Ok, not Winifred. What about these?

[Anonymous]

Ok, despite triggering my natural contrariness, you have all convinced to come down firmly against Winifred. My goodness.

But we do like that genre of name. I plugged it into Nameberry to see what else we might be overlooking, and these are the “similar names” that appealed to me. Thoughts, suggestions?

Edith
Harriet
Theodora
Minerva
Henrietta

[Anonymous]

Harriet is starting to pop up again. Cute.
Theodora is good.
Not a fan of the others -- actually prefer Winifred (cute nickname options). I didn't read your thread, but I will now so I can enjoy the shade.

Minerva is just awful (and it's a Deftones song)

[Anonymous]

I like Winifred.

[Anonymous]

What is with all the old names? My 12 yr old just heard me rattle off these names, and she said, "They are going to be made fun of".

[Anonymous]

You forgot Bertha and Gertrude.

I understand liking old names, but I’m struggling to understand why you like names that are generally considered unpopular and ugly.

Can you explain what draws you to these names?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:What is with all the old names? My 12 yr old just heard me rattle off these names, and she said, "They are going to be made fun of".

A 12YO would probably name a kid Billie or Shawn

[Anonymous]

What about:

Dorothea
Louisa
Lydia

[Anonymous]

https://wehavekids.com/baby-names/Retro-Cool-Vintage-Baby-Nmes-for-Girls

Try this list.

May I suggest Antonia, Delia or Helene?

[Anonymous]

I like Theodora

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I like Theodora

Hate it. So ugly. Like naming your child Stephena.

Of these, I like that Harriet makes me think of Harriet the Spy. It feels like a name with personality.

I don’t like Minerva, but Minnie is a cute nn.

[Anonymous]

I like Theodora



Hate it. So ugly. Like naming your child Stephena.

Of these, I like that Harriet makes me think of Harriet the Spy. It feels like a name with personality.

I don’t like Minerva, but Minnie is a cute nn.

No. Minnie Mouse. Yuck.

[Anonymous]

These are worse than Winifred.

[Anonymous]

I was one of the Winifred-likers, FYI, and I also considered Edith. Edie is contemporary-sounding and somewhat common these days, esp as a nickname for Eden. So you could have it both ways. And to me Edith is just pretty, in the same vein as Frances or Helen.

Re: Minerva, I have to ask: is this your first kid? I gave one of my kids an outré name and don’t regret it, but I have another kid with SN and am glad it worked out that he got the more popular, generally-liked name; it requires something extra to have to explain or spell an unusual name to people, and you and the kid may not enjoy that every day, in all situations. (I always will remember our roofer, who was not a very polished person, making a really blunt, mean comment about how ugly and odd my child‘s name was in front of him). It’s not Covid friendly, but I like the test of using the potential name at Starbucks to see how it goes.

[Anonymous]

Biker Minnie

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I like Theodora

+1
nn Teddy