I don't disagree. But if the family is going to do that, then she risks being fired once the family realizes she's pregnant anyway. By contrast, approaching this like a professional and presenting a plan up front strikes me as the best way to demonstrate to the family that her pregnancy does not affect either her ability or her commitment to work, and will make her appear more trustworthy and reliable, which I think will go a long way to keeping her job through her pregnancy and hopefully afterwards as well. |
I agree with you only in theory. In reality, however, you must know that most "professional" women do not do that. They are doing what they know is best for them. |
My point is that I think approaching it in a professional, up front way is most likely to have the best result for her long term. At the very least, it will demonstrate to her family that she's committed to working through her pregnancy, and will give the best foundation of trustworthiness and reliability for them to want her to come back after the baby is born. Obviously she is free to take or leave the advice, and she knows her situation better than any of us do, so at the end of the day she's in the best position to gauge what will work best for her. All families and all employers are different so there are some risks with any approach. But as an MB whose been there, and whose nanny took the approach I described, I can tell you that letting her go never crossed my mind, partly because she had clearly thought through exactly how *we* as a team were going to make it work. Also, FWIW, all the "professional" women I know, including myself, basically did something similar when announcing our pregnancies at our own jobs. Taking maternity leave in any workplace is disruptive, and most bosses want the comfort of knowing up front how you'll handle your absence and what your plan is for your return. |
| 14:42, At what point did your nanny tell you and how has everything worked out since then? |
|
She told us right at the start of the second trimester, I think. She presented a full plan when she told me and was extremely professional and thoughtful about the whole thing. She made clear she had already thought through child care arrangements for afterwards. She also made clear that she cared about my child and wanted to come back afterwards but would respect whatever we needed to do.
The only part that was really tough on us was when she was actually on leave and was not her fault at all. It was pretty traumatic for my toddler who had a lot of baby jealousy issues (with babies generally), and we had a very difficult time with inconsistent interim care, which is why I added the caveat that I could see why families might let nannies go. I do feel like those few months were definitely not in my child's best interest. But beyond that, it's been good. There were some inconveniences when she was pregnant, in terms of scheduling, etc., and some inconveniences when she returned because life with kids is like that. But all in all, she's a terrific nanny and she's worth some inconveniences here and there. Also, she's always approached her job in a thoughtful and professional way, so it was easy to believe she'd continue to do so after the baby arrived (as she has). |
So she came back after 8 weeks leave? Paid, not paid? She's still with your child? Who does her childcare? |
She is still with my child. I don't feel comfortable discussing the other details on a public forum but as I have said before, she's a wonderful nanny who we care very much about, and we worked with her as best we could (and she worked with us as best she could too). |
| Bump |
Am curious about nannies who leave behind their own newborns in order to care for child of a more wealthy woman. Presumably she's a nanny because she loves to care for children. Perhaps she feels lucky to at least have her child with her in the US, unlike many other domestic workers here. |
|
I'm a nanny with young kids my own. Honestly, it does hurt to leave your kids and take care of other kids, but this is reality! I'm doin this job so I can feed, dress and put a roof under my precious kids head, and I will do anything I can to secure their future.
|
Are a single parent? How old are your children? At what age did you leave them? Who takes care of them? How do you "secure their future"? I think you're a mb troll, but maybe you can make your story more believable. |
Seriously? Why would you think she's a troll. You can't believe anyone would work to feed their children instead of staying home with them? I'm not the PP, I'm an MB and our nanny has 3 young children of her own. She's a single mother and she is working to support her children. Her mother watches the children during the day. |
How old are her children and how much maternity leave did she take? |
She just started working for us 2 months ago. Her youngest is 2. |
Why didn't you think she's a real nanny? I know a lot of nanny who have small kids, I know 2 single mom/nanny they both take their kids to a close friend for much cheaper daycare, and couple of nanny/mom also with young kids and husbands too who happens to make only minimum wage so the mom/nanny needs to work too. I'm just startled that you actually didn't believed the PP poster to be real.. |