But the point is that from Latin there are no kids going to Ivies or UVA or William and Mary! |
Wow. You are not a very nice person. It's fine to set high goals for your kids. Why disparage the choices or outcomes for other people's kids? |
| I think Latin should just post this list internally or only on their website in the future if it's not more impressive. |
|
I see a lot of schools that are close to DMV and travel cost/proximity to home could likely be a factor
Excellent article on challenges of higher education for students growing up in poverty. Even Emory, an elite school which makes a strong push to both attract and retain such students, still finds mixed results. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/23/education/poor-students-struggle-as-class-plays-a-greater-role-in-success.html |
|
Graduating Latin parent here.. Our child came from a small, east coast HS (Latin) and did not want to apply to many excellent schools that were large scale or geographical far flung. Not one CA school was on the list even though some were courting our child aggressively. We, and Latin's excellent guidance counselor, respected and supported our child's wishes. Its her journey. Students from this class are approaching $4,000,000 in financial aid grants.
Our family is upper.middle class fwiw. We consider our childs Latin education a privilege. Our child chose not to.go to private school for HS. The relationships - will be lifelong friendships now- with more than a.dozen teachers and an amazing, lovable group of peers. Priceless. I dont think you have any idea what navigating adolescence is like. We are so grateful for the Latin support team delivering our child health, whole, hopeful to the finish line of HS. Ps. To the nice neighbor, thank you for the warm welcome.and keeping an eye out. We ? you. |
I think this point cannot be made enough times. The top state schools offer little to no aid to out-of-state students, no matter what their color, level of income, or achievements. Michigan, Berkeley, UCLA, UNC, UVA, Texas, Florida, etc., have plenty of low-income students in their own states; they look to OOS students to pay full freight. Also recall that first generation college students often don't want to go that far from home (or family), so they have additional concerns driving their decision-making relative to other students. Also recall that this is a very small class in an urban open-enrollment high school. As noted above, there are plenty of lower-income students at Latin, but remember that SAT scores are highly correlated with family income. So there might be only a handful of students who have the test scores to even make it through the first round of consideration at the elite schools. (Sure, elite schools practice affirmative action, but if you think non-athlete minorities are admitted without good SAT scores, you are dead wrong. They might not have stellar SAT scores; but they definitely have good ones.) Few of these students will be legacies or elite athletes, so they won't have those hooks. The reality is that children of well-off, highly educated parents are likely to do comparatively well in the college game whether they go to Latin or Walls or Sidwell. The children of lower-income, less-educated parents are likely to get a big boost by going to Sidwell. Unfortunately, they aren't likely to get there. The same, BTW, is true of college. Children of well-off, highly educated parents are likely to do comparatively well in life whether they go to Denison or Hampshire or Harvard. The children of lower-income, less-educated parents are likely to get a big boost in life by going to Harvard. And again, they aren't likely to get there. Remember this when you are wringing your hands about your children's future. Perspective, please. |
Yorktown's acceptance list has never looked anything like this...those folks would have burned the Arlington school board office to the ground. |
Since I happen to have access to Washington-Lee's naviance, I can tell you what the Ivy admissions were like in another Arlington high school in 2014. Class size somewhere around 500. Harvard--2 out of 14 applicants (Harvard actually has admitted a stunning 19% of applicants from W-L in the last 8 years; I assume that means W-L grads have done well there) Yale--0/9 Princeton--0/15 Brown--1/17 Dartmouth--0/6 Columbia--1/19 Penn--2/15 Cornell--3/19 Assuming that many of these applications are from the same kids, I'd say something like 20-25 W-L students out of 500 are applying to Ivy League schools, and maybe 3? of them are accepted. 3/500. (FTR, Yorktown has not dissimilar results.) So does that put the Latin acceptances in perspective? |
No it does not. How do things look in the tier below Ivies? That's what really seems to be missing from the Latin acceptance list. |
The school has had FOUR graduating classes. Come on people. Also, I went to one of these "low tier" schools and did just fine. It wasn't about prestige for me. It was about affordability. I put myself through school. I am now very successful in my career and make a lot more than my Duke, Harvard, Yale friends. |
What I think people don't understand is that many of these parents that select Latin, are not running TO Latin as much as they are running AWAY from Ballou, Anacostia, Coolidge, etc. They want their child to have a shot at doing something better. Latin has some students that can't seem to get out of their environment even while at school. Many do not have stellar GPAs and they have behavior issues. They try not to suspend or even expell these students (although they have done this), because with the child in school, at least they are safe and not out on the streets in their neighborhood doing who knows what. This is not and most likely never will have the college acceptances of an application high school as long as they are open to the city, and students peel off after 8th grade (more potential for 9th graders that come from "those wards"). Latin has the curriculum and the tools in place for students to be accepted into Ivies. I'm sure there are a number of students whose transcripts look just like a student from Walls, but maybe just decided not to apply to an Ivy or Top school for whatever reason. |
| PP here^^ Also, no matter how good the college couselor is, I know for a fact they will not be able to convince my DD to apply to a school she has no interest in attending (even if it is Ivy). As a parent, I also would not MAKE her apply. |
DC also has application high schools, at least two of them competitive (SWW and Banneker). It's not a simple dichotomy between neighborhood public schools, charters, or private for high school even if that's largely the case for middle school outside of Deal. |
^^^ and enrollment is 30% higher for Latin middle school than high school |
Doesn't Banneker have similar demographics (i.e., race and poverty). Why do their students get MUCH better results? |