I was in Catholic school in the 80s. Discipline was serious bordering on criminal. Misbehaving kids picked up and physically thrown into hallways or out the front door. Students locked into closets. And things we whispered out later turned out to be true.
Going private? Nope. |
We moved our kids from MCPS to private 2 years ago and haven't looked back. $104k is a big stretch for us, but it's worth it, and this thread only confirms that.
I feel bad for the kids who aren't as lucky. |
I'm not a big defender of private schools, but you are talking about the 80s when this kind of thing was more accepted. Also public schools in the south still allow corporal punishment, and there are stories of misbehaving kids put in closets today in public schools. |
yea, cause Elrich and his progressive minions don't want cops to do their job. |
You think only schools in the south allow corporal punishment? |
Our experience is about the opposite of yours, with an out-of-control public school and a disciplined private. We consider going private the best decision we could make for our family. That’s just our experience, however. You simply can’t make judgments about all schools. |
You get what you vote for. The people whom most of us voted for (I didn't) did the following in an attempt to help poor black and brown kids:
1. Got rid of SROs 2. Instituted Restorative Justice 3. Implemented the 50 percent rule These things actually made things worse especially for the kids they were trying to help...unless they never wanted to help them in the first place. Teachers and parents with means will just leave, leaving behind schools that actually do need help. And these aren't the W schools. |
Yes, for the most part, it's the southern (and red) states. ![]() |
It doesn't matter what Elrich wants. MCPD has an obligation to do their job. |
Those seem like mostly positive changes. Further, all the detentions and suspensions that have been reported here recently mean your narrative is false and misleading. |
NAILED IT! |
You seem to have anger issues and an inability to control yourself. I assure you that you are no better than the lowlifes you complain about. |
Spoken like someone who doesn’t understand the political climate. Elrich and the council absolutely get to determine how much police can do their job. Upthread someone complained police aren’t keeping eyes on bathrooms. They can’t. The new SRO model keeps officers from patrolling schools. That’s on the politicians. It isn’t MCPD failing to do their job. It’s MCPD doing only what they are allowed to do. (If Jawando’s new plan passes, expect everyone on DCUM to be complaining that police aren’t stopping cars for low-level offenses. MCPD will be accused of being lazy, but it’s really the fact politicians are forcing police NOT to act.) This is 100% on the county. If you don’t see that, then you aren’t paying attention. |
You've got your head in the sand. Yes, suspensions and detentions are still happening but not nearly as much as they should be. The idea of RJ is to reduce suspension rates which is forcing schools to do everything possible not to suspend kids even when they need to be. If you think all those were positive changes then tell me what you think is causing the increase in fights, disrespectful behavior, lack of discipline in the schools? Why are teachers wanting to leave the system? |
That's the bottom line here. MCPD is failing our children. |