Textbooks? lol. |
I'm ok'ish with what's in place now but not at all ok with a total ban. Yes, we should be worried about that! |
Not that poster, but to clarify, that won’t be the rules for students at Wakefield in a couple of weeks when their phones are locked in pouches all day (meanwhile, the other HS kids could use phones at lunch, etc). I agree that phones are a huge distraction, but I think there are better (& cheaper) ways to address this than magnetic pouches. |
My students had electronic textbooks in several of their classes. Why is that funny? |
What is wrong with a total ban? My DS private has a total ban and it’s part of why DD will likely go private in 6th. |
What alternatives do you suggest? |
I don’t understand why some of you think a cell phone ban is a bad thing. Seems like your anxiety talking.
Also, this is a national movement so it’s hilarious to give the credit to a rinky dink parents organization in Arlington. |
+2 And most likely, their parents need some therapy for anxiety as well. I don't want their kid's phone to bring attention to my kid's classroom during a mass shooter event, or a bunch of phones tying up communication lines like 9/11. But mostly, I want kids to learn how to go through a school day/work day without checking their phone every 5 minutes and learning to have dinner out with friends or family without answering texts and phone calls from others, and I want them to LEARN period - that's why they're in school in the first place. |
I think the PP was referring to hard paper physical textbooks which seem to be non-existent or not used anymore. Still, textbooks and phones are two different matters. Textbooks can be accessed on the school laptops - students shouldn't need to provide their own smart phone in order to access the school's curriculum. If teachers want to use apps as part of their curriculum, it should be accesses via the school-issued laptop. Believe it or not, there are actually some students who don't have a smart phone. It's not like having to buy your own notebooks and calculator - those don't incur an ongoing monthly contract/expense for a family and aren't available through back to school supply donation programs. |
Wouldn't the teacher have that access? Like they always have - whether it was yelling for help, using the classroom landline phone, using the intercom, whatever. |
Just because taking pictures of slides is possible doesn't mean it has to be done. It's actually better for their learning to take actual handwritten notes. And they really shouldn't need to take pictures of slides, since teachers could make them available on Canvas/google/email/etc. |
+1000 |
They seem to only be sucking up your air. |
So glad my kid is at Wakefield. |
+3 The parent who posted on AEM re: their child having an emergency meeting with their therapist because they were so worried about the possibility of not having access to their phone in an emergency. Ugh. Meeting with the therapist is the right place for that child to work that out--and I don't mean that in an anxiety or mental health bashing way. Americans are obsessed with the idea that we can create or manufacture safety. My personal opinion is that we've ended up this way because we enjoy relative safety in the U.S. aside from our gun issues, which is a whole other debate and rabbit hole. But it has lead to a generation of Americans who panic and cannot handle any situation that causes them discomfort. I felt the same way during COVID--people couldn't control the virus or the way that their neighbor/city/county/state/country responded to it and freaked out--on both ends of the spectrums. We've lost the ability to tolerate risk and discomfort. If there is an active shooter situation at my child's school of course I would want to be in touch with them, but, would being in touch with them change the outcome of the active shooter situation? No. Of course not. Communicating with your child by phone will not save their life--back to the gun debate.... Kids and parents can save any necessary messaging for outside of school hours. If a child needs an accommodation, fine, but, otherwise, phones should be away. There is no need. |