You sound very ignorant about how Covid often presents itself as very mild or even asymptomatic, especially in kids. Are you kids even in school? If not how would you know that other students are showing up to school visibly ill? IME this area has been pretty responsible overall. |
| What’s going on in Kensington/Bethesda/garret park? I don’t have kids at those schools but live nearby and overall community mask usage is still extremely high- like I was in Safeway in CT Ave the other day and probably 90% of shoppers were masked. |
If this area was that responsible we wouldn't be seeing some of the surges at some MCPS schools and central office. This is why we also need mandatory weekly testing. |
Bethesda and Rockville are not masking that much. Kensington, Wheaton, Silver Spring are masking a lot more. |
Yes, but a lot more can be done to keep them OUT of MCPS. |
You'll never get this. Ever. |
Again, you sound ignorant about the contagiousness and symptoms associated with Covid and somehow after two years think that only if everyone were “more responsible” we could stamp Covid out. Testing is another story and I agree that if the goal were to keep cases as low as possible, there would be mandatory testing for everyone in the community, not just schools. Kind of like what they do in china. But that’s not the public health goal here and never was. |
The only way you would achieve this is daily rapid testing to enter schools. Would still likely miss some asymptomatic cases but you’d have a good chance of catching most symptomatic ones. Have you advocated to the BOE for this? |
DP and I live in Bethesda and that is not my observation at all! I agree as you go further up the pike to Rockville usage dips a bit. |
Some of those schools are in silver spring too. Definitely seems to be a significant down-county outbreak right now. |
Play that out. Set aside the cost and lack of human resources. Suppose MCPS could frequent PCR and/or antibody testing and extended isolation and quarantine periods. You’re still not going to completely keep covid out, but to the extent you can keep that up, you’ll be able to keep some of those cases out of school. Now, we don’t know whether that would actually have an impact on the number of cases in MCPS students, since most of the cases are almost certainly picked up off-campus. But let's ignore that. Then what? You're not going to keep that up forever. At some point you'd have to stop it, and covid is still going to be around. We already have vaccines and therapies are highly effective at preventing serious illness, so this is about as good as it's going to get. |
That's a mischaracterization if the vaccine and you know it. And the treatment is not as widely available as you think. Plus we are seeing more and more long term effects from "mild" cases, even in the vaccinated. I have no interest in getting covid or having my kids get covid. You can take that gamble but I will not. |
Well, you're not going to get the Shanghai Protocol here because it's a fool's errand. Everything else is just window dressing. If you're not going to "take the gamble", it sounds like your kids won't be eligible for parole until they're 18. |
How is that not an accurate characterization of the vaccine? Have you looked at hospitalization and mortality rates between vaccinated/booster and unvaccinated people? They're absolutely highly effective at preventing serious illness. |
So, why not give it a try. Mitigation has been proven to help. Let me guess. You don't want testing as you know at some point your kids will bring it in and you cannot be bothered keeping them at home. |