Many adults died, some had comorbidities, some didn't. |
Funny, I remember when the CDC said wear a mask and everyone celebrated. Then the CDC said, you don't need to wear a mask, and suddenly, the CDC was the great Satan. You aren't interested in mitigations, you are interested in what makes you *feel* safe. |
The initial lying about the fact that N95-level respirator use was clearly needed to reduce the risk of COVID infection (because it is airborne!) was dumb and will go down as a historical embarrassment. I personally celebrated when they admitted they were full of it on that score. (I had already bought and was using an N95 respirator at that point; how you looked at me while I did it or whatever you have to say about it now is of no interest.) I now think they’re idiots and will look like shills for minimizing masking in their public health messaging to individuals still trying to avoid getting COVID. IDK what that all means about my relationship to the CDC. At any rate, it’s not as straightforward as you wish it were. |
|
Not a pandemic. They wouldn’t have allowed unvaccinated hordes to flood over the border if it was an actual pandemic. Total lies and manipulated stats. |
This. I agree with this completely. What's the point in being crazy about a very unique situation - 3 years ago. |
= Trump |
They overwhelmingly (OVERWHELMINGLY) had multiple comorbidities. The claims of "healthy and died of covid" were people who were very out of tune with their health. We did not see healthy people (who had annual wellness exams and passed with flying colors every year) dying of covid. |
DP, but I’m betting MoCo. This level of crazy went on for 2.5 years. We were only allowed to take off masks at the gym in late Spring of 2022 |
The point is to figure out which strategies or approaches were worth it and which weren’t, so we can do a better job if something like this happens again. |
So the World Health Organization was wrong? Three year olds masking except for naps and snacks was a success, and the ones who couldn’t mask correctly were because the adults in their lives failed them? But overall masking preschoolers with pieces of cloth, even through spring 2022 a year after vaccines rolled out, was great public policy? You’re sticking with that logic with everything we know now in almost 2024? Just brilliant. |
DP. That is INSANE. In VA, gyms reopened in early June 2020. Masks were not required at all for working out, but some facilities required them for "walking around" and in the locker room (but it was not enforced). I returned to my gym a few days after they reopened, and it wasn't until August 2023 that I got covid (and it was wayyyy better than getting the flu). No, I'm not a Trumper. Neither were any of my gym friends that returned to work out right away. We were interested in taking care of our overall mental and physical health - covid was not the only health concern (we were low risk 40-somethings). |
I find it concerning that nearly 4 years after the pandemic started whenever someone wants to reasonably question whether certain mitigation efforts were worthwhile in retrospect they still have to caveat the fact they aren’t a Trumper. As a dem, I don’t think it’s a good look for our party that one has to prove they’re not a Republican in order to engage in rational discussion of health policy. |
As a Dem, I think it's concerning that you seem to be of the belief that "rational discussion of health" is not subject to criticism, with regards to Democrat officials and legislators. Many, many Dems effed up in their policy - and knowingly so. Both sides presented a poliarized prescription of how to handle covid, and both were more interested in "winning" rather than present a livable, rational, moderate, and one-size-does-NOT-fit-all approach. |
I don’t think you understood my post at all. I agree that many dems messed up policy and we should absolutely be critiquing the handling of COVID. But I was pointing out the fact that in order to make any sort of critique it feels like you have to disclaim that you’re not a Trumper. I remember when I first started questioning the efficacy of masks for children or continuing to keep schools shut down, I felt like I couldn’t say this stuff out loud IRL or else risk accusations of being MAGA. It’s like scientific questioning somehow became a thing that democrats couldn’t do. And even now in Nov. 2023 someone who is reasonably pointing out that masking in a gym as recently as 2022 was insane has to caveat their post with the fact they aren’t a Trumper because we have come to associate critiquing masking with the far right. |
So, it's fine if you disagree with public health policy, but wrong for me to disagree with public health policy. You must be more of a medical expert than I am. What's your degree in? |