They are shrinking all the option programs that over capacity. When neighborhood school enrollment went up and those schools got too crowded, APS forced the option schools to add kindergarten spots to up their enrollment as well. It was the right call, but now they are allowing the option schools to go back down. Claremont is way over capacity, and the reduced number of kindergarten spots will help that. If there is demand for a 3rd Immersion program, they should offer that, not up over-enroll the 2 current schools. I think they should offer Immersion at all the under enrolled schools to see what happens. Ex: offer a Spanish speaking classroom at Drew or Discovery and see what happens. |
They can! Through boundary adjustments. Which is exactly what is being discussed here. |
They need to hire competent staff and make the boundary changes with NO public input. Honestly, it's ridiculous how the loudest/whiniest people get listened to in this county. Make the moves that MAKE SENSE not the moves that result in the least amount of crying at a school board meeting. |
Just to be clear, the K classes at option schools are always at maximum enrollment per APS numbers, unlike neighborhood schools which often have smaller class number based on the split of students. The decrease was from 6 K classes to 4 K classes. The actual class sizes are larger than ever given the class size increase that APS put through last year. |
They could have gotten the bigger McKinley building if they weren’t so busy trying not to move. |
This is not accurate. From APS's initial presentations for Glebe posted October 2020: 2019-20 PreK-5 Capacity Utilization 113% (including 4 existing relocatables 95%) Estimated 2021-22 PreK-5 Capacity Utilization 128% (including 4 existing relocatables 108%) Estimated 2023-24 PreK-5 Capacity Utilization 122% (including 4 existing relocatables 103%) The same presentation references that one planning unit already assigned to Glebe could be designated walkable to Reed (and eventually was designated as such) so that would have further alleviated pressure at Glebe and made sense from a transportation perspective. The process wasn't allowed to play out in any way that made sense. It was just immediate freak outs and APS shut the whole thing down. |
What happens also is mainly the people within the school community who perceive they are negatively impacted by a proposal pay attention and freak out. So those people are represented by the school PTAs (which they dominate) as "the community" when often really it's just one neighborhood or block of planning units that doesn't want to get moved somewhere. Their voice takes on a very outsized part of the conversation and they are taken seriously. It's a ridiculous process. |
Those numbers are the second iteration after APS realized their mistake and walked back their proposal somewhat. The initial version from APS was worse. It never made it into school board slides, but was DCUM fodder. |
So some terrible first proposal that APS circulated widely but then buried which pre-dated their stated public engagement time window? When the entire process and everything having to do with is exhaustively laid out on their website. https://www.apsva.us/engage/fall2020elementaryboundaries/ |
These numbers aren't the original APS proposal. Glebe is one of four elemtary schools in APS that is over capacity even with the COVID decrease in enrollment. APS wasn't proposing to move any kids out, only busing many more kids to Glebe. APS may have designated part of the Glebe zone as walkable to Cardinal, but APS wasn't going to move any kids there. Cardinal was already full in the APS plan. Those kids were staying at Glebe and have stayed at Glebe. The question was whether Glebe was going to pick up a chunk of McKinley (keeping all of their existing students and despite already being overcrowded) so Nottingham students could attend Cardinal, leaving Nottingham significantly over enrolled. |
*Nottingham under enrolled. |
It takes 5 mins to get from Nottingham/tuckahoe to ATS. |
Also, there's no reason ATS (or any other option school) needs to continue to exist. If you choose an option school you get what you get in terms of location. |
Thanks to trusty Waze:
Pentagon City to Discovery - 18 min Pentagon City to Nottingham - 17 min Pentagon City to Tuckahoe - 16 min Pentagon City to ATS (current location) 16 min |
So the way the process works is APS puts out an original proposal and then always tweaks it. It's a starting point, not the end point. Cardinal was not full in the initial APS plan. It was only pretty near full by the end when APS went with the option of putting nearly all of McKinley at Cardinal (minus the 3 planning units that went to Ashlawn plus and the one Tuckahoe unit that got the option to attend). There could have been plenty of room in a sensible world to move some of those Glebe kids to Cardinal and move Madison Manor to Tuckahoe instead of Cardinal. That probably would have made a lot of sense in terms of continuing to bus kids that were already bused and maximize walks and even out enrollment. BUT....the point is people FREAK OUT at the first proposal that yes, might affect their school or them personally negatively. So yes, the Glebe parents freaked out and the Ashlawn parents freaked out and some of the former McKinley parents freaked out. Oh and the Tuckahoe and Nottingham parents freaked out with threats they would be option schools once left under enrolled. It's a lot of self-involved freaking out. |