I feel like I’m in the minority but I don’t think she fell. There are way too many witnesses who truly seem to have seen her. And what reason do they have to come forward? Especially the marine? I think Yellow had something to do with her disappearance. Ultimately I don’t believe she’s alive now. Such a heartbreaking story. |
They think they saw her, nothing really concrete. Often people see what they want to see. I believe the sex worker was hustling the marine, just trying to get a $200 payout. |
They *saw* someone they didn't know, who they'd never seen before. There are no perameters to reality there, just hopeful thinking and imagination. It's tragic, it really is. |
She’d be 50 now. It’s so very sad |
What makes their accounts slightly credible is that the person they *saw* identified themself as Amy from [West] Virginia. The witnesses having some amount of confirmation bias in how they recounted the event is still entirely plausible though. |
eh no, not in every instance they did not - the woman on the beach did not. the woman in the bathroom maybe, but the older lady who met her had clearly been drinking a lot. Take it all with a pinch of salt, its not swear-on-the-bible truths here. |
. I just feel it’s so many people who have seen her- not just one person. I have to believe that they all wouldn’t lie and she met with foul play. |
They aren't lying. Witness identification/recollection is not reliable. |
The women claiming to be Amy were probably setting up a scam to ask for money.
|
The older woman seemed a little nutty. Not sure whether she is credible. I believe the sex worker knew Amy's story (pretty infamous in that area) and was trying to hustle the military guy. Pretty convenient that "all she needed was $200 to be free"... |
Something is very very odd with the guy in the next room. He reminds me of the Tylenol killer guy who never quite admitted it but loved to talk about it. |
He was a colleague, would be pretty odd. Seems easy enough to establish whether the balcony dividers could be opened? |
He made a strange comment about her coming over to talk. |
He was indicted for smuggling leopard hides. A weirdo, yes. But even weirder that the documentary left out that he was a colleague, not a stranger.
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/men-indicted-for-smuggling-leopard-hides/# |
I think she was under the influence and pretty unsteady. Used the table to step up and sit on top of the railing and smoke. Lost her balance, fall was so sudden and fast, and her reactions time slow, that she didn't even manage to scream. Or did and that's what woke her father up--who didn't realize what he heard that jarred him from a deep sleep after only a short time.
I don't believe the rationalizations about her being afraid of the sea etc. And I believe the eyewitnesses didn't see what they thought they saw. |