Thanks for this drill down on dates. |
Can you cite a single example of such a civil action? |
|
The statute in VA is 20 years from date of offense, or 20 years after turning 18, so if she was sexually abused herself, no action is possible at 45, so she could not sue her family if the facts supported it either.
She is responsible for what she has done as an adult. Her husband separating and filing for divorce as her MH deteriorated was the best of bad options to create a more stable situation for the children. It is the course often recommended on here when one parent is mentally ill. He is not responsible for her decline nor her illegal acts. |
PP here. Not disagreeing with what you wrote, but I still think could have accelerated her mental deterioration. |
A farher is perfectly capable of establishing a stable home for his children without bringing in someone else to their home |
What better options did he have? It is likely that she was erratic and acting out sexually (hopefully with adults!) and refusing treatment. So what would you have had him do? Isn't it better for the children that he formed a more stable family unit for them? It does seem likely that as PP have indicated, she has had little contact with the kids in recent years. Are you seriously suggesting that had he stayed in the marriage she would have been a stable person? When her untreated mental illness likely was what ended the marriage? |
There is no indication he was having a relationship with the second wife while married to Hoppe. Why shouldn't he be able to remarry? Y'all are whacked. So if someone is mentally ill and refuses treatment they should basically be able to hold other adults hostage to their illness? It seems better that the childen have 2 stable adults, hopefully they have bonded to their stepmother. Their mother is a pedo and will be in prison for a long time. Another caring adult can not only lend support to the ex-H but also the girls. |
This! You are 100% right! |
That's a very good, and heartbreaking, point. |
| Why do people keep excusing her revolting actions due to mental illness? Maybe she is just warped and evil, no excuses for her. |
|
EHH has a lot of signs of csa, this is all just horrendous and grim. In earlier times she may well have been institutionalized far earlier in her mental decline.
Now, unless someone is an imminent threat to self or others it is true that it is all but impossible to compel an adult to get help or to compel them to remain compliant with treatment. |
It's not an excuse but a likely partial explanation for the hypersexuality and extreme recklessness. Other pieces may be csa she experienced and/or drug use that amplified mental decline and risk taking. And yes, a degree of evil is likely too. Most likely, all of the above. Her decline was well underway by 2018 when the separation occurred. |
That's an interesting perspective on it. How I view it is . . . my brain needs to understand how something so horrible could happen. I don't buy that some people are just "warped and evil." I think some combination of brain development/chemistry and childhood experiences shaped them. Knowing the details helps me feel more calm and in control, like OK, this horrible thing happened, but we can see how she get from A to B. It may be a totally false sense of security in a chaotic world, but I think it's natural to want that touchstone. And to me understanding what caused this in no way excuses what happened. Those are two different issues. There are people who call themselves virtuous pedophiles . . . they are people who no matter what they try cannot help their attraction to children. However, they understand that acting on those feelings would cause harm, so they choose abstinence. Just because something is wrong with you doesn't mean you are exempt from needing to make good choices. My 5th grader's long time BFF has turned very toxic over the last few years. Eventually this led to my DD requesting therapy, and the therapist explaining that something must have happened in BFF's life for her to act out these toxic cycles. My spouse was worried DD would hear that and then feel really bad about ending the relationship, but I said, oh no!!! She is relieved to hear that there is a "reason" that isn't "you didn't try hard enough to be this girl's friend." But it stood out to me that my husband's read on it was the opposite of my DD's and mine. I guess people's personalities play a role. My DD needed to be told that her ex-friend had been hurt in order to understand why she acted so terribly. |
PP here. I in no way implied a relationship between father and new wife when married to Hoppe. |
| Not to go back to an old point but how does responding to a specific picture request confirm that one is “safe” and presumably not LE. I don’t totally understand this. |