? If your town gets flooded and the National Guard comes to help and the commander is Muslim, do you tell them to take their sandbags and leave you alone? I'm just trying to grasp this. Also, do you refer to Christians as "Christian practitioner"? As for "Christian Ideals" every religion, even those that do not include a God in the sense of a creator or a divine person, such as Buddhism or, to take things further, Confucianism, include a Golden Rule principle (love your neighbor as yourself is the New Testament equivalent). To the extent that the US is founded on a religious principle, that would pretty much be it--the idea of human value and dignity. The rest pretty much follows--freedom of conscience, of expression, and so on. That's it. People who do not believe in God, whether they call themselves atheists or agnostics or secular humanists, have no problem believing in the same principle. Even to the extent that the Declaration of Independence does invoke a God (the God of nature, innate rights and dignity which do NOT require Christianity at all), the United States is a system of law. That's it. This system doesn't tell us whether to go to church or not, what to eat, what kind of music to listen to, where to live, what kind of livelihood to have. It simply establishes the framework through which we ultimately decide what laws to make, how to carry them out, and to provide for judges to decide when either there there are disputes how to apply the law (civil matters) or to oversee judgment when one person does not comply with the laws the rest of us, through our system of law-making, have put into place. That's it. All the rest--the anthem, the eagle, the flag, the national holidays--are simply trappings to remind us of that. |
Yes, but as its own nation, no longer as just a colony since patriation of its Constitution in 1982. This is not hard. Canada was not self-determining before 1982, and now it is. When do you think the USA started its history as a nation? Back while we were still a colony of the Brits? Come on. |
Behold the atheist. Got something completely wrong and is now doubling down in the most cringe inducing manner rather than admit a fault. Atheistic morality requires one to string self-serving lies together to preserve your worldview. Thank you for illustrating to anyone on the fence what it will be like if atheists ever take control of. |
| Try pushing LGBTQ in an Islamic country and see how that works out for you. Write back. |
Not that PP, but this thread is about whether people want a Christian nation or a free nation. Sounds like you are against freedom. |
This has nothing to do with the subject of the thread. Stay on topic. |
|
I wouldn't trust these fraudsters to make America a "Christian nation" because they don't believe in or practice the teachings of Christ.
From another thread:
|
Please stop with all of the religious nonsense. If you need religion in your life knock yourself out, but can we create a don’t ask don’t tell for god? |
Can you let the Heritage foundation know? People like Hegseth? And perhaps Trump as he issued the document linked in the first place? THANKS!! |
Nobody is “pushing lgbtq” on anyone. |
Try “not pushing” lgbtq on anyone in an Islamic country. What freedoms you take for granted are entirely dependent upon a Christian heritage. Which brings me back to my original question. What country that was never Christian do you consider free? |
It does, even though you don’t understand why. |