I think it's funny that you think calling me paranoid is some sort of gotcha. Yes I am paranoid. Bad things happen in the world. I am the only person in the world responsible for my kids safety and I take that very seriously. I'm sorry your kids have a mother that doesn't. |
This. It depends on the organization and where their picture will be displayed, etc. |
There’s taking things seriously and there’s paranoia. |
And you are the final arbiter of that. Congrats. Listen do whatever you want. Feel free to call me paranoid and I'll feel free to call you a selfish mom who prioritizes her own wants over the safety of her kids. Hopefully nothing bad happens and you don't have to learn the hard way. Have a blessed afternoon! |
I’m not saying you’re paranoid. I am saying it’s a paranoid way of thinking. It just is. |
| I think I understood the no photos thing a few years ago. It was easier to keep kids away from creeps. But now that people in public are constantly with smart phones and ipads out pointing everywhere, how do you know your child isn't being photographed by creeps in public? |
seek therapy Rocky ASAP |
We didn’t even allow yearbook in ES but one year they ignored us. We pitched a fit and they ultimately offered to correct “our” YB but they’d already been distributed to everyone else so what was the point. We’re not the “suing” type but we still have not let the school admin forget they screwed up. We still sign the opt-out (last DC is a senior in HS) and most teachers/clubs sincerely attempt to comply. Current compromise for those who ask for something special is name or image but not both. And, yes, we have walked away from certain activities, in part, because of their strict demand for permission to publish. |
I mean, you don't, but for a parent who is concerned about this, knowing that strangers might be photographing your kid in public is not a reason to just say "screw it, let's give everyone permission to post pics of our kids all over the internet." That doesn't make sense. Once when I was at a kid's birthday party, there was a dad there I didn't know who made a big production of taking pictures of the birthday girl. It wasn't his daughter, he was a guest, but he made a point of pausing the festivities at one point to take photos of her. My kid was standing behind the birthday girl, with a group of other children, so they were all in the photos. Something about his behavior just sent up a big red flag, so I just quietly walked over to my kid to stand between her and the camera and pretend I had to help where with something or ask a question. The kids at recently been running through the sprinkler and were still in suits, though my DD had put a skirt back on. It still felt super sketch. I hate feeling like I need to think about that kind of thing but... I think I do. These experiences don't make me LESS vigilant about keeping photos of my kid off the internet, they make me more vigilant. |
Again, paranoid. Parents have been taking photos of kids at birthday parties for generations. |
Other people's kids? Your own kid, sure. Your own kid with the birthday kid, yes. And the hosts might take photos of the kids to commemorate the party for themselves. Taking photos of a group of other people's kids, at a party you are not hosting, is sketch. What are the photos for? Especially if you don't even know all the kids in the photo you're taking? Why is that a memory you need to take home with you? |
|
the whole fb sharing back to school pics thing freaked me out— I’m grateful to not be on social media and hope somehow it’s safer when my kids are big enough to us it
https://www.news18.com/world/deliberately-provocative-meta-under-fire-from-parents-after-photos-of-daughters-appear-in-targeted-ads-ws-ekl-9586914.html |
|
I work in social media and see the dark sides. If it were up to me, there would be zero pictures of my kids, but I’ve found even when I specify no pictures, my kids end up in pictures anyway. I remember one organization that absolutely did not have my permission took a picture of my daughter and used it in multiple promotional pictures - social media, flyers, etc. It was very upsetting for me when I walked into a coffee shop and saw a stack of flyers with my daughter’s photo on them.
There’s an absolutely insane number of pedophiles out there, and they all save thousands of pictures of kids. It’s very disturbing. Even more so with AI. |
|
context: we didn't post kids on social at all for a couple of years. As they got older, they started appearing more and more because they tag along with me when i'm out doing my thing around town and I started feeling like sharing that they're there. Even so, I still choose angles and scenes that don't show their faces.
for photo releases, I have yet to find a situation I felt comfortable approving. I don't want my kids' images in the algo and sometimes I also very specifically don't want my kids used to promote certain businesses - and for free. |
| OP, are you a bambini parent? The timing of this question today made me think you might be. if yes and in case it helps, we said no thank you as did most of our class as far as I know. I don't think excluding my kid from promotional material will be a "make or break" factor in helping to enrich Otter management. |