Ex–Google exec says degrees in law and medicine are a waste of time in the era of AI

[Anonymous]

I'm a lawyer who's seen AI work and it's a giant mess. Hallucinates like crazy, leads people entirely wrong. Maybe it will, but for now it's making messes that are taking more attorney time to fix. Legalzoom and their ilk were supposed to put lawyers out of business and largely did the same thing.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:When we do get to the point of AI super intelligence we're going to have bigger problems than this. Just sayin'

+1

We won’t have to worry about whether AI lawyers and medical doctors are better than human doctors. The logical conclusion is that humans are inefficient, being both problematic and unnecessary for the future of AIs. Without humans, legal and medical services are unnecessary.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:There will never be a true replacement of a physician, but I noticed our newest med school class is full of students who are working on si projects.

That might be true, but instead of needing 10 radiologists, they now need 1 to sign off final approval.

Will be interested to see the lawsuits.

Popcorn time.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:Ok so you go to AI doctor with your kid, kid has heritable illness. AI overlords sterilize you and kid to lower social healthcare costs in long term.

You go to AI doctor at age 75 and it diagnosis cancer. Sends you to palliative care because AI overlords have rule about treating old people.

What's not to like?

You sound as delusional as tea partiers and their “death panels.” In reality that AI doctors costs a few thousand a year to operate so they’ll have more money for R&D and nurses to get you healthy again.

Aw, you are so innocent. It’s cute.

[Anonymous]

How's AI supposed to perform a physical exam, palpitations a stomach, look in someone's ears, do developmental questions with an anxious kid, etc?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:I trust what AI will be capable of five years out over a general practitioner. Most aren’t that good and often overworked so they make errors AI won’t. I’m excited and it will lower health care costs.

AI will not lower health costs for people unless you are a CEO. Get real.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:That has been true for law for a long time. It’s not worth getting the degree unless it’s from a top school. The market is over saturated and a lot of legal research that used to be done by entry level lawyers can be outsourced.

AI will never replace physicians though. It’s one thing for a physician to use AI to help diagnose, but nobody is going to have surgery just because an AI interface recommends it.

Meh. I am a lawyer and would never hire an AI for a legal need I had. I can see it being a tool but I would always want the actual lawyer advising me and helping me think through the issues.

When AI stops hallucinate cases and laws, we can maybe start talking. Right now -- a lawyer still has to check every cite and read every case. AI might help with research, but it's not replacing the lawyer.

Just create an AI to check. What could possibly go wrong.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:I find these "experts" know little about the lived experiences, needs, and preferences of the majority of people.

Yea. I need a hectic and understaffed ER in the city that takes eight hours to get through for ultimately minor ailments. Extra points for patients who are handcuffed to their bed because they also committed a felony. I’ll take AI

Ok. Let us know how it goes bandaging your head or restarting your heart.

[Anonymous]

I don't know what medicine is going to look like in 5-10 years, but I generally think it will be worse for both patients and doctors...and AI will be part of the excuse for making it work.

Right now, it already takes forever to see a specialist. And cost-cutting is everywhere. I broke my foot, and I the only doctor I've seen in person was at urgent care. My initial follow up with the podiatrist was virtual, and now my 6w follow up is also virtual. They had me get an xray on my own. There will be no physical exam. I know enough to know what kinds of questions to ask and where to point out pain/bruising, but they really should do a physical exam. I am also checking with AI what I should be sure to ask about.

AI is only going to put more pressure on doctors to see more patients faster. And patients will rely more on AI to ask about symptoms, because doctors will be even more rushed and less available. Important stuff will get missed, and any personal element that's been left in healthcare will be diminished completely.

[Anonymous]

But, very soon lots of humans will die due to war, climate change and pandemics. So, if your kid survives and has good solid educational background...they will be in high demand.

[Anonymous]

They should not use it in war anymore, deadly stupid mistakes

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/careersandeducation/ex-google-exec-says-degrees-in-law-and-medicine-are-a-waste-of-time-because-they-take-so-long-to-complete-that-ai-will-catch-up-by-graduation/ar-AA1W8Fzh?ocid=entnewsntp&pc=U531&cvid=69ad725a7d7b4a33a3b8db35aa5b5448&ei=29

My DS and DD are in first year of medical school with student loan debt at public universities, and this really scares me. My younger brother is working for an AI company specializing in radiology that can do a much better job than a radiologist.

Some of you really are dumb.

How is AI supposed to do a physical exam on someone?

How is AI supposed to argue a case in front of a judge?

You read some comment by a Silicon Valley CEO and blindly nod your head.

[Anonymous]

The vast majority of physicians are better than AI any day, but AI is better than most physician assistants / nurse practitioners.

[Anonymous]

AI can definitely replace most doctors. You input symptoms, imaging, vitala, labs, etc, and it will be able to make diagnoses better than a human.

Basic medicine doesn’t change all that much. It can be done by AI. And not only that, AI can cosntantly learn from new research while a human can barely read one journal article per day.

You have to remember this is the infancy of AI. It will get exponentially better as time progresses. 10 years from now I wouldn't doubt at all AI becomes better than most doctors. Look how much cell phones have advanced since 2010. Hospitals and healthcare admins will demand it to drastically cut labor costs.

[Anonymous]

Im not letting an Ai bot do my tubal ligation.