FCPS Skyview Boundary Scenario 1/2/3

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All this thread is doing is proving to me that Navy parents live up to their reputation, LOL

Really? They don't seem that annoying to me.

Really? The one mom going on and on about how Crossfield is the reason her kid is getting rezoned to Navy isn't annoying? She's completely ignoring the fact that Oak Hill is getting zoned out of Franklin, and without it, Franklin will be at 80-something percent capacity There's plenty of room for the 2-3 classes of Crossfield kids there. The reason Navy kids are getting rezoned to Rocky Run is because Rocky Run is the primary Chantilly feeder, not because of Crossfield. Anyway, we'll see where Crossfield ends up. Almost everyone I've talked to would prefer to stay at Carson.

Why do you assume its just one mom? Because that position disagrees with yours, and of course everyone else must agree with you?
Crossfield should be Carson--Skyview, based on the map and common sense.

+1

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All this thread is doing is proving to me that Navy parents live up to their reputation, LOL

Really? They don't seem that annoying to me.

+1 all because they don’t want to be rezoned to Rocky Run and then go on to Oakton with hardly any peers? I see. So it’s ok for other schools except crossfield to be split at middle schools.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Just curious, where is the "Walney Oaks" aread and did the "Walney Oaks" area get moved out of Chantilly in any of the scenarios? Or is that the same area as the "rest of Cub Run" everyone is talking about.

Walney Oaks is a rich neighborhood off of Walney Road. They are a natural candidate to be moved to Westfield and they were actually proposed to be moved at the previous boundary changes, but some mom made BFF with Reid at the community meeting. She not only got her neighborhood to stay at Chantilly by misrepresenting how close they are to Chantilly (I seriously doubt they can hear the Chantilly band), but also rezoned from Franklin to Rocky Run

[Anonymous]

Rocky Run is right next to Chantilly. Kids zoned to RR should all go to Chantilly (And I think now they do, except for the AAP kids).

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just curious, where is the "Walney Oaks" aread and did the "Walney Oaks" area get moved out of Chantilly in any of the scenarios? Or is that the same area as the "rest of Cub Run" everyone is talking about.

Walney Oaks is a rich neighborhood off of Walney Road. They are a natural candidate to be moved to Westfield and they were actually proposed to be moved at the previous boundary changes, but some mom made BFF with Reid at the community meeting. She not only got her neighborhood to stay at Chantilly by misrepresenting how close they are to Chantilly (I seriously doubt they can hear the Chantilly band), but also rezoned from Franklin to Rocky Run

What streets are they? just curious about where they are on a map. I guess they didn't get moved in any of the three new scenarios?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just curious, where is the "Walney Oaks" aread and did the "Walney Oaks" area get moved out of Chantilly in any of the scenarios? Or is that the same area as the "rest of Cub Run" everyone is talking about.

Walney Oaks is a rich neighborhood off of Walney Road. They are a natural candidate to be moved to Westfield and they were actually proposed to be moved at the previous boundary changes, but some mom made BFF with Reid at the community meeting. She not only got her neighborhood to stay at Chantilly by misrepresenting how close they are to Chantilly (I seriously doubt they can hear the Chantilly band), but also rezoned from Franklin to Rocky Run

If Westfield needs UMC kids, it makes sense to move this area over.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All this thread is doing is proving to me that Navy parents live up to their reputation, LOL

Really? They don't seem that annoying to me.

Really? The one mom going on and on about how Crossfield is the reason her kid is getting rezoned to Navy isn't annoying? She's completely ignoring the fact that Oak Hill is getting zoned out of Franklin, and without it, Franklin will be at 80-something percent capacity There's plenty of room for the 2-3 classes of Crossfield kids there. The reason Navy kids are getting rezoned to Rocky Run is because Rocky Run is the primary Chantilly feeder, not because of Crossfield. Anyway, we'll see where Crossfield ends up. Almost everyone I've talked to would prefer to stay at Carson.

Most Navy kids go to Oakton, nitwit. So you want Oakton kids to go to a Chantilly feeder school? Ok got it. Why don’t you put your Crossfield kids at Carson which is going to be a Skyview feeder? Same thing. You don’t want to go to a middle school that doesn’t feed to your high school and neither do we.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Rocky Run is right next to Chantilly. Kids zoned to RR should all go to Chantilly (And I think now they do, except for the AAP kids).

Yes but there is one scenario that has Oakton kids feeding into Rocky Run and then back to Oakton.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Just curious, where is the "Walney Oaks" aread and did the "Walney Oaks" area get moved out of Chantilly in any of the scenarios? Or is that the same area as the "rest of Cub Run" everyone is talking about.

Walney Oaks is a rich neighborhood off of Walney Road. They are a natural candidate to be moved to Westfield and they were actually proposed to be moved at the previous boundary changes, but some mom made BFF with Reid at the community meeting. She not only got her neighborhood to stay at Chantilly by misrepresenting how close they are to Chantilly (I seriously doubt they can hear the Chantilly band), but also rezoned from Franklin to Rocky Run

What streets are they? just curious about where they are on a map. I guess they didn't get moved in any of the three new scenarios?

Eagle Chase Circle Dr. area

[Anonymous]

I wonder if Westfield would have enough students to be viable with adding in the balance of Cub Run that should be moved + Walney Oaks. If that's a few hundred kids, it would put them right around 2000.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All this thread is doing is proving to me that Navy parents live up to their reputation, LOL

Really? They don't seem that annoying to me.

Really? The one mom going on and on about how Crossfield is the reason her kid is getting rezoned to Navy isn't annoying? She's completely ignoring the fact that Oak Hill is getting zoned out of Franklin, and without it, Franklin will be at 80-something percent capacity There's plenty of room for the 2-3 classes of Crossfield kids there. The reason Navy kids are getting rezoned to Rocky Run is because Rocky Run is the primary Chantilly feeder, not because of Crossfield. Anyway, we'll see where Crossfield ends up. Almost everyone I've talked to would prefer to stay at Carson.

Most Navy kids go to Oakton, nitwit. So you want Oakton kids to go to a Chantilly feeder school? Ok got it. Why don’t you put your Crossfield kids at Carson which is going to be a Skyview feeder? Same thing. You don’t want to go to a middle school that doesn’t feed to your high school and neither do we.

+1

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Why can’t Oak Hill and Crossfield swap middle schools without impacting other schools?

They could. And perhaps the county saw that as an easy win to resolve a MS split feeder. Inconvenient that it doesn't fit the narrative that this whole mess is Crossfield's fault.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:All this thread is doing is proving to me that Navy parents live up to their reputation, LOL

Really? They don't seem that annoying to me.

Really? The one mom going on and on about how Crossfield is the reason her kid is getting rezoned to Navy isn't annoying? She's completely ignoring the fact that Oak Hill is getting zoned out of Franklin, and without it, Franklin will be at 80-something percent capacity There's plenty of room for the 2-3 classes of Crossfield kids there. The reason Navy kids are getting rezoned to Rocky Run is because Rocky Run is the primary Chantilly feeder, not because of Crossfield. Anyway, we'll see where Crossfield ends up. Almost everyone I've talked to would prefer to stay at Carson.

NP. I don't think this is true about Rocky Run because it's clear with adding Navy kids to Rocky Run, they had to subtract Cabels Mill kids to Liberty. For the same scenario, the Cabels Mill kids are back at Chantilly and half of Navy kids are back at Oakton.

+1 ripple effects, like I said.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Crossfield is nowhere near Franklin MS - why are they getting moved in there in all 3 scenarios??

Crossfield originally fed Franklin before being moved to Carson. The Crossfield boundary is large and for better or worse many MS and HS are clumped in areas that are either West or East.
Carson is 4.9 miles from Crossfield and Franklin is 5 miles. Distance isn't a rationale for one MS over the other so FCPS will look toward the other criteria they have outlined in 8130.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Crossfield is nowhere near Franklin MS - why are they getting moved in there in all 3 scenarios??

Because RIO lobbied for it to try to ensure their kids stayed franklin to oakton. And they have a parent embedded at Gatehouse.

1) look at a map, Franklin makes sense for resolving split feeders, and yes feeding Oakton

2) this is a blatant lie that keeps getting repeated by some troll(s) who is not connected with reality