The same here! When I do the lifting programs with my husband I get the fat ---fwiw he lifts the most in his 'chubbier stages'. When I stopped doing cardio 4-5 days per week and transitioned to weight-lifting mostly ---the gut comes back. |
That’s because muscle grows but there is still fat over it. I feel like I have looked bigger too because I didn’t keep to a strict diet that weigh lifters usually have. |
Drop the processed carbs and the anxiety meds. It’s a continuous feedback loop. Get your gut in shape by eliminating processed foods and seed oils and focus on whole foods, mostly meat and a few veggies/fruits; grains and nuts. This, some walking and weights will significantly change your body and mental health. |
Different methods work for different bodies. My gyn specializes in peri and menopause and recommended switching to low intensity steady state cardio and limiting carbs, and adding endurance style lifting. The type you mention above sounds like more of a hypertrophy style program aimed at muscle gains, and often requires a bulk/cut to lose the fat on top of the muscle. If OP is struggling though, it may be another option to try. It’s not that anyone is “against” cardio, it’s just that it hasn’t gotten us the results we wanted. Again, different goals and different outcomes because we are all different! |
At 45, I don’t want to be injured and I need functional training that keeps moving and active. Haha so I much prefer light weights and more reps even if instagram says we need to lift as heavy as possible all the time. I love my active cardio days and a good burpee but I am trying to be more balanced. |
Have to be so controlled now. My basics are - fast 6:30-11:30 except black coffee. Eat high protein low carb/sugar in the eating window. I eat plenty but super clean. Run 3x a week, Pilates 3x a week and walk as much as I am able. 45yo |
PP here whose doctor recommended cutting out cardio. I recognize now I should have clarified my specific goal because it matters. I was skinny fat after years of cardio and restricting, followed by a period of increasing inactivity. My BMI was the same it’s always been, but my body fat percentage was higher than expected for someone my size. My doctor’s only goal was muscle gain and cardio was counter productive to that. Weight loss was not my goal but I did end up losing fat. |
I had to significantly decrease my calorie intake. Reduce by 700 calories a day. I did this and I am currently eating about 1200 -1300 cal a day and I am losing a little less than 2 pounds a week (knocking on 25 pounds lost since new year). I am larger than you. I also walk the 10k and have since before fitbits. I fully expect the weight loss to taper off and I will be eating 1200 cal for the rest of my life. I have always eaten less and exercised more than my peers and have always been 2-3 sizes larger. This was evident when I went to college and it hasn’t changed in nearly 40 years. My genes are valuable during famine but a curse in abundance. |
Don’t eat out. Take a “thin” probiotic. Work out harder than walking. |
What is a thin probiotic? |
This has also been my experience. Low carbs (mostly from plants), limited refined sugars, and a gram of protein for each pound of target weight. As for the cardio debate... Walking is technically cardio. That's not really a problem. Heavy, steady-state cardio (think running on a treadmill) can cause hunger spikes, and impede fat loss. Weight training, or a combo like HIIT that also pushes you cardiovascularly, prioritizes building muscle which burns fat at rest. The more muscle you have to support, the more calories you're using to maintain it (oversimplified, but that's the math). Steady state cardio doesn't build muscle; it might break down muscle if you're not properly fueling and providing adequate protein supply. |