window replacement

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:A grand a window, give or take (by a lot). Do you know if you want vinyl, wood, fiberglass, something else?

We just did fiberglass. It was $22k for 19 custom-sized replacement windows (so, pocket install versus full frame tear out). These were 16 double hung and 3 casement windows. We did white on white with cross grids (2x2). Every single custom thing you want to do will raise the price. We were quoted half that for vinyl, but I just really wanted a sleeker look and to be able to paint them if I want. I think aluminum clad wood would have been about $2k a window, but I couldn’t get anyone to give me a quote other than “astronomical.” Although it would have been a grand a window for just a sash replacement with builder grade 1 wood windows. We were replacing our 1960s wood windows. They were just a mess. Install took 3 days and so far I like them more than I thought I would.

DCUM (and all my style blogs) had me convinced I needed divided lite wood windows. It’s possible I did 🤔

So you got SDLs? This is pretty much exactly what we want, but will have two fewer windows. What was the name of the window you went with and what company did the install?

+1 would like to know who you used. Is fiberglass in between wood and vinyl as far as cost and quality?

[Anonymous]

Here's more real data from a recent window purchaser for my new build. We spent roughly 50k for Sierra Pacific wood windows with aluminum cladding. This was for 49 windows... though I'm counting a single unit with 2 or 3 windows as 2 or 3 for this count.

Our smaller double-hungs -- about 37.5 x 64.5 (still fairly sized windows) -- were about 650 each.

We had several BIG double-hungs -- 37.5 x 107.5 -- and they were about 1520 each.

We had some large fixed windows for our stairs -- two windows measuring a total of 82.5 x 119.5 -- for about 3k (for 2 windows totaling that span).

Again, these were all aluminum clad wood windows.

For whatever its worth, based on my experience, the idea of 2k a window seems very, very high. As noted, our really big double hungs--basically 3 foot by 9 foot windows--were only 1500 each. And the smaller windows were a lot less.

Of course, I chose Sierra Pacific aluminum clad because my judgment that it was the best mix of quality and value. I'm sure others may see it differently.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Here's more real data from a recent window purchaser for my new build. We spent roughly 50k for Sierra Pacific wood windows with aluminum cladding. This was for 49 windows... though I'm counting a single unit with 2 or 3 windows as 2 or 3 for this count.

Our smaller double-hungs -- about 37.5 x 64.5 (still fairly sized windows) -- were about 650 each.

We had several BIG double-hungs -- 37.5 x 107.5 -- and they were about 1520 each.

We had some large fixed windows for our stairs -- two windows measuring a total of 82.5 x 119.5 -- for about 3k (for 2 windows totaling that span).

Again, these were all aluminum clad wood windows.

For whatever its worth, based on my experience, the idea of 2k a window seems very, very high. As noted, our really big double hungs--basically 3 foot by 9 foot windows--were only 1500 each. And the smaller windows were a lot less.

Of course, I chose Sierra Pacific aluminum clad because my judgment that it was the best mix of quality and value. I'm sure others may see it differently.

What company did your installation? And would you recommend them?

[Anonymous]

Bumping this chain. Help! Just got quoted close to $3K a window from Andersen Renewal and it feels outrageous. We have a traditional brick colonial home in NW DC and are looking to spend $1500-$2000 per window (or less if thats even possible?!)

Please recommend a specific installer/contractor for windows + line of windows (should we look at Marvin? something else) (we are looking to replace our whole house - 30+ windows - pocket installation (not full frame tear out):

-Fiberglass or Composite Window w/ wood on inside. Higher End (but not top of line). We don't want vinyl, but we don't want all wood exterior either (and have to deal with up keep/painting)
-Single Divided Light/grids on inside out

[Anonymous]

I’m also in the market and would love to hear more on this.

[Anonymous]

Higher End Home Remodeler here. Not in the DC area but similar priced market.

Thought to share some pricing information to help folks understand costs.

I am full service GC not a window replacement contractor.

When we do replacement windows we do full rip and replace.

Usually Clad - usually Marvin although they have had some lead time issues. If client has budget issues will look at some of the Anderson's lines. Try to avoid Pella given issues in the past.

Rough (my) cost for a good Double Hung (DH) window is approximately $1000.00.

Need to add for exterior trim, installation materials and consumables - about $150.00 a window. Again my costs. Figure PVC trim, flashing tape, clapboard for bottom sill, etc.

Installation of window and casing is about $400.00 a window. We screw the window flange and pocket screw the casings. We also screw the interior jamb liner so that the foam insulation does not push the window out of plumb.

Add for an Exterior Crown Window Head - add $100.00 plus another $100.00 for copper drip flashing. I don't do aluminum and when we crown our heads we hip them so our flashings have to be hipped as well.

We prefer to add a backband to our casings - that's another $75.00 - $ 100.00 per window.

Then add for siding materials, repair and paint.

Then we have to case the interior - sometimes one piece - we prefer two (easier to customize to existing conditions) - plus sill and apron. That's another $150.00-$200.00

Depending upon whether the interiors came pre-finished we have to paint the interior casing and/or the interior of the window. We usually go wider with the new trim then the existing interior trim so that we are not forced to paint the walls.

Have to demo out and depose of windows - figure $100.00 a window.

Add $ 100.00 per floor to the above.

Add $ 150.00 for a double.

So my number for a rip and replace window is an easy $3000.00 a window more often $3,600.00.

My clients usually understand that their time, money, and energy are spent on doing it right.

Not everyone needs this level of work nor this level of window but these are my numbers for this level of work so I thought to share.

Thought to share a couple of photos of a finished install.

[Anonymous]

Simonton is great for price.

BTW my old house previous owner did top of line most expensive Anderson wood windows in 1991. Most expensive possible.

In porch area also 1992 which was unheated he did the cheapest possibly crappy vinyl windows.

When I sold in 2018 the vinyl window all warped and barely opened the Anderson’s were perfect.

But remember the Anderson cost double to triple. Cheap crap ones last 25 years. Top of line 50 plus years.

It is a long payback. My old owner actually had receipt for a single huge Anderson window he paid $6,000 for in 1991. That was one window in 1991 that was price of a new Chevy

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Here's more real data from a recent window purchaser for my new build. We spent roughly 50k for Sierra Pacific wood windows with aluminum cladding. This was for 49 windows... though I'm counting a single unit with 2 or 3 windows as 2 or 3 for this count.

Our smaller double-hungs -- about 37.5 x 64.5 (still fairly sized windows) -- were about 650 each.

We had several BIG double-hungs -- 37.5 x 107.5 -- and they were about 1520 each.

We had some large fixed windows for our stairs -- two windows measuring a total of 82.5 x 119.5 -- for about 3k (for 2 windows totaling that span).

Again, these were all aluminum clad wood windows.

For whatever its worth, based on my experience, the idea of 2k a window seems very, very high. As noted, our really big double hungs--basically 3 foot by 9 foot windows--were only 1500 each. And the smaller windows were a lot less.

Of course, I chose Sierra Pacific aluminum clad because my judgment that it was the best mix of quality and value. I'm sure others may see it differently.

Most people aren't doing custom builds at that price. You weren't worried about cost.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Simonton is great for price.

BTW my old house previous owner did top of line most expensive Anderson wood windows in 1991. Most expensive possible.

In porch area also 1992 which was unheated he did the cheapest possibly crappy vinyl windows.

When I sold in 2018 the vinyl window all warped and barely opened the Anderson’s were perfect.

But remember the Anderson cost double to triple. Cheap crap ones last 25 years. Top of line 50 plus years.

It is a long payback. My old owner actually had receipt for a single huge Anderson window he paid $6,000 for in 1991. That was one window in 1991 that was price of a new Chevy

Was it a huge house as we didn't spend that much and we used a mix of Marvin and cheaper windows.

Our cheap vinyl have held up just as well as our Marvin windows.

[Anonymous]

Thank you all - how about windows that are replacement windows that are pocket installs v full frame ? Are those less than the full frame ?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Higher End Home Remodeler here. Not in the DC area but similar priced market.

Thought to share some pricing information to help folks understand costs.

I am full service GC not a window replacement contractor.

When we do replacement windows we do full rip and replace.

Usually Clad - usually Marvin although they have had some lead time issues. If client has budget issues will look at some of the Anderson's lines. Try to avoid Pella given issues in the past.

Rough (my) cost for a good Double Hung (DH) window is approximately $1000.00.

Need to add for exterior trim, installation materials and consumables - about $150.00 a window. Again my costs. Figure PVC trim, flashing tape, clapboard for bottom sill, etc.

Installation of window and casing is about $400.00 a window. We screw the window flange and pocket screw the casings. We also screw the interior jamb liner so that the foam insulation does not push the window out of plumb.

Add for an Exterior Crown Window Head - add $100.00 plus another $100.00 for copper drip flashing. I don't do aluminum and when we crown our heads we hip them so our flashings have to be hipped as well.

We prefer to add a backband to our casings - that's another $75.00 - $ 100.00 per window.

Then add for siding materials, repair and paint.

Then we have to case the interior - sometimes one piece - we prefer two (easier to customize to existing conditions) - plus sill and apron. That's another $150.00-$200.00

Depending upon whether the interiors came pre-finished we have to paint the interior casing and/or the interior of the window. We usually go wider with the new trim then the existing interior trim so that we are not forced to paint the walls.

Have to demo out and depose of windows - figure $100.00 a window.

Add $ 100.00 per floor to the above.

Add $ 150.00 for a double.

So my number for a rip and replace window is an easy $3000.00 a window more often $3,600.00.

My clients usually understand that their time, money, and energy are spent on doing it right.

Not everyone needs this level of work nor this level of window but these are my numbers for this level of work so I thought to share.

Thought to share a couple of photos of a finished install.

You are really marking up material costs. We DIY'ed our windows and have fancier trim and spent nothing like you are saying. We replaced both the inside/outside trim, repaired the damage/rot, etc.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Thank you all - how about windows that are replacement windows that are pocket installs v full frame ? Are those less than the full frame ?

Do full frame, pockets are hard to get a good tight fit. Just make sure they remove the interior trim before measuring or you will not get accurate measurements.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Bumping this chain. Help! Just got quoted close to $3K a window from Andersen Renewal and it feels outrageous. We have a traditional brick colonial home in NW DC and are looking to spend $1500-$2000 per window (or less if thats even possible?!)

Please recommend a specific installer/contractor for windows + line of windows (should we look at Marvin? something else) (we are looking to replace our whole house - 30+ windows - pocket installation (not full frame tear out):

-Fiberglass or Composite Window w/ wood on inside. Higher End (but not top of line). We don't want vinyl, but we don't want all wood exterior either (and have to deal with up keep/painting)
-Single Divided Light/grids on inside out

They are one of the most expensive companies. Do a full frame vs. pocket as its an easier install and a better window. Look at Anderson from Home Depot or Lowes. You can custom order them in store and then get someone to install them. You might be able to find a handy person. They aren't hard to do.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Do yourself a favor and do a full new construction window rather than replacement. Replacement windows look horrible and make the glass opening smaller.

Who has that kind of money? It doubles your cost, easily.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Bumping this chain. Help! Just got quoted close to $3K a window from Andersen Renewal and it feels outrageous. We have a traditional brick colonial home in NW DC and are looking to spend $1500-$2000 per window (or less if thats even possible?!)

Please recommend a specific installer/contractor for windows + line of windows (should we look at Marvin? something else) (we are looking to replace our whole house - 30+ windows - pocket installation (not full frame tear out):

-Fiberglass or Composite Window w/ wood on inside. Higher End (but not top of line). We don't want vinyl, but we don't want all wood exterior either (and have to deal with up keep/painting)
-Single Divided Light/grids on inside out

They are one of the most expensive companies. Do a full frame vs. pocket as its an easier install and a better window. Look at Anderson from Home Depot or Lowes. You can custom order them in store and then get someone to install them. You might be able to find a handy person. They aren't hard to do.

You can get a high quality vinyl with SDLs for 1500 a window installed, maybe a little less. Ours look great. We were quoted over 2500 per window for what you want and comparing them side by side it wasn’t worth it for us.