Not really. She just wouldn't have our parents trying to control her as an adult, which I'm sure you would feel the same. She's what used to be called strong-willed or what DCUMErs now call their kids CEO's in training. Fortunately fo all of us our parents idea of parenting wasn't based on control and rigidity. My sister is also a pretty cool person. I'm sure her tendency to question everything drove our parents nuts, but that little pain in the ass grew into a badass with an awesome career that's saving lives by constantly questioning a pushing back against norms. |
Then you described her incorrectly. An inability to follow a family rule with the defiance you described is classic oppositional disorder. We are all “controlled” in society by laws, morals, and cooperation. To take such a strong stance (as you described) is more than strong willed. It’s childish and hurts only her. NP here. And my parenting isn’t based on control. It’s based on cooperation and respect. I was raised the same. I defied my parents wishes when I joined the Peace Corp at 22 and again by moving to Scotland after graduate school. But when I was being supported by them thru college, I definitely followed their rules and respected them. No sex in the house and no tattoos or piercing. Not hard or too much to ask of us. |
Eh... no. Anyone who would pass up a full ride college scholarship because she wanted her nose pierced is about as far from a CEO in training as one could get! |
She definitely doesn't have ODD. She just wouldn't stand to be told what she could wear or do with her own body at the age of 21 because mom and dad didn't like it. Great if it works for you and your compliant kids, it won't work for every child. So the classic DCUM adiivce of just take away money doesn't apply to every person and a person refusing to fall for it doesn't have ODD. |
If said person had a full-ride scholarship why would mommy and daddy be paying for school? I'd say it's more idiotic for parents to attempt to derail their child's education over something sa benign as a nose piercing. |
I can't decide on what's more pathetic your parents being upset about you joining the Peace Corps and moving to Scotland or that you at 40 + years of age thinking those things are some big act of defiance. I guess those are terrible things for conservatives though lol. |
This the type of more critical thinking and reasoning that results from such controlling parenting. Just because someone gets a nose piercing doesn't mean they are scofflaws. As for my example, I said she would have moved out and done XYZ, Don't set the standard of if you live here you do what I want, and then get upset when someone takes that to heart and moves out and does what they want. |
Stop, PP. Clearly no one is talking about a 21 year old. And you’re confusing respect, maturity and consideration with your silly dig of “compliant. Stop embarrassing yourself now. |
| And crazy sister-worshipper has taken over the thread. |
😂😂😂 |
Yeah - I thought we were discussing tweens/ teens and what body piercings they get? |
This. It's something stupid that young adults / teens do to be "rebellious." My rules are they have to be 18, pay for it themselves, and deal with the consequences. Most people get tired of the extra piercings eventually and let them go. I remember when it was super trendy to get tongue piercing in the late 90s. How many 40 year olds do you see with that now? My friend got so many ear piercings that her baby grabbed an earring and was able to rip through her ear, and she then had to have plastic surgery. They will learn soon enough, as adults. |
Jesus. |
It’s so much easier to wear a Che Guevara shirt…
|
|
Once they are teens, it is important to teach them to be responsible for themselves.
Their body, their choice. |