+1 |
Unhooked white kids with 1520 and 1560, took the hardest APs the school offered, almost entirely 5s: I have listed the non-EC because that matters first and foremost. ECs : each had a different art activity they did for over a decade with awards regional/state, each had impactful volunteering outside of school, each had at least one club president, one had substantial school and statewide academic awards, one had local/school academic honors(rare at their school). Both had LOR that they were shown later that indicated best in the year or on one case best in many years. Most of the unhooked peers at their colleges have similar resumes, some a little less, and several friends there are even more impressive. |
+++ yes precisely. one has to have a kid at one of these and a kid at a top public to see the differences |
Thank you for this response. I see the disconnect now. I will reply later with my kid’s profile, and you’ll understand (as I now do) why we have different views of the top UCs and how they are a great fit for kids like mine, and why the Ivy and other Top 10 private are a great fit for your kids. |
| aren't these really just based on things like patents and citations. UVa is pretty weak in graduate level science research. this why places like pitt crush it. |
Laugh. |
Read their actual criteria... |
|
URL for their criteria/method, in the vain hope it will help folks...
"https://www.timeshighereducation.com/world-university-rankings/world-university-rankings-2025-methodology" |
Following up … - Unhooked white kid - Full pay - NMSF/F - Large public HS, consistently ranked as one of Top 100 in the U.S. - 15 AP classes, 6 honors classes, no DE - 13 AP exams, 12x 5, 1x 4 - Varsity team sport, 4 years at Varsity level, 3 year starter, 2x state champion, junior and senior yr. co-captain - Head of two clubs, one related to Varsity team sport and one related to academic interests - Member of 4 other clubs associated with academic and/or volunteer interests - Paid job related to Varsity team sport - Two research internships at local major research university, both in area of academic interests - Unweighted GPA below 25 - 75th percentile range - Weighted GPA barely within 25 - 75th percentile range - Lastly, essays were probably viewed as “very strong” aspects of the application Details that didn’t matter for the UCs: - 1600 on SAT, one-and-done - LORs and counselor report were probably average-to-good, at best, because they tend not to be very impactful in a large public H.S., especially for a male student who doesn’t shine the apple, as they say UCLA and Michigan seek applicants out that look like that ^^^, and the environment at those schools provides a great fit for kids like mine. Your kids sound great, and hopefully the environment in the Ivy and the environment in the other Top 10 private are at least as fulfilling for them. I just know that satisfaction at that level would not have been achievable for my kid. |
OK. I looked at Niche surveys for academics and the top 25 privates do better than Berkeley, UCLA, Michigan, Florida, Texas, UNC, and Virginia. |
Social experience, quality of life, and research budget don’t mean much to you, apparently. Checks out. College is a pre-professional trade school for your kid(s), and I’m sure they are happy, well-adjusted souls. |
If you don't think the above can be had at the top privates, you are the ill-adjusted one. |
I don’t think you understand what I mean by social experience and quality of life. |
you truly do go to extreme lengths to justify paying out of state tuition after the bitter sting of rejection |
I never said that we are OOS … |