Are Mormons Christians?

[Anonymous]

I am an active Mormon and am not really that concerned with being labeled a Christian. I know that I focus my life on Christ and try to follow His commandments. I know what I am taught at church and read in the scriptures, including the Bible (as a church, we are studying the Old Testament this year.)
I consider myself a devout follower of Christ and find others in my religion to be the same. I really don’t care what others call me.

I have a good friend, who is extremely active in her mainline Protestant church. She often asks me if Mormons celebrate Easter (yes, but we don’t follow Holy Week traditions) or seemed surprised by all the pictures of Christ in the Temple or asks if I’ve ever heard about a parable Jesus taught. I think she’s subtly and maybe unconsciously questioning my “Christianity.” I find it odd because she doesn’t believe in the resurrection of Christ or in an afterlife, which seems far more against biblical Christianity than the belief in the trinity.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If your definition of Christian is some who believes in a follows Christ, then yes. It’s even in their name - The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints

As a former Mormon, l can tell in you practise there is equal emphasis and time spent on the Bible and Book of Mormon in Sunday school etc

The name was created for marketing/PR purposes, to normalize the religion.

Definition of a Christian is a member of the mainstream Christian churches, one who is able to recognize a member from another denomination as also a Christian.
Such a person can visit and attend service in any church and be seen as a fellow believer.
Mormons do not see a Lutheran or an episcopalian as a fellow believer, but as a mission field that needs to be converted.

Once you add the belief that only members of your church are people who will be saved
then you are too exclusionary

This definition is new to me. I grew up in Texas and met many, many evangelicals who did not see Catholics as Christians. I remember in 1999 when a lot of them were told by their church that Y2K was the end times, girls I played basketball with "laying hands" on me and weeping and praying that I would accept Jesus and be saved by the blood of the lamb so I wouldn't have to burn in hell forever, as I was clearly destined to do. So I guess Assemblies of God, Church of Christ, and Pentecostal aren't Christian either? Or is it that Catholic isn't Christian?

I'm not convinced this question means anything in the first instance. If you say a Mormon is not Christian, and they say they are, you don't "win." And we know that they say they are Christian, so what's the point of trying to prove they aren't?

You hang around with weird people
Pentecostals do recognize people in other denominations as Christians.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:No, they are a religion of their own, more like a cult

This would be a matter of opinion/perspective, right? Because that could be said about all religions. Are Mormons not deserving of the same respect as Lutherans or other religions, including non-Abrahamic ones?

so same for scientologists?

Assuming you are the PP, answer the question, because it is in response to your post. Then, if you want to ask me my position, I'll be happy to share it in return.

ok, no I think they Mormons history, how it was founded, makes them seem a bit dubious to me in relation to Lutheranism (presumably founded by Martin Luther).

So it is a matter of personal position then? That each of us can decide which beliefs are worthy of respect, and which are not?

If that's your position, great, we agree completely.

And now to answer your question, as I promised, WRT scientology: I do think the "history, how it was founded, makes them seem a bit dubious to me". And I also think that about Mormons. I also think that about Lutherans, Catholics, Muslims, Pagans, Shinto, Rastafarianism, etc etc. All faiths which have a supernatural foundation, "seem a bit dubious to me".

But if it is demanded that we show respect to certain religious beliefs, shouldn't we show respect them all? Shouldn't we not call any of them "cults"?

Supernatural?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If your definition of Christian is some who believes in a follows Christ, then yes. It’s even in their name - The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints

As a former Mormon, l can tell in you practise there is equal emphasis and time spent on the Bible and Book of Mormon in Sunday school etc

The name was created for marketing/PR purposes, to normalize the religion.

Definition of a Christian is a member of the mainstream Christian churches, one who is able to recognize a member from another denomination as also a Christian.
Such a person can visit and attend service in any church and be seen as a fellow believer.
Mormons do not see a Lutheran or an episcopalian as a fellow believer, but as a mission field that needs to be converted.

Once you add the belief that only members of your church are people who will be saved
then you are too exclusionary

This definition is new to me. I grew up in Texas and met many, many evangelicals who did not see Catholics as Christians. I remember in 1999 when a lot of them were told by their church that Y2K was the end times, girls I played basketball with "laying hands" on me and weeping and praying that I would accept Jesus and be saved by the blood of the lamb so I wouldn't have to burn in hell forever, as I was clearly destined to do. So I guess Assemblies of God, Church of Christ, and Pentecostal aren't Christian either? Or is it that Catholic isn't Christian?

I'm not convinced this question means anything in the first instance. If you say a Mormon is not Christian, and they say they are, you don't "win." And we know that they say they are Christian, so what's the point of trying to prove they aren't?

You hang around with weird people
Pentecostals do recognize people in other denominations as Christians.

I agree that evangelicals are weird, but they are still Christian, even though they don't recognize Catholics as such. Same as Mormons. You evidently don't recognize Mormons as Christians so wouldn't you be excluded from the definition of Christianity using your own convoluted terms?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I'm agnostic, and I think all religions are cults, but in terms of personal integrity and behavior the Mormons I have known have been some of the nicest, most honest, hardest-working people I've come across. I've worked in organizations where, at the end of the day, people of one religion definitely displayed favoritism towards others of the same religion (I guess because of a shared belief they are "God's chosen"), and that's not been the case with Mormons.

So if they want to call themselves Christians, that's fine by me.

Is it ok if we call you a Christian since I'm sure you're nice, honest and hard working too?

That's not how it works. See?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:If your definition of Christian is some who believes in a follows Christ, then yes. It’s even in their name - The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints

As a former Mormon, l can tell in you practise there is equal emphasis and time spent on the Bible and Book of Mormon in Sunday school etc

The name was created for marketing/PR purposes, to normalize the religion.

Definition of a Christian is a member of the mainstream Christian churches, one who is able to recognize a member from another denomination as also a Christian.
Such a person can visit and attend service in any church and be seen as a fellow believer.
Mormons do not see a Lutheran or an episcopalian as a fellow believer, but as a mission field that needs to be converted.

Once you add the belief that only members of your church are people who will be saved
then you are too exclusionary

This definition is new to me. I grew up in Texas and met many, many evangelicals who did not see Catholics as Christians. I remember in 1999 when a lot of them were told by their church that Y2K was the end times, girls I played basketball with "laying hands" on me and weeping and praying that I would accept Jesus and be saved by the blood of the lamb so I wouldn't have to burn in hell forever, as I was clearly destined to do. So I guess Assemblies of God, Church of Christ, and Pentecostal aren't Christian either? Or is it that Catholic isn't Christian?

I'm not convinced this question means anything in the first instance. If you say a Mormon is not Christian, and they say they are, you don't "win." And we know that they say they are Christian, so what's the point of trying to prove they aren't?

You hang around with weird people
Pentecostals do recognize people in other denominations as Christians.

I agree that evangelicals are weird, but they are still Christian, even though they don't recognize Catholics as such. Same as Mormons. You evidently don't recognize Mormons as Christians so wouldn't you be excluded from the definition of Christianity using your own convoluted terms?

You sound bitter
Protestant churches are evangelical and they do recognize Catholics as Christian. Catholics differ on allowing priest’s to marry, penance

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:The correct name of the religion is: Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints

so that sounds pretty Christian to me.

Jim Jones and all the other cults sounded like great Christian places as well. Just because an institution claims the name "Christian" or "Christ" does not mean that its members are Christians. A sucker is born each day. Cults are manipulative and have a way of luring people in. Somehow Church of Satanic Demons will drive people away. So, cults have to utilize a catchy marketing name to attract misguided people into their camp.

Mormonism is a cult. It was founded by a delusional white supremacist. Their teachings do not align with the historical roots of Christianity or Jesus Christ for that matter. Mormonism was created for the preservation of whiteness. They do not follow the teachings of Christ, but the teachings of Joseph Smith. Also, this cult was created in the United States. Last time I checked the historical and geographical origins of Christianity are not in the United States.

Their teachings contradict the fundamental elements which align with Christians and Christianity. Mormonism is cult. Heck, now they send their young adult children all over the world on missions to convince the folks in impoverished communities to join them. Whenever I witness this I step in and rescue these people. The Mormons incessant need to manipulate and prey on people solidifies them as a cult. This is a growing problem that needs to be dealt with. Mormons are vultures who prey on the weak.

I am an advocate for those who leave cults. I have counseled many people over the years who had left the cult of Mormonism.

Mormons are not Christians!

Mormon church is not protestant, catholic or orthodox
Mormons do not recognize believers in any of those denominations as fellow believers

therefore they are not

Let's get real - Catholics don't recognize other religions as equal to them. Or JWs, or Adventists, or pretty much any religion.

However, I'm concerned if Mormons don't believe that the only way to heaven is through faith in Jesus. I'm not feeling the reliance on a husband bit. That's anti-biblical

It’s completely anti-biblical. Joseph Smith only made Mormonism Christian-adjacent to make it more palatable to potential followers. End of story.

[Anonymous]

Remember that most mainline Protestant Churches invite Catholics to take communion—so clearly they consider Catholics as fellow Christians.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:Remember that most mainline Protestant Churches invite Catholics to take communion—so clearly they consider Catholics as fellow Christians.

The other religion-bashing threads are pretty quiet so you thought you’d try to resurrect (pun intended) this thread bashing everybody’s favorite target, Mormons?

[Anonymous]

Who cares really if Mormons constitute Christians per se. We generally know their beliefs. Bible + Book of Mormon. Is what it is. We should just focus on ourselves.

[Anonymous]

I’m an Interfaith Minister. Reality check- The only person who gets to decide whether or not they want to identify as a Christian, a follower of Christ - is that individual person. Not the religion. Not the church. Not a religious leader. It’s a personal relationship. If someone calls themselves a Christian, I believe them.

That said, I know an awful lot of evangelical “Christians” who are nothing like the Christ they claim to follow. The LDS people I know are certainly more Christ-like than any southern baptist I’ve ever met. Including clergy.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Remember that most mainline Protestant Churches invite Catholics to take communion—so clearly they consider Catholics as fellow Christians.

The other religion-bashing threads are pretty quiet so you thought you’d try to resurrect (pun intended) this thread bashing everybody’s favorite target, Mormons?

Yeah, the trolling “my friend’s grandson committed suicide and her faith is waning” and “missionaries do TERRIBLE things but I am not saying what TERRIBLE things they do!” thread is at a standstill. Time to call the Mormons a cult.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I’m an Interfaith Minister. Reality check- The only person who gets to decide whether or not they want to identify as a Christian, a follower of Christ - is that individual person. Not the religion. Not the church. Not a religious leader. It’s a personal relationship. If someone calls themselves a Christian, I believe them.

That said, I know an awful lot of evangelical “Christians” who are nothing like the Christ they claim to follow. The LDS people I know are certainly more Christ-like than any southern baptist I’ve ever met. Including clergy.

Actually, this is decided by the Christian or Heretic Religious Intersectional Tribunal. They decide if a particular person or faith qualifies as Christian. Updates from the weekly Thursday meetings are posted on their website.

[Anonymous]

When I was a practicing Christian (Lutheran ELCA) the general feeling was absolutely not.

Now that I'm non-practicing I don't really think it matters much. But I do think of Mormons as a cult more than a religion.

[Anonymous]

No - Greek Orthodox here.