Millennial men pitched themselves as equal partners. What happened?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Typical dcum thread

Ladies communicate what you want

That's it communication

Wife and I talk through everything and do what works best.

Dh

Ok

I want DH to take control of half the things that need to be done and figure out for himself what needs to be done without me saying what I “want” (what any normal adult would understand needs to be done).

Clear enough?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Typical dcum thread

Ladies communicate what you want

That's it communication

Wife and I talk through everything and do what works best.

Dh

Ok

I want DH to take control of half the things that need to be done and figure out for himself what needs to be done without me saying what I “want” (what any normal adult would understand needs to be done).

Clear enough?

You posting on DCUM doesn't help. If you had this conversation with DH and he doesn't respond just divorce the dud

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Typical dcum thread

Ladies communicate what you want

That's it communication

Wife and I talk through everything and do what works best.

Dh

Ok

I want DH to take control of half the things that need to be done and figure out for himself what needs to be done without me saying what I “want” (what any normal adult would understand needs to be done).

Clear enough?

You posting on DCUM doesn't help. If you had this conversation with DH and he doesn't respond just divorce the dud

You’re missing the point. Prods to just “communicate” are another way of framing “women should be in charge of the administrative tasks and just tell (and remind) men what to do.” How about, instead, men say “don’t forget you need to make lunches for tomorrow.”

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Typical dcum thread

Ladies communicate what you want

That's it communication

Wife and I talk through everything and do what works best.

Dh

Ok

I want DH to take control of half the things that need to be done and figure out for himself what needs to be done without me saying what I “want” (what any normal adult would understand needs to be done).

Clear enough?

You posting on DCUM doesn't help. If you had this conversation with DH and he doesn't respond just divorce the dud

You’re missing the point. Prods to just “communicate” are another way of framing “women should be in charge of the administrative tasks and just tell (and remind) men what to do.” How about, instead, men say “don’t forget you need to make lunches for tomorrow.”

Um no you are complaining on a website vs actually trying to address an issue

[Anonymous]

I see I am late to the convo, but how are they going to be equal partners when they watched their boomer dads do nothing?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I knew my husband would not be equal but I didn’t expect him to be as bad as he is. He really thinks he does a lot too. I love him and he’s important, but I would have less labor if he didn’t live here. I fantasize about a 50/50 custody schedule even though I don’t actually want that at all. I thought he would step up overtime but he’s just lazy and selfish. That’s the truth.

This is so real.

And yes to the part about having more work if I was a single parent. I'm not saying I want to be a single parent -- I love my DH and get emotional value out of our relationship, plus I do think it's better for kids to be in a home with both parents. But my DH is soooooooo lazy. And he would admit it. It's not just about parenting, though yes he's a lazy parent. He won't schedule a doctor's or dentist appointment FOR HIMSELF. He doesn't like ironing, so he just wear wrinkled clothes, and when something absolutely hast to be ironed, he will put it off until the absolute last minute (and sometimes I offer to do it just so it can be done and we can pack a bag or leave the house or whatever).

I don't just do more childcare and housework. I take care of the car, I do maintenance on the house and yard, I plan our vacations, I research and execute all major appliance, furniture, or car purchases, when we move I do all the real estate stuff plus 90% of the packing and executing the move. I make sure we get kid and family photos and make sure they get sent to grandparents. I select gifts for his parents and brother when he puts it off and puts it off. I wrap all gifts. He also offloads most of his wardrobe maintenance to me by simply never buying clothes to replace his clothes once they are falling apart, and then when it's his birthday or Father's Day or Christmas, he just says "I don't know, I need new pants but I'm not sure what." So I wind up buying most of his clothes, figuring out what is in fashion, what goes with what he has, shopping sales, etc. I do our taxes and manage our retirement accounts. AND I do most of the childcare and the housekeeping (I do basically all the cleaning except he occasionally cleans the kitchen, and I'm primary parent for everything from school to drop off/pick up to arranging childcare to bedtimes and meals and hygiene, etc. -- there is no child-related thing that he takes the lead on).

He does none of this for me. He's never booked a vacation for me, he can't even make a reservation for my birthday -- I do it myself because I've learned that otherwise it won't happen. He doesn't buy my clothes or get the oil changed in my car or make sure the yard is taken care of or replace lightbulbs. If I ask him to do these things (and I MUST ask, he will never do them voluntarily), he will put it off indefinitely or complain he doesn't know how or say "you've always done it before, it's easier if you do it this time."

Stuff he does do, he wants like a freaking Purple Heart for it. If I ever complain about any of the above, he'll point out that he goes to the grocery store more, does about half the cooking, and does the laundry about 30% of the time. He also checks our credit card statement each month to make sure there is nothing unauthorized and makes sure that we have the right amount of money in the checking account to pay off the balance. He also occasionally makes me a cup of tea in the morning without me asking for it. I am grateful for all of these things. But it's not half, it's not even close to half. He's just a very lazy person and I pick up all his slack because we're married and have a kid together and him putting crap off or avoiding it just winds ups screwing me over in some other way later.

And people will refer to my DH as "one of the good ones" because they see him hanging out with our kid and being a good dad, he'll mention cleaning or laundry, he seems engaged with our lives. Bu the doesn't actually do this stuff. He's just kind of vaguely taking credit for the enormous amount of stuff I do that makes our lives function, and peopel don't press him on it because why would they, so from the outside our marriage looks egalitarian, but I honestly think my DH does less than my dad did if you add it all up, because my dad was the clear breadwinner (my mom worked but as a nurse and made very little money back then) and he also did all the yard work and anything related to the car. Whereas DH and I both work and make similar amounts and I handle the stuff my dad used to handle plus everything my mom did, too.

I’m male and this sounds like learned helpfulness. Off your list
* car maintenance
* house maintenance
* vacation planning
* major appliance and furniture
* taxes and retirement

Need to be moved to him entirely.

Female here, and agree with learned helplessness. What I would immediately push back in him is anything to do with him - his wardrobe, his parents, etc. His clothes are falling apart - let him figure it out. MIL didn't get flowers for Mothers day - too bad, should have raised her biy better. And so on. Let the world nag him.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I see I am late to the convo, but how are they going to be equal partners when they watched their boomer dads do nothing?

Boomer Dads are the worst. Which is funny since they’re basically the same as the guys in the Greatest Generation who were, by definition, the best. I guess your relative worth to society depends a lot on whether you get the chance to kill Nazis.

[Anonymous]

I have personally known many women I know are so over the top controlling over the kids that the husband just stops even trying to do anything. I have also known several women who flat out refused to rejoin the workforce even when they’d previously agreed with their husband to do so.

Stuff changes when you have kids. You either grow together or you don’t and some of it is society and some of it is personal. You can’t make a broad declaration. That’s why there are so many different views even on this one thread.

[Anonymous]

I’m disgusted by the privileged woman (allegedly an immigrant from a third world country) who posted this BS:

No couple with kids is thinking of doing it alone. Corporate policies and federal policies are very flexible for family requirements. There are generous leave policies and flex work arrangements. Family also pitches in, domestic help is plentiful and organized. No working woman is leaving her job because of lack of childcare - even during the pandemic.

Please, explain to me how you could type such utter rubbish? Am I missing the part where you made it clear this is your pipe dream? MILLIONS of women in the USA were forced to leave the workforce because of lack of childcare in the pandemic and beyond, because there is still a critical shortage of childcare and it is more unaffordable than ever.

I rarely get seriously angry, but reading that absurd declaration made me want to punch the poster, who is clearly so privileged now (immigrant success story, yay!) as to be totally ignorant of the lived experience of millions of American mothers right now.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think it's a few things.

First, as a woman, I am so much more aware than my husband and better at multi-tasking. If I notice something needs to be done, I do it soon because otherwise it takes mental space to remember. Meaning that it is actually less work overall for me to sign up for music lessons instead of discuss it with my husband and wait for him to get to it and remember the deadlien to sign up and then subtly check in with him as we get closer to the deadline because if I ask outright I'm "nagging."

For many things, the easiest thing is just doing it myself. The only way that I've found to split the work is for each of us to 100% own things. I own more than he does though, and it's self fufilling because I am busy so I want things to be done, and I have a lot of things on my plate so I want to manage work myself so I can plan around it. This means I continue to take on more than my fair share.

I think a big piece of it is mental load. I've tried to implement different mechanisms to share it but it's nearly impossible with someone who was socialized without mental load. It's like my brain has a rolling ticker at the bottom of things that need to get done and I can't turn it off.

The mental load is real. My sister’s husband has a diagnosed anxiety disorder, and it comes with its own issues, but part of it is that he wants to be in control of everything, so he deals with all of the crap…arranging childcare, finding music lessons, opening 529’s, getting the leak in the ceiling fixed, planning vacations, figuring out why the dog keeps vomiting, etc.
I had thought this was all BS when other women complained about it because it could be done between other things, but I can’t tell you how much easier parenthood has been for my sister when she doesn’t have to think about all of this stuff. She goes to work, then comes home and plays with her girls. If she has to go out of town, then she tells her husband and he just deals with it.

I mean...I do this... What am I supposed to be doing exactly? I'm going out of town next weekend to see my college friends. I asked my husband about the weekend ahead of time, put it in the joint calendar, and the on Friday I will leave. What else should I be doing before I go?

I don’t know. I would have to figure out childcare or play dates or carpools or something for the time that my husband was at work and not available to do the kid stuff.
My sister’s husband would just figure it out.

I don’t mean to be a jerk here, but it’s not like I am struggling to work full time while I’ve got a partner who is home every evening and takes two days off every week.

I'm the PP. I guess I don't understand why YOU are figuring out childcare or play dates or carpools or something for the time that your husband was at work. Why doesn't he do that? I guess if I were a SAHM and would normally be responsible for the children during the day while my husband worked and I was going to go out of town I could see it being my responsibility to find someone to fill my shoes when I'm gone, but since we both work, we're both responsible for the kids after work. Sure there are times when one of us isn't available because we have to work late, travel for work, etc., but that's when the other person steps up. I just can't imagine being married to someone who doesn't know how to take care of their own children.

[Anonymous]

I say this as a woman who breastfed (for a while): If you do exclusive breastfeeding you are setting yourself up for a "Mom does everything" dynamic from the get-go.

[Anonymous]

OP made the title “millennial men” and then starts talking about doctors & Yale Law School in her post

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I think men DID want equal partners, to be involved with children and egalitarian marriages. But it's just really, really hard. There's so much working against dual working parents.
-school hours are atrocious
-school is basically closed one day a week at least and you need to figure out coverage
-kids are always sick, all winter long
-parenting is extremely hard
-it's very, very difficult to be successful at your job if you left work at 3pm when school ends every day. My boss would have a fit and I'd miss out on lots of meetings.

Dh and I have figured it out and have a nice 40/60 marriage (I'm the 60%), but it's a combo of zero-5 minute commutes, telework, lots of grandparent help, back up nanny and a lot of work.

+1 word for word

Yup. It is hard to have a marriage with two equal partners that also have full careers. Society isn't set up for it. Men want an equal partner, but they also want to have to make any career sacrifices to do that.

We are pretty equal in terms of actual childcare, although still have a pretty gendered split around certain household things, and I'm the one who is always thinking of my kid before myself. Not to a martyr extent - I do prioritize myself too. But if kid and I are both hunger, she gets the snack first (obviously!!!!) whereas my husband often thinks about his own needs before looking around. I find that pretty boggling.

What do you mean by full careers? Our HHI is about $500K from salaries (not investments, real estate, etc.) and we make about the same (it has fluctuated over time and then there are bonuses, benefits, etc., but it's approximately equal). I think we have by far the best set up, and I would choose those over one of us making $500K and the other making nothing every day of the week. We're equal partners on all fronts and we're very happily married with multiple kids. To me, this is the ideal situation, but maybe that's just me.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I knew my husband would not be equal but I didn’t expect him to be as bad as he is. He really thinks he does a lot too. I love him and he’s important, but I would have less labor if he didn’t live here. I fantasize about a 50/50 custody schedule even though I don’t actually want that at all. I thought he would step up overtime but he’s just lazy and selfish. That’s the truth.

This is so real.

And yes to the part about having more work if I was a single parent. I'm not saying I want to be a single parent -- I love my DH and get emotional value out of our relationship, plus I do think it's better for kids to be in a home with both parents. But my DH is soooooooo lazy. And he would admit it. It's not just about parenting, though yes he's a lazy parent. He won't schedule a doctor's or dentist appointment FOR HIMSELF. He doesn't like ironing, so he just wear wrinkled clothes, and when something absolutely hast to be ironed, he will put it off until the absolute last minute (and sometimes I offer to do it just so it can be done and we can pack a bag or leave the house or whatever).

I don't just do more childcare and housework. I take care of the car, I do maintenance on the house and yard, I plan our vacations, I research and execute all major appliance, furniture, or car purchases, when we move I do all the real estate stuff plus 90% of the packing and executing the move. I make sure we get kid and family photos and make sure they get sent to grandparents. I select gifts for his parents and brother when he puts it off and puts it off. I wrap all gifts. He also offloads most of his wardrobe maintenance to me by simply never buying clothes to replace his clothes once they are falling apart, and then when it's his birthday or Father's Day or Christmas, he just says "I don't know, I need new pants but I'm not sure what." So I wind up buying most of his clothes, figuring out what is in fashion, what goes with what he has, shopping sales, etc. I do our taxes and manage our retirement accounts. AND I do most of the childcare and the housekeeping (I do basically all the cleaning except he occasionally cleans the kitchen, and I'm primary parent for everything from school to drop off/pick up to arranging childcare to bedtimes and meals and hygiene, etc. -- there is no child-related thing that he takes the lead on).

He does none of this for me. He's never booked a vacation for me, he can't even make a reservation for my birthday -- I do it myself because I've learned that otherwise it won't happen. He doesn't buy my clothes or get the oil changed in my car or make sure the yard is taken care of or replace lightbulbs. If I ask him to do these things (and I MUST ask, he will never do them voluntarily), he will put it off indefinitely or complain he doesn't know how or say "you've always done it before, it's easier if you do it this time."

Stuff he does do, he wants like a freaking Purple Heart for it. If I ever complain about any of the above, he'll point out that he goes to the grocery store more, does about half the cooking, and does the laundry about 30% of the time. He also checks our credit card statement each month to make sure there is nothing unauthorized and makes sure that we have the right amount of money in the checking account to pay off the balance. He also occasionally makes me a cup of tea in the morning without me asking for it. I am grateful for all of these things. But it's not half, it's not even close to half. He's just a very lazy person and I pick up all his slack because we're married and have a kid together and him putting crap off or avoiding it just winds ups screwing me over in some other way later.

And people will refer to my DH as "one of the good ones" because they see him hanging out with our kid and being a good dad, he'll mention cleaning or laundry, he seems engaged with our lives. Bu the doesn't actually do this stuff. He's just kind of vaguely taking credit for the enormous amount of stuff I do that makes our lives function, and peopel don't press him on it because why would they, so from the outside our marriage looks egalitarian, but I honestly think my DH does less than my dad did if you add it all up, because my dad was the clear breadwinner (my mom worked but as a nurse and made very little money back then) and he also did all the yard work and anything related to the car. Whereas DH and I both work and make similar amounts and I handle the stuff my dad used to handle plus everything my mom did, too.

You husband may be weaponing his incompetence but you are enabling a lot of this behavior.

He doesn't make a doctor or dentist appointment for himself? Then he doesn't go. Let him get cavities, etc. Seriously, you treat him like a child.

YOU want his clothes ironed. Nothing absolute HAS to be ironed, unless he is in the military (which it doesn't sound like he is). So let him wear wrinkled clothes. Or, if you're the one who cares, then do it but acknowledge that you're doing it for yourself.

Pictures are voluntary. Sure, they're important to you, and that's fine, but if you take that task on, again, you need to acknowledge that you're doing it for yourself.

Stop buying gifts for his family. If he doesn't buy them gifts then they don't get gifts. That's not on you. You don't get to take it on and then complain about it. Either do it graciously or not at all.

As for his clothes, he's an adult. If he needs clothes, he will buy them. You spend time figuring out what's "in fashion" and shopping sales for him BECAUSE YOU WANT TO. Stop trying to make these tasks you HAVE to do.

Honestly, you sound like the husband who added "get birth certificate" to his list of tasks.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I have personally known many women I know are so over the top controlling over the kids that the husband just stops even trying to do anything. I have also known several women who flat out refused to rejoin the workforce even when they’d previously agreed with their husband to do so.

Stuff changes when you have kids. You either grow together or you don’t and some of it is society and some of it is personal. You can’t make a broad declaration. That’s why there are so many different views even on this one thread.

I think you aren’t talking about millennials.