Sidwell football article in post....what are the parents saying?

post reply Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools
[Post New]09/17/2011 21:42
quote
Anonymous
The Landon references are dumb, if you ask me. I think the misogynist (only boys' sports matter) obsessed (same IP address again and again) poster is either (a) an angry Sidwell current parent; (b) an angry former Sidwell parent; or (c) a parent of a child who didn't get in to Sidwell (or was counseled out, possibly). (My bet is on C.) Could also be an obnoxious teen -- there is a distinctly adolescent quality to the posts. Landon folks worry about Prep and STA -- Sidwell is not really their "competition" in terms of the potential student base.

Sidwell is a wonderful academic school that fields lots of teams and affords lots of athletic opportunities, and along the way sends a respectable number of male and female athletes on to play in college. If you are looking for top football, send your child to Good Counsel, but better be certain he's very talented or he'll never play. And no, the teaching won't generally be as good nor the other students as bright as at Sidwell.

This thread to me is like a website dedicated to saying Harvard football stinks because they can't play SEC or PAC-10 teams. (On a related note, interesting article in Washington Post on how the University of Chicago, with 15,000 students, happily fields a D-3 football team.)
[Post New]09/18/2011 06:50
quote
Anonymous
Comparing Sidwell to the University of Chicago is a very appropriate comparison.
[Post New]09/18/2011 14:14
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:The Landon references are dumb, if you ask me. I think the misogynist (only boys' sports matter) obsessed (same IP address again and again) poster is either (a) an angry Sidwell current parent; (b) an angry former Sidwell parent; or (c) a parent of a child who didn't get in to Sidwell (or was counseled out, possibly). (My bet is on C.) Could also be an obnoxious teen -- there is a distinctly adolescent quality to the posts. Landon folks worry about Prep and STA -- Sidwell is not really their "competition" in terms of the potential student base.

Sidwell is a wonderful academic school that fields lots of teams and affords lots of athletic opportunities, and along the way sends a respectable number of male and female athletes on to play in college. If you are looking for top football, send your child to Good Counsel, but better be certain he's very talented or he'll never play. And no, the teaching won't generally be as good nor the other students as bright as at Sidwell.

This thread to me is like a website dedicated to saying Harvard football stinks because they can't play SEC or PAC-10 teams. (On a related note, interesting article in Washington Post on how the University of Chicago, with 15,000 students, happily fields a D-3 football team.)


Just curious, how do you see the IP address?

My post will be blank on Sidwell football - I have nothing to say on it, nor do I understand the obsession.
[Post New]09/19/2011 08:32
quote
Anonymous
Wow. Sidwell ends an 18 game losing streak, defeating juggernaut Victory Christian Academy.
[Post New]09/19/2011 16:48
quote
Anonymous
Victory Christian Academy? Who's next on the schedule - Holton Arms?
[Post New]09/20/2011 18:02
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:Victory Christian Academy? Who's next on the schedule - Holton Arms?


That's a mean comment. Although it's true that Sidwell sports is inferior to most of the top private schools in this area.
[Post New]09/21/2011 00:03
quote
Anonymous
How does an anonymous poster see an IP Address? Jeff? Maria? Can you please address this?
[Post New]09/21/2011 06:26
quote
jsteele
Site Admin Online
Anonymous wrote:How does an anonymous poster see an IP Address? Jeff? Maria? Can you please address this?


They can't. But, some posters are very good at detecting sock puppets. They don't need to see IP addresses.
[Post New]09/21/2011 08:04
quote
Anonymous
21:42 Thank you, Jeff. I hope you are right and not hacked.

[Post New]09/21/2011 16:46
quote
Anonymous
Anonymous wrote:21:42 Thank you, Jeff. I hope you are right and not hacked.



What do you mean, "hacked"? If one poses as one or more people, that is not "hacking" a website.
[Post New]09/21/2011 17:02
quote
jsteele
Site Admin Online
Anonymous wrote:21:42 Thank you, Jeff. I hope you are right and not hacked.



I would never say that it is impossible that we were hacked. A lot more secure places than DCUM have been hacked. But, I sincerely doubt anyone wasting his time in this thread has the wherewithal to pull it off.
[Post New]09/22/2011 00:25
quote
Anonymous
as someone with no dog in this fight, I find it extremely comical that so many people want to attack a school like Sidwell for having a bad football team. For the math challenged - SOME schools must be bad at football. Not every team can be good. Sidwell is known as a top academic prep school with politicians' kids. Many teams in other sports ARE good. I don't see the problem.

Seems like tons of jealous people are doing the criticism. It is hard for a small top academic school which does not recruit to be good at football. Real hard. And that's ok. There are other sports, and in the end, sports are an extracurricular activity like many others. They're supposed to be fun competition, and the main mission of a SCHOOL is to educate.

And yes, I played sports (though not football, so my brain still works).



[Post New]09/23/2011 13:52
quote
Anonymous
What perpetuates this thread in large part are the Sidwell parents and their inane, illinformed replies (e.g. anyone who replies to this thread must be affiliated with Landon, Sidwell's athletic program is comparable to strong programs in the area, anyone who likes football must be a meathead, etc.)
[Post New]09/24/2011 16:51
quote
Anonymous
To build on the prior note about not equating an entire sports program with the football program -- went over to watch St. Albans soccer play Sidwell the other day. Good game, Sidwell won 2-0. I think the Sidwell boys' soccer team is ranked, and believe the Sidwell girls' soccer team is too -- the NCS girls' soccer team is also strong so that could be a good match-up with banner (league title) implications. Our kids say Sidwell's boys and girls' cross-country teams are solid too. Finally, saw on the Channel 9 news last night (Game of the Week!) that Sidwell won its most recent football game too. So, from your friends down the street on Wisconsin Ave, good job with the sports and don't get too bent out of shape by these nasty posts. In the end it's about providing a great education and a good team sports experience for kids, and our schools are all doing that.
[Post New]09/24/2011 16:58
quote
Anonymous
Nice post, PP. Stay classy, St. Albans!
post reply Forum Index » Private & Independent Schools
Message Quick Reply
Go to: 

Search   Recent Topics   Hottest Topics