Nah, they won’t make RM IB smaller! They’ll keep it the same size and let more Wooton and Churchill kids in. |
Of course they will loosen the criteria and water down the programs, but my point is RMIB and the new Wootton STEM programs won't be watered down as much, compared to Blair SMCS if the class size remains the same. For Blair SMCS, the fact that there was no draw from waitlist in the past two years means that there are barely any turned-down offer from Whitman, BCC, or Einstein. Since BCC IB is currently strong and is on the track to become stronger when becoming regional, and it's closer to Whitman, my bet is those families from Whitman that claim they do not want to even give it a try to Blair SMCS will feel more appealing to try BCC-IB in the future. Blair SMCS might attract more Einstein students in the future per se. |
I think my point is the regional model on the long run would bring benefit to the social-economically wealthy regions/schools, and cause more harms to social-economically poorer regions/schools. |
More than half the students at Blair SMCS are from Wooton, Churchill, and WJ. And Blair is really overcrowded. MCPS might use this an excuse to shave seats off the Blair program. That way they can move staff to new SMCS at Wooton, so the Wooton and Churchill kids can still get the benefits of the Blair program’s depth of experience, but closer to home. |
And this is how you dismantle Blair's magnet, a program that has stood among the best in the nation, until Thomas Taylor showed up to say that Blair is inequitable. I had a BOE member say to my face that Blair is hoarding programs. Blair's magnet and CAP were developed to attract high-achieving students to the school, to turn it around from the lowest performing school in MCPS back in the 1980s. It was all about real equity. Blair teachers developed these programs - there weren't bureaucrats with no curriculum experience from the school district office involved. Blair will remain too big after its boundaries are adjusted, and soon, it will likely be overcrowded again. And it will slide down in achievement, lose its best teachers, and Blair will be back where it began after awhile. So much for equity. Thanks Thomas Taylor. |
The Bethesda Mag opinion piece in Aug contained good links, including an MCPS report for IB and AP data as of Feb 2025. Comparing RMIB vs. 3 regionals, in summary, RMIB has >95% of students with mean scores >5, while the 3 regional IBs have low numbers of students "passing" and has mean scores <4 (ie, NOT passing). It's not just IB. Similar trends in the AP data, with only notable exception of Spanish Lang (if I remember correctly). Additionally, the 3 regional IB schools offer fewer selection of AP classes/exams. So if a student wants IB (or AP), it's no wonder students choose RMIB over the regionals. So this "proxy" data indicates that this is likely our future with the regional model. TT, NHP, JF all claim that the regional IBs haven't had a fair shake yet and blame RMIB for its underenrollment. JF also said that IB teacher training has been the same. It's too bad they are blind to their own data. |
They're not blind to their own data. They're just dishonest and liars and don't want to be held accountable to facts or data. |
Yes. So sick of their bs. |
| The regional magnet model is a good one. Y’all are tearing it down before it has even begun. |
+1 |
It is really bad for the kids in the DCC and NEC. They lose choice, programs are being downgraded from consortium-wide to local, at the same time, some of those schools are losing hundreds of students to boundary changes. That will mean staff and budget cuts. |
This is a pale statement without any elaboration of your justification or situation awareness. Please show me that I'm wrong. |
You mean, some of those absurdly overcrowded schools will finally be able to fit all their students inside their buildings. |
You mean, hundreds of students will be forced out of some of the most popular schools in the county, and cut off from choice and programs they've enjoyed for decades. |
| Where’s the evidence the regional magnet will work? There are decades of evidence that Blair is one of the best STEM programs in the country. Guess it doesn’t matter. |