You know it’s true. Talento will happily tell you how it is. |
Yep, when you buy a house in North Arlington, there's a covenant in the deed where the county guarantees your elementary school will never be over a certain % FARMS.
Or maybe at least some of those people bought in those neighborhoods because the houses were nice and the schools were good, and didn't come to understand the broader socioeconomic dynamics of Arlington until they had already bought the house. If people can buy in the Randolph zone without realizing just how much of an impact the high FARMS rate has, is it not possible that NA parents were similarly ignorant about school inequality when they bought, especially if they didn't even have kids yet and were only doing a cursory check on school quality before buying based on things like commute? |
Yes, it would. The problem is the status quo: the belief that SA should stay how it is, so that NA can stay how it is. It's only with that mindset that the PP comment about buyers remorse makes sense. That somehow SA homeowners have no right to buy a house there and agitate for better schools. That somehow, "you get what u pay for." And nothing can change, ever. That's a mindset that makes perfect sense to NA people who paid a premium to avoid socioeconomically integrated schools and perceive SA efforts to have that very thing as underhanded, a short cut, a bail out etc. they think SA parents want the same thing they did and paid for. We don't. We want something different, and frankly, better for everyone. |
| You only buy in SA if you can’t afford NA. Plain and simple truth. |
Yes, you can CHOOSE to leave - like she did - IF you are able; otherwise, being with "your community" is critical and it doesn't matter what south Arlington residents who are not part of "your community" think or feel or are impacted. |
The rest of the county should not have to go through crazy transit gyrations to fix your mistake. |
I firmly believe that I pay the same for my $850-900K house that homeowners in north Arlington pay for their $850-900K house. So I don't buy the rationale behind the argument that you get what you pay for and that North Arlington has paid for "more" or "better." So I guess I simply GET less for my $850-900K because there are so many more rental units and homes that cost so much less in the south; and it's the people living in THOSE homes that are "getting what they paid for." Yet, I don't, merely because I purchased property south of route 50? What NA has actually "bought" is a wealthy homogeneous voice that guarantees they will never have to give-up anything, including their sense of entitlement and superiority. |
For many, but not all. I've spoken with two different new neighbors just this past week who have professed quite the opposite. They both, in fact, specifically chose south Arlington. One of them even specifically targeted one of the high FRL schools, fully aware of the GS ratings. And if people like you making comments such as you did actually took the time to come south and talk to people, you would hear over and over again how they can, but choose not to, or wouldn't even if they could, move to the north. |
And our entire County shouldn't have to keep paying more for you to keep it the way you already have it and want it. And Arlington students shouldn't have to lose out because of their parents' misconceptions, prejudices, narrow-mindedness, and self-centeredness. North kids are missing out, too. |
Plenty of people in NA (myself included) who paid much less than you did. It all depends on when they bought. What I paid doesn't matter. What you expect me to do to validate your housing decision? That matters. |
We are two working parents who bought what we could afford in a nice area that gives us both a short commute. That meant S. Arlington. Now, several years later, we are in a financial position to move North, but we are happily staying put. Perhaps it is because we are minorities, but we feel more comfortable in SA. We value education, but it is not THE defining value in our household. We also emphasize kindness, empathy, hard work, family time, bettering our community, etc. |
Yes. We bought a house in SA for 1.2 million, and budgeted to pay 35K a year for private school for our kids, so we clearly could have afforded NA! Initially we made this choice because we prefer private school, and didn't want to "pay" for the good public schools. BUT I've come to LOVE South Arlington. The Pentagon City area is wonderful, the Whole Foods there is significantly nicer than the one in NA, we are much closer to Alexandria (Del Ray especially but also Old Town), and we still get the advantages Arlington County gives over Alexandria (better parks, good gymnastics program and great swim classes for the kids, good library system). We go to Shirlington all the time, and the dog park. And frankly, I love that our local playground on any random afternoon is up to 50% minority. It's important that my kids get exposure to people of different races and cultures (we are white). We have neighbors in the same position as us. South Arlington is not what it is made out to be on DCUM. |
True for some, not for all. Again, SA people are not all wannabes. I don't want to send my kid to a school where annual December ski vacations and trust funds are normative. |
DP. I assume those parents aren't shouting for APS to provide them with more option schools or busing north of 50 to get away from their high FRL schools. |
Hmm, seems like things like "kindness" would include not engaging in stereotyping and maligning thousands of people you don't know. |