Shall we show out all of the results from that election or those you don’t like? Shall we also throw out I-83 because it similarly failed to attract votes from a majority of registered voters? There was nothing else on that ballot - other than uncontested candidates - that attracted such overwhelming support from those who voted in the election. But it is funny that you apparently think very highly of yourself for concocting an argument that is not only stupid but could be used to delegitimize almost any election result in the country. |
Setting policy based on the whim of 28 percent of the voting population is absurd, and a recipe for bad policy. I guess you're fine with Anita Bonds, then? She wins with like 15 percent of the vote. |
Another false claim that can be quickly debunked by browsing the biographies of the members. Maybe it would be good to have more council members with deeper private sector experience. That is not for you or I to decide, however. If you feel passionately about this and you have the experience you feel is so important for the council, please mount a campaign. But you might want to consider developing a closer relationship with the truth before doing so. |
You debunked your own argument. Thanks. |
You mean the same Council that is composed of members that attracted only 15% of the vote (and even smaller proportion of registered voters)? Your logic would invalidate the vast majority of election results in this country, including the presidency. Please try to put a little more thought into your posts. |
Why is our restaurant industry so messed up compared to the places in the world where tipping is not a thing? |
Tipping has been a thing in the United States since the Civil War. If your plan to raise wages for waiters turns on getting rid of a 165-year old custom, you need a better, non-stupid plan. |
Because our system was built on tips, whereas they were not in the US. It makes a difference when restaurants are doing their business planning. |
Special interest groups love ballot initiatives. It's a way for them to get changes in the law that elected leaders would never ever approve. They take some complicated issue and they turn it into a question of whether you love or hate puppies. They carpet bomb with advertisements saying that if you love puppies, then you support their dumb idea, even if it doesn't actually have anything to do with puppies. They always want to do it in an election where few people turn out so that their supporters represent a huge share of the electorate. 50 people show up to vote, they all say they love puppies and then it turns out that two years later, all the restaurants are closing because it turns out the ballot initiative didn't do what they promised. |
Let's review a few facts, shall we? 133,000 DC residents voted in favor of I-82. In the same election, Muriel Bowser won the same proportion of the vote running against an Independent, a Republican, and a Libertarian. Other than the mayor or the Chairperson, I-82 won more votes than anyone or anything else on the ballot - more than Anita Bonds or Kenyan McDuffie. This was a hardly a novel issue. I-77, which DC voters approved in 2018, concerned the same question. The issue had been discussed ad nauseum in the four years between that result and the I-82 vote. It's also an issue that personally affects everyone who would eat a meal at a DC establishment. You can complain as much as you want about the wisdom of the majority of voters, but those who showed up to vote on I-82 in November 2022 were about as well-informed about anything they were asked to vote on at the municipal level. Your issue doesn't thus seem to concern the results of I-82 as it does basic tenets of democracy. |
People who peddle restaurant industry talking points won't tell you this, but seven states - Alaska, California, Minnesota, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, and Washington and one territory - Guam - require employers to pay tipped employees full state minimum wage before tips (https://www.dol.gov/agencies/whd/state/minimum-wage/tipped). And across the US, the share of restaurant worker earnings that come from tips is steadily declining (https://www.adpresearch.com/the-shrinking-value-of-tips/). Research on the effects of increases of the tipped minimum wage finds that they increase worker earnings while having no significant effects on employment (https://irle.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/10/Tipped-Wage-Effects-on-Earnings-and-Employment-in-Full-Service-Restaurants.pdf) The implementation of the tipped minimum wage seems to predominantly benefit low-wage workers. As of 2018, waitstaff earned on average just $0.36 above the legal minimum wage (https://www.epi.org/blog/seven-facts-about-tipped-workers-and-the-tipped-minimum-wage/). |
Ummm. DC nonprofit/attorney/consultant/community organizing is not the same thing as the private sector… Have any of the Council ever have to make payroll, order inventory, pay rent, build something? Nope. They’re all unimpressive white collar, barely employable hacks. |
People are so well informed that even today, years later, they still have no idea whether they're supposed to still tip. Ballot initiatives are a sleazy business. A bunch of lies foisted on informed voters by special interest groups. |
I thought I-82 ended tipping. wasn't that one of the goals |
You have a very special idea of what the phrase “private sector” means, one that accords with no conventional definition. If you have done these things and think that your expertise would add value to Council business, please run. |