Lily Collins is too thin in Emily in Paris

[Anonymous]

She looks like a child in some of the scenes, not good.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

Okay.

So, again -- is there any way to bring up that an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- has lost weight to the point of being scarily thin?

[Anonymous]

What's the intended point of bringing it up?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:What's the intended point of bringing it up?

For shaming purposes.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

Okay.

So, again -- is there any way to bring up that an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- has lost weight to the point of being scarily thin?

Who decides what is "scarily thin"? That's not a medical term. The truth is that someone else's weight isn't your business, even if they are a public person. You don't know if she's underweight based on looking on her, and even if you did, you don't know why.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

Okay.

So, again -- is there any way to bring up that an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- has lost weight to the point of being scarily thin?

Who decides what is "scarily thin"? That's not a medical term. The truth is that someone else's weight isn't your business, even if they are a public person. You don't know if she's underweight based on looking on her, and even if you did, you don't know why.

How many times does it need to be said that she is anorexic?
She is anorexic. She has said so.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I have a small frame and have always been thin, and can't stand people like you. I eat a normal amount, work out a normal amount, and have a super fast metabolism. I've spent my whole life getting the "eat a hamburger" comments. Hearing people whisper that I must have an eating disorder. I don't.

Maybe she's perfectly fine. Maybe she's not. But you're not her doctor or her parent, so it's none of your business.

Okay, but Lily Collins does have an eating disorder. It's on record,

Then why talk about it or start a thread about it?

Would we start a thread about what someone should do about their cancer? If she has an ED, that's a disease.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

How many times does it need to be said that she is anorexic?
She is anorexic. She has said so.

Is or was? Is anorexia a condition you have permanently?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:The main differences I notice are her forehead is super wrinkly, like deep lines and her head to neck and shoulder ratio looks like a lollipop. She was very thin 1st season, but she looked healthy. Now, she looks scary. It reminds me of Ali McBeal when she was wasting away and was portrayed as the sexiest thing around.

Also reminds me of Natalie Dwyer from stranger things. She has a similar very concerning look. And it distracted me watching the episodes. This might be because I am hyper vigilant because my younger sister had an eating disorder that was quite serious. She is doing well now though but there is a certain look.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

Okay.

So, again -- is there any way to bring up that an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- has lost weight to the point of being scarily thin?

Who decides what is "scarily thin"? That's not a medical term. The truth is that someone else's weight isn't your business, even if they are a public person. You don't know if she's underweight based on looking on her, and even if you did, you don't know why.

So, it's never to be spoken of. Verboten. Yes?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It sounds like nobody can bring up an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- having lost weight to the point of being scarily thin, ever. As if you are never allowed to point it out.

Is that true? Or how can it be phrased?

Well if you do it for an overweight actress, it's fat shaming.

Okay.

So, again -- is there any way to bring up that an actress -- a public figure in a very public medium -- has lost weight to the point of being scarily thin?

Who decides what is "scarily thin"? That's not a medical term. The truth is that someone else's weight isn't your business, even if they are a public person. You don't know if she's underweight based on looking on her, and even if you did, you don't know why.

Is "she" specific just to Emily Collins, or does it include other people, such as Eugenia Cooney?

[Anonymous]

^^Lily Collins

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The main differences I notice are her forehead is super wrinkly, like deep lines and her head to neck and shoulder ratio looks like a lollipop. She was very thin 1st season, but she looked healthy. Now, she looks scary. It reminds me of Ali McBeal when she was wasting away and was portrayed as the sexiest thing around.

Also reminds me of Natalie Dwyer from stranger things. She has a similar very concerning look. And it distracted me watching the episodes. This might be because I am hyper vigilant because my younger sister had an eating disorder that was quite serious. She is doing well now though but there is a certain look.

Yeah but on that show, her small waist wasn’t the point of the character. Emily’s small waist is the point of the character and really of the whole show. That’s why they have those ridiculous costumes. The show is one step up from Tik Tok Thinspiration.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:She looks like a child in some of the scenes, not good.

No, that's great. She'll look young for a long time and it's nice to see a child-like young women instead of 22 year olds looking like 40-year old escorts.