would you report a kid who is planning on breaking an ED for a EA school to your private high school?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Report to whom? The high school counselor?

Start there. The ultimate option is reporting to the college.

I'd think twice about reporting it to the college. First off, you have no idea whether it is true or not, high school kids talk crap about each other all of the time. In addition doing so will not benefit your own kid if anything it will harm them and their peers. Colleges generally shut out students from high schools that breach ED, either officially or unofficially so all you will be doing is making harder for your own kid. If you must stick your nose into this situation report it to your high school counseling staff, who frankly as others have pointed out, will have to send transcripts and won't unless there is something that you don't know because it is none of your business.

This.

[Anonymous]

TL: DR of course! A high school just got national attention and blackballed for allowing this. The parents and counselor sign an agreement. There is no equivocation here.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:How can you report something that hasn't happened yet, that's not good, but also none of your business? It may affect kids younger with certain kinds of ED black listing, but it won't affect kids in the kid's grade. This is not for you to report.

1. If what OP is saying is true (aka kid got in to their ED) then it *has* in fact happened because no other apps should be out anymore. They should’ve been pulled.

2. People saying report to colleges are unhinged. If it’s reported to anyone it’s to the school college counselors and let them manage the situation. They will decide next best course of action because if this student breaks their ED, it could affect schools future applicants.

Report anon and no one is the wiser. Why is this so hard?

[eastcoastmom]

Anonymous wrote:This is highly unethical.

Seen a lot of kids EA MIT, at the same time ED an ivy (Penn or Cornell), on top of that, EA Chicago, EA USC. EA MIT is considered a grey area, a loop hole.

Even worse, some kids REA one of HYPS, then ED/EA to an ivy plus at the same time.

In my opinion, their acceptance(s) should be rescinded, both EA/REA and ED acceptance.

You are allowed to apply ED and EA (as long as it is not restrictive EA). I also can't imagine being this involved or concerned about another student's college list.

[Anonymous]

eastcoastmom wrote:

Anonymous wrote:This is highly unethical.

Seen a lot of kids EA MIT, at the same time ED an ivy (Penn or Cornell), on top of that, EA Chicago, EA USC. EA MIT is considered a grey area, a loop hole.

Even worse, some kids REA one of HYPS, then ED/EA to an ivy plus at the same time.

In my opinion, their acceptance(s) should be rescinded, both EA/REA and ED acceptance.

You are allowed to apply ED and EA (as long as it is not restrictive EA). I also can't imagine being this involved or concerned about another student's college list.

I don’t think OPs kid or anyone else at their school (and therefore this thread) would be involved if the kid in question wasn’t running around openly talking about it/bragging about it so… what’s the saying about FA and finding out?

[Anonymous]

1. If what OP is saying is true (aka kid got in to their ED) then it *has* in fact happened because no other apps should be out anymore. They should’ve been pulled.

2. People saying report to colleges are unhinged. If it’s reported to anyone it’s to the school college counselors and let them manage the situation. They will decide next best course of action because if this student breaks their ED, it could affect schools future applicants.

Report anon and no one is the wiser. Why is this so hard?

Why report “anon” if you are certain with the ground truth. Big give away…mark of a spineless coward!

PS: isn’t #1 a large assumption? Did the EA school send you the other candidate’ s acceptance letter?

[Anonymous]

Those who fearfully hide behind the veil of anonymity are the very spineless scumbags who plead the 5th under oath in a court of law stripped naked the whole world to see.

[Anonymous]

I would stay out of it and let the college counselor and the colleges deal with it. That’s their job. There’s nothing to be gained by a parent reporting an ED violation. Parents should focus on their own kids during the application process.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I would stay out of it and let the college counselor and the colleges deal with it. That’s their job. There’s nothing to be gained by a parent reporting an ED violation. Parents should focus on their own kids during the application process.

+1

[Anonymous]

Mind your own business. Nothing good comes of you reporting it, you will be known as the crazy family. Let the school admin deal with it if anything happens. Don’t worry, they will be pissed. The school will likely tighten up next year. Known example this year: Colorado Academy & Tulane

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:As a Director of Admission if a family sent me false and unsubstantiated gossip about another applicant it instantaneously triggers potentially dubious concerns about their child — who unknowingly will garner more inspection under our microscope of evaluation.

Are you a Director of Admissions?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Depending on the timing, you don't even know yet if it will be a violation. If the student gets in to the EA first, then withdraws the ED applicaiton before a decision is made, that's fine.

This is what I've heard numerous time. I really don't understand why people don't find it unethical.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The need to legitimize cheating by some parents here are appalling.

Imagine these people in the workplace.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:MYOB.
There are many reasons why a family would break an ED. If it’s not your own family, it’s not any of your business. The private school will find out.
Why is this even a question? It’s unethical but the reason why the counselors are involved to begin with. Rich people do what they want all the time. It’s not like the entire private will get blacklisted for her for one student.

Yes the rich rely on everyone else following the rules so they can get away with doing whatever they want to do. That’s why the rules were created in the first place.

[Anonymous]

OP, MYOB.