Spring 2017 soccer club tryouts
![[Post New]](/jforum/templates/default/images/icon_minipost_new.gif){kind=icon}
Anonymous
You're right. That one kid disproves all the general studies: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3658407/ http://changingthegameproject.com/is-it-wise-to-specialize/ http://www.usyouthsoccer.org/are_kids_specializing_in_sports_too_early/ https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/04/130423172601.htm There's a recent German study, too. But it's not exactly difficult to find much more evidence. |
Anonymous
I'd wouldn't pay attention to any of the US studies because we suck at soccer. I will say that while the Europeans do specialize---they train less. They limit how much their kids are doing in Academy. At they youngest--2 days per week and around elementary school 3-4 days per week tops. THEY ALSO DO NOT DO THE DUMBSHIT THING OF HAVING KIDS PLAY 4-5 GAMES A WEEK IN TOURNAMENTS. |
Anonymous
The ADP program has some kids with real skill, whose parents may not have the time for Travel - but there are also some moderate players who did not qualify for Travel, but need more of a challenge than simply Rec soccer. There are stories of ADP kids jumping up to a high Travel team after the tryouts, but it is unusual and more often with girls soccer. However, it is common for ADP kids to move to a Travel Team such as Silver and Gold fairly easily. Also, there are other Travel Tryouts in the area not as competitive as Arlington Soccer, such as Alexandria, Vienna, McLean, etc... which have pretty good programs, but harder for carpooling and getting to practices. Best of luck to you and your son. |
Anonymous
But (A) we're very good at sports medicine and psychology, and (B) not all of those studies are U.S. studies. |
Anonymous
| Maybe we suck at soccer because in the U.S. kids are forced to specialize in soccer early. Remember that European academies provide a well-rounded athletic development experience that incorporates track & field-type speed and agility training along with martial arts or gymnastics sometimes, swimming, and even other team sports. And as someone said, the practice-to-game ratio in academies emphasizes training, not tournaments. |
Anonymous
The best athlete in the US do not play soccer. |
Anonymous
|
^^depends how you define that.
Studies have shown in overall fitness a professional soccer player is the most well-rounded and combo. Soccer players do have the best bodies though--can't deny that. Football players are too big, basketball players are too tall, baseball players are dumpy. |
Anonymous
Not PP, but I suspect the point was that the most athletically talented people do not play soccer (they choose instead to develop in or pursue a sport that has a lucrative financial future). |
Anonymous
And the refutation was that soccer players tend to be physically different from other athletes. |
Anonymous
Forbes Releases The World's Highest-Paid Athletes List 2016 Rank Athlete Sport 1 Cristiano Ronaldo Soccer 2 Lionel Messi Soccer 3 LeBron James Basketball 4 Roger Federer Tennis |
Anonymous
You really do not follow sports do you? Odell Beckham He picked football over soccer. 5'11" 195, 40 time 4.43, bench best 225 7 times, vertical 38.5", broad jump 112, 20 yard shuttle 3.94, 60 yards 10.93, etc Champ Bailey 40 time 4.28. Ever try to man up a receiver? Its really hard. Michael Vick Darrell Green Darren Sproles 5'6" 190 lesean mccoy etc sure there are some big guys in the NFL but there are many many great athletes under 6'. NBA is more selective on height, but still many are 6-4 or less. eric bledsoe Ty Lawson Isaiah Thomas Chris Paul Plus a ton more in college. These are strong, fast, quick elite athletes with great visual spatial skills. If US soccer had the same athletic bass to draw on as these sports have the US would be a very dominate power in soccer. |
asksoccernova
Member Offline
Member Offline
|
lol if you have no foot skills and have never manipulated a soccer ball with your foot while someone else is trying to take it away form you, it doesn't matter how great of an athlete you are, unless you are a goalkeeper.
That's like saying soccer players are great endurance athletes, so a few of them would make good basketball players. They have no hand-eye coordination whatsoever if you give them a basketball because they haven't been exposed to it. It takes thousands of hours to develop the foot skills you need at the pro level, starting from a very early age. A great athlete is a great athlete, but athleticism alone with zero skill will get you roasted when you play with skilled players that are average athletes. All you can do is defend, but the ball can always "outrun" players - meaning the ball can always be passed faster and be moved around the field more quickly than anyone can catch up with it. You also have no clue what is happening around you - small group tactics, attacking and defending as a group, and all the techniques involved in striking a moving ball with all the surfaces of your feet. When I was in college, I'd practice and play pick-up soccer indoors in our campus rec center over the winter months when most students were on vacation, and there was always a group of basketball players there who were the best on campus outside of the varsity athletes. They were great athletes, and type A macho guys who had to let everyone know they were the kings of the court. They'd see a few of us doing all these skills with the ball and occasionally one of them would wander over and "try" to play in our game to prove he could dominate, but he would basically embarrass himself and look completely ridiculous trying to control a soccer ball while decked out in full basketball gear, shoes and everything. The first instinct was always toe ball as hard as possible. They were so uncoordinated with the soccer ball, especially trying to juggle. To this day it is one of the funniest things I have ever seen. |
Anonymous
I do love dominating on the bass, but this topic is dead within soccer circles. Discussed to death, and the consensus is that the skill sets and types of athleticism in soccer just aren't the same as they are in other sports. That's not a value judgment -- yes, Champ Bailey was a fantastic athlete, as are most NBA players and most NFL WR/DBs. But they wouldn't necessarily be dominant soccer players. |
Anonymous
Wow, how is this a debate? As a former athlete all the way up through college, I said it former (bad knees) you workout based on your sport. Even within that, you work out based on your position in the sport. Comparing Odell (GO GMEN) to any soccer player is unfair, besides football is probably the most rounded sport in terms of representing athletes. Strength positions, speed positions, and skill positions. But overall, I think soccer athletes are probably more in line with runners or a swimmer. Constantly moving and the only thing that changes is the pace. I tip my hat off to the pros where you don't have unlimited substitutions, that's a variable that no other sport can really touch. Just look at the Flea, he wouldn't look like an elite athlete but will go down as one of best players in the world. |
Anonymous
Soccer is an early specialized sport because of the politics. You don't get fare shakes if you don't run the gambit of club levels unless you are mind blowing good. I force my kids to at least try other sports over the summer and winter, they fight it but they are better athletes because of it. Swimming (life skill) allows them to build endurance and basketball gives them that agility. |