Happily. I linked it above: “12) Reduce sworn officer FTEs in police Districts 3 and 4 by 50% to reduce patrol officer contact with residents in these districts.” There are plenty of other suggestions that are going to exacerbate crime in DTSS, too, like the suggestion to ignore crimes against society (which includes drugs). https://ele4a.org/wp-cont...report.pdf Since traffic stops actually lead to confiscates drugs and guns, including a ton of fentanyl recently, I’m thinking his Step Act is very short sighted. |
I'm not the PP but I thought they made a good point about police staffing shortages nationwide, including in places deemed sufficiently "supportive" of law enforcement. How do you square your assertion regarding the Council's culpability in staffing challenges with that nationwide trend? Moreover, if we understand that the nationwide trend is in part due to people not wanting to be part of an institution that has so publicly discredited itself in recent years, what changes would you suggest that police forces themselves should make to ensure that people want to join? |
Thank you for the cite. I don’t agree with that specific proposal but I see no harm that it was mentioned in a report. It’s a valid POV even if you disagree and it is wrong to suggest that anybody wants to make our community less safe. There is room for disagreement but not for misrepresenting the goals of those who you disagree with. I also see the following in the same report so it seems like a reasonable document. “Challenge to reducing patrol officers in districts 3 and 4: One community member disagreed with this recommendation As representative of the MC-NAACP Branch, Unit 7022, on the task force noted, "it would be more pragmatic to support a ratio of uniform police staffing in relation to population density in Districts 3 & 4, rather than reduce staffing to these communities. It would also be useful to see the conviction rate in relation to the over-policing of these areas, as many believe” |
That's horrible. Did you/your spouse share that info with the police? This is not directed at you, per se, but I wish people would call the police. You can call MCPS main number and leave a message -- you don't have to call 911 if you don't feel your life is imminent. |
Council members who refer to police as “thugs” and “goons” are absolutely contributing to an anti-police stance coming from the council, as are council members who throw out statements about needing to limit interactions with the police as a way of protecting citizens. Sure, this is a nationwide problem. Why is it, however, that this council (and its anti-police friends) can’t acknowledge that we continue to have a model police department in spite of all challenges? Even after the expanded definition of use of force, over 99% of police interactions contain none. What about highlighting life-saving efforts on the part of the police, which happen daily? Perhaps altering rhetoric to acknowledge all of the good would go a long way to helping recruitment, as well. |
Why is it that defenders of the Montgomery County Police Department can't acknowledge that MCPD has problems? "We're totally not as bad as THOSE guys" only takes you so far. |
Sigh. Nobody fails to acknowledge problems, including me. I just don’t exist entirely in a “police are terrible” realm. I am intimately aware of the good they do, too. Why, to use your question, are critics of MCPD incapable of acknowledging that the department does a tremendous amount of good? |
This you?
The County Council, individually and collectively, is constantly praising the Montgomery County Police Department. But somehow the praise-to-criticism ratio still isn't high enough? |
Both of you seem to agree but are concerned about different aspects. Why not tone down the rhetoric and find mutually agreeable solutions? |
Great! Can you please point out a couple of these praises? I watch a lot of the meetings and don’t see them. Perhaps some social media posts to balance out “thugs,” “goons,” and “defund”? |
“Elrich said that many stories people around the country hear about police are negative, and that positive stories like this deserve just as much attention. "You don't hear about this stuff very often. It's important that this is elevated to the same level that everything else is," Elrich said. "There are a lot of good stories that come out of the department. They deserve to be told."” https://moco360.media/2023/06/30/elrich-awards-officers-and-others-for-their-bravery-at-cabin-john-creek-on-june-23/ |
I think it’s important for the public to understand that there are many ways to fight violent crime, and a significant tool is traffic stops.So when you take things like traffic stops and SROs away, you reduce resources that help prevent violence before they happen. Most of the violence right now is being committed by teens against teens. And nobody has this conversation. The Council is hyper focused on reducing harms like suspensions in schools or disparate traffic stops, neglecting to see that disparities haven’t fallen, and in some case have increased, since police reform began. |
And what we are saying is that many non-violent people have had their lives ruined because of small quantities of drugs found during such searches. I don’t think it is good policy to sacrifice mostly good people just to catch a few bad apples. That is the point here. If you can think of a way that people are not harassed for minor violations while the violent offenders are the ones affected then please tell me because we would all agree. |
I disagree with that statement. Marijuana has been decriminalized for almost 10 years. Nobody is getting arrested for that and has not for almost a decade. Nobody is getting harassed for minor traffic violations in any systemic way. 85% of all traffic stops last less than 5 minutes. 96% total last less than 15 minutes. |
You are advocating for an increase in pre-textual stops which are proven to lead to racial disparities in the level and type of arrests. What would you suggest be done to ensure that officers do not disproportionately stop black drivers if we went in that direction. In my opinion, if you don’t have a clear answer for that issue then you are not serious about solving the problem. |