|
I know I am going to get questions about our ages/maturity levels so here goes: we're well into our 30s.
I've been dating someone for 6 months. We're committed, and exclusive and have discussed that we don't intend to date any longer than 18 months prior to an engagement. We've met each other's immediate family and friends, and within the next month b/c of the holidays we are supposed to be meeting colleagues and extended families at Christmas parties. Overall, our relationship is excellent. Here's my problem: I'm uncomfortable with his FB. I'm very private online. I have always said that I won't change my relationship status unless I'm engaged (and I haven't, though he has changed his, but not tagged me in it at my request). I'm not FB friends with any guys I've dated except those who turned into long-term friendships. He has, literally, more than 3 times the number of FB friends that I do. He was a bit of a ladies man in the past (and like I said, we're not kids, so his "number" is relatively high) and several of his FB friends are past FWBs, flings, etc. Like more than 30 of them. I know what his past is, and I've accepted it. He was upfront about it. I'm not jealous, and I trust him. But, I don't want my coworkers or cousins seeing a FB friend of his after the holiday party and asking their friend about him and finding out he slept with them a couple of times. I think that when a person is in a serious relationship, one needs to minimize the presence of their past "dalliances" out of respect for their current partner. I'm not suggesting that he de-friend anyone he's actually still actively friends in real life with, but anyone he's not, to my mind, should go. Girls he hooked up with in university, or only dated a couple of times, etc. As I said, he's got way more friends on FB than I do, and is obviously way more casual about who he friends at all. I've kind of nudged casually at the subject, and in addition to just being way more into FB than I am, he's also quite proud of the fact that he wasn't a "player" to these women and they still want to be his friend. Oftentimes, the women were connected to his social group in some way (friend of a friend) so they were casual friends before sleeping together for a bit, and he uses this to justify it, too. Ironically, he's quite nervous about my family/friends liking him/thinking he is good enough for me. I don't want to give him an ultimatum, or make him do anything he'll resent me for down the road. But I also feel strongly that if I'm serious enough about him to bring him around my extended family/coworkers (I haven't taken a date to a family party or work function in more than 5 years) he should be serious enough about me to clean up his profile (there are some pictures on there, too, that don't indicate "serious adult man in a relationship" but he's shown more willingness to remove those when I've nudged at it) and his friends list. Am I slut shaming him? Or is it reasonable to expect that when you're in a serious adult relationship, you don't stay connected to half the people you slept with via social media? I'm not being hypocritical - I have no one on my FB that was a romantic/sexual relationship that I'm not actually friends with currently. I don't want people I know, who I have managed to keep my own personal life very private from, having the potential to find out all about his, for no good reason except that he likes having a lot of FB friends. Any men want to weigh in on how I can explain this to him so he understands where I'm coming from? Obviously, being I value privacy, I can't talk to anyone in my day-to-day life about this, so I came to DCUM. |
| The fact that you don't remain friends with your past lovers does not mean that he cannot. Personally, I think you are being insecure and controlling--and it appears that you are not comfortable with his "number." Whether he is Facebook friends with these women or not, it is always possible for someone you know to know someone he slept with. I think you seriously need to explore how "threatened" you are by his sexual past. Deleting a FB friends doesn't delete his history with these women. |
| I think expecting him to "un-friend" anyone he had a relationship with in the past is over the top. My DH is FB friends with past girlfriends. I'm honestly a jealous type and I'd probably flip if he were in actual contact with these women, but I'm not going to get worked up about them seeing some random pics of our kids and such. Asking him to unfriend them would seem like an incredibly insecure act to me. |
C'mon, this stuff is for people in their early 20s. You're in your 30s? Pull yourself together. |
|
Man here. You're being too controlling.
I've been married 5 years and still am friends with many exes. We watch each other "grow up" together -- they now have husbands and sometimes children, and I know them too. Heck, I invited some to our wedding and they come to parties at our house. Get over it. What would be worse (and you did allude to this) is if none of his exes wanted to keep in touch with him at all. That would be a possible red flag. |
|
OP here - I'm thankful for the responses- even though they've been 100% critical of me, so far.
I think a couple of things have been overlooked in the replies, though. I am still friends with some past loves of mine in real life and on FB. I don't want him to unfriend people he's actually friends with, or who would come to our parties or wedding if we had one. I am not asking him to unfriend actual ex-girlfriends. I feel like he's treating FB like he's posting his little black book all over the internet, and would be asking that he unfriend the women he slept with once or twice 3 or 5 or 7 years ago and hasn't spoken to since. |
|
You seem very concerned with what other people think about your relationship OP, and yes that reeks of insecurity. You'very mentioned a few times, that you don't want people you know to find out who your boyfriend hasingle slept with or something along those lines. Why do you care what anyone think? You're the one dating the guy.
When we are insecure, we tend to respond by being controlling. And as others have pointed out, you are headed in the control freak direction. |
As noted in my OP, I am concerned with my own privacy. Nothing about that has changed with this relationship. I don't want people to know who I've slept with casually (this is why I've kept my casual relationships offline), so I don't think it makes me insecure to not want people to know who he has slept with casually. |
| Why would being FB friends with someone mean that people would know who he slept with? You're asking for way too much, OP. You're overthinking this. Maybe this guy isn't right for you. This clearly means a lot more to you than it does to him. That's fine if it does, but you can't expect him to conform to your social media privacy profile just for your peace of mind. |
If that's what you really cared about, you could remove yourself from Facebook and tell him not to post anything about you. But your issue is not privacy it's insecurity. You need to deal with that. Go see a therapist because your request is completely unreasonable. Most people are Facebook friends with acquaintances. Or old friends or whatever. |
| OP here again. No one sees being connected via social media to numerous people your only connection with is that you slept with them casually a few times as a bit of flaunting it? Getting more specific, when you run down your list of FB friends, and by the time you come to the end of the people whose name starts with "A" you've got 5 people you slept with, that isn't considered extreme? |
|
OP you sound controlling and very insecure.
The poor guy -- did you make him divulge who he has slept with to you? I have been married 15years and have no clue (not a one!) who my DH's exes were/are - so I have no clue if he is current FB with them. Even if there were 50 and he was FB friends with all 50--- I would not care. Not a single care. I am not on FB because I truly am a private person, so I don't have a clue what his social media presence is. But what I do know is how strong our marriage is. And how great a husband and father he is. Grow up, OP. Have some self-esteem. If he really loves you it doesn't matter what's on FB. It definitely should not matter to you. Good luck. Or, you will find yourself scaring this guy away. |
| OP, if this bothers you so much, he's not the guy for you. Just accept it and move on. |
|
You are WAY too uptight. I have a feeling that when you lose your shit, while it's rare, you scream in a horrible out-of-control way to the point of scaring people. You need to unclench.
He's banged whoever he's banged. And just like we were all taught in seventh grade sex education, when you bang someone you're banging everyone they've banged. If you want to marry him, you need to accept how he lives his life. To marry someone with the intent of changing them is wrong. Hopefully the people you know are more secure and mature than you are. |
Pretty much this. For the record I agree with you. |