This is big. Our condo hasn't appreciated that much -- maybe 8% or so in 10 years. Condo fees have increased modestly. But we now have hundreds of thousands of dollars in equity, our mortgage costs about what rent would have been in our neighborhood 20 years ago, and hour condo is really nice and updated. We would have loved to buy a SFH but our options for our budget were really slim pickings and we would have had to buy a major fixer upper and lived in it for years before we could afford to upgrade it. We also didn't want to spend every weekend working on our house. So we bought a brand new condo instead, the total lack of effort required in maintaining it (no yard, it's small so it's not that expensive to hire people to do whatever work is needed) freed me up to start a side gig that has netted me an extra 20k the last few years, which has gone straight into a house fund (getting a decent rate of return via CDs and a high yield savings account). Now we can buy what we want, where we want. Even if our condo sells for exactly what we paid for it a decade ago. Condos can absolutely be a good investment. It just depends on your specific situation. |
| So much for my plans to become a real estate agent when I get laid off from my niche scientific research contractor role for NIH. |
There is an article in the WSJ today about condos. The issue is you need to buy in a building/area that doesn’t significantly raise condo fees and won’t experience significant capital assessments. Thats easier said than done. The specific case study was a guy buying in Michigan…but even then the article said that 57% of all condos are now selling below their purchase price. |
You are confusing owning your home with owning an investment property. I would probably not buy a condo as an investment. And buying a condo in general is risky, for us it worked better to rent before we bought our townhouse which we love and is our forever home. But I know many people who climbed the property ladder starting with a condo, and it worked well for them and their needs. When the alternative is a tiny, money pit SFH and the condo is in a newer building, it can work. Especially if you re short on time to deal with repairs. |
Except almost nothing works all that well when you sell for less than you paid for it. I don’t understand the logic. If you sell for more than you bought your SFH plus any repairs, that’s likely better than selling a condo for less than you paid and all the maintenance fees and the special assessments you paid as well. I agree a townhouse is probably the best option as I would not imagine you are subject to the special assessments that plague condos…though I guess if you are in a complex with a pool and other amenities then you may need to pay for upgrades to those amenities. |
There are some things you can do to minimize the chances of special assessments and big fee raises: don't buy in a building with a pool (insurance and maintenance are crazy), don't buy in a building that has staff (front desk, mailroom, etc.), buy in a newer building where there shouldn't be big-ticket maintenance items due to age, and buy in a building whose only amenities are ones that you will use regularly. |
Do you not understand that a money pit SFH can be devastating financially? And for many people, the labor required is not worth it. They can still build equity with a condo while living in it. |
Anything that is a money pit is devastating financially…many condos are money pits. People are making recommendations on the type of condo you should buy…same goes for a SFH. Don’t buy a money pit. You make it sound like 90% of SFHs are money pits and 90% of condos won’t substantially raise your condo fees or charge crazy special assessments. |
This is why I think it's not a total downturn. I bought in bethesda for 870k in 2020...comps in my neighborhood are going for 1.2-1.3 ...there is a long way still to drop back to pre covid prices |
No, you are saying it is never worth it to buy a condo, and I am saying it really depends on the individual situation. |
| Kensington prices are coming down. Not by much but it's a downward trend. |
Your subjective opinion is not consistent with the data already discussed in this thread |
You won't build much if any equity on a condo (in a 5-10 year period) given the current interest rates and the fact that condos tend to lose value after adjusting for inflation. At a 7% interest rate, you will only pay off 6% of the loan balance after 5 years and 14% of the loan balance after 10 years. Unless you plan on living in the condo for more than a decade you would likely come out ahead by renting. |
I mean you need to stay in any home a fairly long time to build equity. |
You must be responding to someone else...I never said it's never worth it, but rather it's risky to purchase an asset where 57% decline in value. Here are excerpts from the article: There are a lot of reasons not to buy a condominium these days. Gordon Miller did it anyway. He looked past the homeowners-association dues that are rising across the country, and the special assessments that more buildings are charging for major repairs. He acknowledged that a condo probably wouldn’t appreciate as quickly as a single-family house, and might eventually be tougher to sell. What he found is that there are deals to be had for someone willing to stomach the risks. About 57% of U.S. condos that sold in April went for less than their original asking price, according to real-estate brokerage Redfin. Condo association dues were up 7% in April nationwide this year versus last, and as much as 10% in parts of Florida, but just 3% in Michigan, according to Redfin. After three days of negotiating, Miller agreed with Spencer and Golden on an all-cash deal of $550,000 from an initial listing price of $649,000. “I won’t take a mortgage at today’s rates,” said Miller. The 30-year fixed-rate mortgage recently averaged 6.81%, Freddie Mac said Thursday. Rates can be higher on condos than on single-family homes, and mortgages are harder to get, because lending requirements have become stricter. The mortgage giant Fannie Mae maintains a list of condos that it thinks don’t have adequate property insurance or need to make critical building repairs. Being on the list can make it harder for potential buyers to get a mortgage, The Wall Street Journal has reported. |