Obama thinks platitudes like this will raise his popularity. It will - with those who don't think things through and simply react to how it feels. I think Tubman deserves honoring, but not at the expense of another individual. In fact, re-writing history like this is foolish. As a Jew, I don't want Hitler forgotten - I want his photo everywhere. I want youth to know who he was and what happened, as if they don't, his evil deeds will be minimized and they WILL occur again. Liberals wanting all visual signs of slave-owners purged in the name of feeling good are risking youth not caring that slavery occurred at all. What, you say? They will teach it in the schools? It will mean NOTHING to these kids - they are simply too far away from it. Being offended is a very, VERY important life-lesson. If you've never been offended or been faced with something offensive, you have no idea how NOT to offend others. |
What do you expect from this president. A decision NOT based on his 'cool factor' and how people view him? Consider one of his 'esteemed' WH guests had is ANKLE BRACELET GO OFF while visiting. Why did this guest HAVE an ankle bracelet you ask? He pistol-whipped a contractor doing work on his home, and would not let him leave, leading to an additional charge of kidnapping. What a GREAT GUY to have in the WH, don't you think? |
This exactly. I was one of the advocates for Harriet Tubman in the thread discussion from last year. The ridiculous PP you are trying to educate is not worth it. The Underground Railroad and Harriet Tubman have been taught in schools for decades. The Underground Railroad is part of American mythos. |
(Also a Jew) But would you really want Hitler to be prominently featured on the most popular bill in the treasury? One you'd get several of every time you go to the ATM? One you'd handle every day of your life? I sure wouldn't. I want the face of my country represented, with people who changed history and laws in our country for the better. Of course that includes our founding fathers. But it also includes many, many women and people of color who aren't taught about as much in school. FWIW, I'm a raging liberal, and I think the expunging of the names of slave owners and other people who have questionable history (beyond the good they did for our country) is ridiculous. And Alexander Hamilton, who was saved from being taken off of the $10, was a slave owner. |
As I understand it, Jacksons ownership of slaves is not the real issue with him - it's one of many. He also was the reason behind the Trail of Tears. Another piece of history you should have learned about in grade school. |
So you want that to be erased from history as well? I don't. |
Yes, I do. Why? Because look what happened with September 11th. What happened was not forgotten, but WHY has been whitewashed to the point where it's now OUR fault, according to liberals. WE provoked it. So yes, I want Hitler in everyone's face, ALL THE TIME. |
Yeah, no, sorry if I wasn't clear with that. Hamilton's slave ownership was a response to the assertion that liberals want all slave owners stricken from history; I was showing proof that that's not necessarily true. I know very well about Andrew Jackson and the Trail of Tears, but thanks for throwing shade on my education. |
Yeah, well, the parties kund of flipped positions many decades ago, such that the GOP is the racist party. |
Who are all of these liberals who are whitewashing 9/11? Again, raging liberal here, who recognizes 9/11 as an act of terrorism in the name of a form of Islam. (But I don't think that all Muslims are terrorists, nor are all terrorists Muslim. Is that the "whitewashing" you're talking about?) Also, I have to believe that you're hyperbolizing about plastering Hitler all over the place, especially on government-issued currency. That kind of reverence and reference is usually for people we want to celebrate. |
Also, I believe he's still going to be on the back of the bill, so not "expunged from history." |
Jackson will still appear on the $20, but on the back.
I'm an Oklahoman and therefore think of Jackson as a genocidal Indian remover. |
Black women much respect. |
I don't understand this idea that updating the bill to reflect current values and notions of who should be honored is expunging or erasing history. Especially since Tubman is a part of this very same history that people are worried will be expunged? Very odd. Sounds like an excuse to maintain status quo me. |
+1 |