This is a plausible argument. We noted several students in nephews "prep" school who got "shut out" and ended up going to Alabama and Elon. |
| SMU |
|
Bard
Carlton Earlham Grinnell Lawrence |
Carlton is already hot and Bard, for a certain kind of student. I would add Scripps, Muhlenberg, Skidmore, Occidental. |
That's pretty useless. What are they supposed to do? Take their coding classes at community college over the summer? It would be more useful. |
You don't work in high visibility high value tech do you? My sister went to a top 3 lac, majored in math/cs (barely can code) but she's already involved heavily in high visibility teams at one of the biggest tech firms on the planet. Coders are a dime a dozen in the valley or seattle. In fact devs and tests are routinely faced with the job axe or their work is outsourced/parceled up to cheap coders anywhere on the planet. What is important is the ability to think like a computer scientist/mathematician when analyzing problems and thinking of new products. |
| We moved from New York a few years ago, and my DH and I will strongly consider some of the NY public universities for our children, one of whom is in middle school and the other a rising HS sophomore. Particularly Binghamton University, which is highly selective and ranked and less than 5 hours drive, and Stony Brook University, which has a great science and pre-med program. I think both of these universities will gain more of a national reputation as they get better in sports (sad that sometimes that is what it takes) and people realize their value relative to private tuition even as out of state residents. |
| I think the next "hot" college is not a college but a different trend for society to obsess over and feel they need the "best" to be the "best". I think people are so sick of USNWR rankings and obsessing over colleges. Soon no one will care what college you went to at all. It is making high school students and their parents crazy and people are overspending on certain colleges. There will be something else in life to rank themselves against everyone else with. In the past few decades it has been colleges, houses, neighborhoods, kitchens and bathrooms. Pick the next trend for people to get worked up about trying to seek some sort of perfection. |
Rich people problems. Seriously? |
It is not just rich people. The middle class is driving themselves into debt trying to keep up with what is perceived as the good life. |
Elon has long been over, so was not impressed. Many of the Nescac's my sons advisor is saying are suddenly more popular than ever (f they are looking for a top education in a small school). Oberlin also has seen a rise in apps. Also University of Texas- Austin seems to be a popular school these days. |
Ah, no. |
| It's Carleton not Carlton |
College is more important than ever. Now not graduating from college is like not graduating from high school used to be. Don't kid yourself. |
I agree that there a multiple routes to a successful career. Going to a top college is one of them. |