I encourage you to listen to the last 10-15 min of the oral arguments in the appellate court. |
the surpeme court has made it legal for the government to simply snatch people off the streets and out of their homes and throw them into gulags in central America.
And if you think this stops with "illegals," think again. ANYONE is at risk. |
No. They didn't. They ruled 5-4 that the suit was brought in the wrong venue. That it should have been brought in Texas, not DC. The court ruled 9-0 that the Alien Enemy Act requires due process. What due process? We have to wait and see. |
Due Process can be met in a variety of ways. |
It does sound like the Supreme Court decided that judge shopping is frowned upon. |
DP. The whole point of using the AEA was to avoid due process. The Supreme Court basically rejected that and said that due process is required. The Supreme Court didn't outright overturn the invocation of the AEA, but they basically defanged its use. At first glance, this looks like a win for the Trump administration. But actually, they lost. |
Again, it all depends on what "Due Process" means here. It could be as simple as holding a short hearing before deportation. |
Angry little baby. I hope you have a horrible day. |
Yes, a hearing challenging nationality or belonging to tda could be due process. The Trump administration wanted to avoid all of that using the unreviewable AEA. The Supreme Court didn't review the AEA one way or the other but instead said it is challengeable. Now explain the distinction between reviewable and challengeable and how that [non-existent] distinction helps the government. Answer: it doesn't. It is the opposite of what they wanted. |
While your statement is true, it is rather broad. And reading the opinion is really important (despite how difficult Repubs find reading - and understanding). Here's the quote though. "Although judicial review under the AEA is limited, we have held that an individual subject to detention and removal under that statute is entitled to “‘judicial review’” as to “questions of interpretation and constitutionality” of the Act as well as whether he or she “is in fact an alien enemy fourteen years of age or older.” Ludecke, 335 U. S., at 163−164, 172, n. 17." Seems clear cut. You get your day in court, yes? |
The real purpose of AEA was to get Venezuela to take its people back. They had agreed to do so, then refused. Once they saw the alternative was their people would be in El Salvador they agreed to take their citizens again. These alleged anti-Maduro folks are being greeted with fanfare by the regime. |
This was available nearly a month ago. The district judge blocked the AEA entirely. |
That's why they sent Abrego Garcia there? The whole point was optics. To show a big win. To threaten immigrants and American citizens. It's working. We're scared. |
DP but the little baby is right and you're wrong. “ disappear verb dis·ap·pear ˌdis-ə-ˈpir disappeared; disappearing; disappears Synonyms of disappear intransitive verb 1 : to pass from view The moon disappeared behind a cloud. 2 : to cease to be : pass out of existence or notice dinosaurs disappeared from the earth My keys seem to have disappeared again. transitive verb : to cause (someone or something) to disappear: a : to abduct and kill or imprison (someone, such as a political dissident) while withholding information about the person's fate Her son was disappeared during Argentina's so-called 'Dirty War.' —Associated Press Under his repressive regime, tens of thousands of Chileans were "disappeared," tortured and killed; hundreds of thousands were forced into exile. —Mandalit del Barco Fearing that he would be kidnapped or "disappeared" in Syria under some false pretext, Mr. Omar made a video, which he posted on YouTube, to establish that he had defected. —Dan Bilefsky https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disappear |