a girl classmate called DS gay

Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:It's an insult -- if she had called him a freak or a creep, that would be an insult too. Surely by 4th grade, he has figured out how to respond to insults to make them stop without running to the teacher every time -- whether that's making a comment back, not reacting so the insulter gets bored and moves on etc. So tell him to do what he'd normally do.

I'm not sure that going down the -- but being gay is so awesome road -- is really needed here.


No one said "but being gay is so awesome." But it is very important that kids know that "gay" should not be used as an insult. It's an irresponsible if you like it's no big deal to say that. It is a big deal and it needs to be discouraged.


Eek. Sorry for being illegible! It's irresponsible if you act like it's no big deal.
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:
Anonymous wrote:I would be less concerned with reporting it thanby making sure DS knows that "gay" is not an insult and anyone who thinks it is is mistaken.


+1



Parent of two middle school boys here.

You are both dead wrong. It is most definitely used as an insult by kids. Now you can live in a PC world where that isn't true, but watch out for the unicorns and other fantasy creatures in that world. In the real world, when a kid tells another "you are gay", it is meant as an insult. A different discussion could be "should" it be used as an insult, but that is not what you've said. Now, depending on the context, it is very likely such a minor insult as to be completely unworthy of a response. But lets not pretend that it was not meant as an insult of some kind. It was. A fourth grader is old enough to tell when someone has insulted him. So "making sure DS knows that "gay" is not an insult" is an exercise is trying to convince him that what he actually knows, he does not know.


PP, I get what you mean, but the takeaway is "son, being gay is an insult" and son hears being gay is bad, wrong, etc. Suicide is the leading cause of death for LGBTQ kids. Don't feed it. In case OP's DS is testing his mom with this incident, she should make sure son knows he is loved and supported.


Do you have a source for that? Suicide is the second leading cause of death for all teens. With accidents being the first. I haven't seen any sources that show that isn't true for LGB+ kids. Interested in your research findings.


What may differ here between straight and LGBTQ teens is bullying by peers and rejection by relatives. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suicide_among_LGBT_youth
post reply Forum Index » Elementary School-Aged Kids
Message Quick Reply
Go to: