Marshall High School?

[Anonymous]

We are house hunting and hoping to buy in Vienna, feeding into Madison High, but even with a healthy budget of $850k-$900k, none of the homes we are seeing, can we envision as our forever home. So, I have questions about Marshall High School. One person I talked to described it as 'very diverse' and to him that wasn't a good thing. someone else said its 'a lot of military families'. We think diversity is great for our kids, but where we live now, we are the minority, and to be honest, we really don't like it. So, some diversity is great, but not so much we feel like the minority. We are white and Jewish. Will our kids be the only Jewish kids in their classes? Will we like communities feeding into Marshall High? Will we fit in? Thanks for any opinions.

[Anonymous]

The big thing about Marshall is that it is IB. Madison is AP.

What about the house on Hidden Valley?

[Anonymous]

I posted this earlier on another thread. Here is the breakdown from 2015-2016

Ethnicity Marshall Percentage FCPS High School Average
American Indian / Alaska Native 0.3% 0.3%
Asian 17.6% 20.1%
Black/ African American 4.6% 10.3%
Hispanic/ Latino 17.1% 22.6%
Native Hawaiian/ Pacific Islander 0.1% 0.1%
Two or More Races 5.9% 4.7%
White 54.4% 42.0%

[Anonymous]

I'd consider Shouse Village near Wolf Trap. It is zoned for McLean.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:We are house hunting and hoping to buy in Vienna, feeding into Madison High, but even with a healthy budget of $850k-$900k, none of the homes we are seeing, can we envision as our forever home. So, I have questions about Marshall High School. One person I talked to described it as 'very diverse' and to him that wasn't a good thing. someone else said its 'a lot of military families'. We think diversity is great for our kids, but where we live now, we are the minority, and to be honest, we really don't like it. So, some diversity is great, but not so much we feel like the minority. We are white and Jewish. Will our kids be the only Jewish kids in their classes? Will we like communities feeding into Marshall High? Will we fit in? Thanks for any opinions.

This is the real problem. "Forever homes" are a myth and unrealistic fantasies.

[Anonymous]

From what I hear, it's pretty easy to transfer between Marshall and Madison by stating preference for either IB or AP.

[Anonymous]

How about this one

https://www.redfin.com/VA/Vienna/9708-Counsellor-Dr-22181/home/9444691

[Anonymous]

OP, anywhere in Vienna us fine. Marshall, McLean, Madison or Oakton are all great schools. Check out mrishomes.com for realtime listings.

[Anonymous]

https://m.trulia.com/property/3259282571-9977-Stone-Vale-Dr-Vienna-VA-22181

Great area! But only a 4/2 split up top which is hard to resale- at this price just want a 4/3 upstairs- same issue as house on hidden valley in courthouse oaks. Is wait for a 4/3 split upstairs. So much better!

[Anonymous]

OP, we are in a neighborhood that is zoned for Shrevewood/Kilmer/Marshall. My kids are both in Shrevewood now. We are a Jewish family, and there are very few Jewish families at Shrevewood. However, looking at our temple's list of Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, I would say 1/4 or so attend Kilmer, so they are out there sprinkled among the feeder schools. Shrevewood itself is quite diverse.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:https://m.trulia.com/property/3259282571-9977-Stone-Vale-Dr-Vienna-VA-22181

Great area! But only a 4/2 split up top which is hard to resale- at this price just want a 4/3 upstairs- same issue as house on hidden valley in courthouse oaks. Is wait for a 4/3 split upstairs. So much better!

hard to find. We were house hunting last year in Vienna and for $900k -- you get very little. If you can find something that has an actual 2 car garage and updated bathrooms in that price point, you should jump on it. We were opposed to IB, so we were looking only in Madison zone (not that there's anything wrong with IB/Marshall). The ones in the $750 range had closed off kitchens. There was one backing to Flint Hill school that had three baths up, but they were all "original" 1960s baths with 1 in pastel tiles and it sold for $900+ (it had a huge back yard). Another over near the east on Onondio sold for almost $900 with open kitchen, but a 2 car carport and a tiny master bath and one other bath upstairs.

You are looking for something that is very hard to find in Vienna -- 3 baths up. I think there was something like that over off of upper lawyers, but it had a very weird layout. That's usually the trade off... very odd additions if you can find 3 baths up.

[Anonymous]

If you want jewish families, my experience is there is a larger population feeding in to Freedom Hill than any other school in Vienna. I am not sure of the prices.

We are members of TRS and live in NW Vienna, and are very happy with it. But TRS is not a big part of our life any more.

[Anonymous]

My kids are at Marshall. It is diverse, in a good way. We know some Jewish families, but not a single military family. I think that person may have been confused. Most of the military families in the area are concentrated at Lake Braddock and Robinson.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:We are house hunting and hoping to buy in Vienna, feeding into Madison High, but even with a healthy budget of $850k-$900k, none of the homes we are seeing, can we envision as our forever home. So, I have questions about Marshall High School. One person I talked to described it as 'very diverse' and to him that wasn't a good thing. someone else said its 'a lot of military families'. We think diversity is great for our kids, but where we live now, we are the minority, and to be honest, we really don't like it. So, some diversity is great, but not so much we feel like the minority. We are white and Jewish. Will our kids be the only Jewish kids in their classes? Will we like communities feeding into Marshall High? Will we fit in? Thanks for any opinions.

This is the real problem. "Forever homes" are a myth and unrealistic fantasies.

Np. Plus, here, 850K-900K isn't really a "healthy budget."

[Anonymous]

For Marshall You need at least a 1.1 to get a new home in pimmit hills or a used newer home in Dunn loring or Vienna.