Then you should add whoever is top of NCSL, I mean you are adding Metro. |
No, the level of competition at GA is much higher than NCSL. The average national ranking in Metro's GA conference is 374. Of the teams ranked in ECNL-R for Northern VA the overall National Ranking average is 685. Great Falls and Villareal are not ranked or are at least not accurately listed, but their rankings would likely be worse than 1500 in the nation. You don't have to believe Metro is good, but to say they are no better than NCSL when the team has been successful against significantly higher competition than NCSL or ECNL-R is crazy. |
There is a anti metro troll. I think they have some issue with a coach over there or their kid tried out but was not selected. |
| or a competing coach trying to squash their program here. Metro hasn't been around that long- all these clubs that are bigger and more established "should" be ranked higher than them in theory.... |
Not at all. after Arlington left the GAL there is no real competition, GA fell to the level of EDP, CCL, NCSL, and very close to ECNL-R. |
The rankings average are post Arlington. Arlington 08 finished 3rd in GA last year. They were hardly the anchor of the league or even the age group and as such they got swept in the GA playoffs over the summer. |
Yes and arlington made the playoffs by a last minute goal to beat metro 1-0 at home with a big crowd watching. I saw the match and it was very close. Do not have a connection to either team. In this area ECNL is very similar to GA in terms of quality just with more teams. There are the few tops teams(who basically crush everyone), a few teams a good step below the top teams(lose to the top teams and win/lose by a goal to similar teams) and a bunch of “still developing” teams(lose to mid table and above teams). |
My guess what the poster means is that with Arlington gone from the 08 group, there are really two teams - FCV and SJEB - and the level of competition drops precipitously from there. That means there are a lot of games that FCV and SJEB play that aren't going to be very competitive. FCV is currently 5-0 with a +10 goal differential. SJEB has only played two games, and its only loss was a one goal loss to FCV. At the national level, the top teams of GA are every bit as good as ECNL. But at least for the 08s, the middle of the conference for ECNL is more competitive than the middle of the conference for GA. That said, the middle of the conference for GA is still better than CCL, NCSL and most ECNL-R teams. And, FWIW, Arlington did not get swept in the GA playoffs, they won one and lost two (the second one being to the eventual tournament finalist). |
|
Metro lost to BRYC I think that says enough about GA and to not mention VYS after beating Maryland United shows your ranking is wrong. I would put put
1)Richmond United 2) Pipeline 3) VDA 4) Arlington 5)Loudoun 6) Union 7) VYS 8)Bethesda 9) Maryland United 10)FCV 6-10 can be switched in any position but that's the top 2008 teams in the area if you want to add Metro then here. Somebody is trying really hard to convince everyone that Metro is a top 10 DMV team . . 14. BRYC 15.Metro |
There are teams in lower level leagues that are much better than Metro and many other GA teams. VYS 08, for example, beat Maryland United 08, which beat FCV 08 academy with the score 4-0. I would not be shocked if VYS 08 could do extremely well in GA, if they played there. |
Both of these are better than the above post. Everyone has an opinion however. I would sub out out VYS with Metro, and that is about it. Bethesda and Arlington are a toss up but both are likely better than Arlington. FCV and Union are a toss up as well. Metro is behind both VYS and Maryland United. No way they could beat either of those teams. Everyone also seems to forget about FC Frederick. |
| I meant both are better than Loudoun. |
All those Maryland teams are counterfeit. Pipeline? Lol no. BSC beating Loudoun and Maryland United means nothing. Those three teams are in that bunch of like 7-8 teams that will beat each other but never beat the top teams. Actually Maryland United is is borderline and should not be included. The thing is the top 1 or 2 teams are just in a different league vs the rest of the group. There is little difference between the teams in the rest of the group. Team A will beat team B who will beat team C who will beat team A just depending on the day. VYS, Maryland United and FC Frederick are clearly below the "rest of the group". |
Maryland United beat FCV 4-0 so if you drop them as a borderline, you have to first drop FCV. VYS has a very good team, certainly stronger than Metro and probably stronger than FCV. VDA and Union tied each other so they should be at about the same level. You have to either drop one down or raise another one up in rankings. |
| Its simple people VDA, Richmond, and Pipeline are on a league of their own. Everyone else is a second tier team including Metro and Arlington |