PP here. I’m fine without mandating vaccination for kids under 12. But the teachers need to be vaccinated to protect the kids, or fired. |
I believe it’s already mandated for teachers in our district and there is little pushback. But the problem with mandating the vaccine for some of these professions is that there is already a shortage of workers or very little margin for losing more. What’s worse for kids in an area with lower vaccine uptake- an unvaccinated teacher or the ramifications of losing, say, 30% of the teachers? Especially when families will soon have the option of getting their kids vaccinated. |
Honestly, I think that losing the unvaccinated subset of teachers is the best possible outcome. What could these anti-vaxxers possibly be teaching the students that we want the kids to learn? Why should the more at-risk students be forced to have subpar teachers who are not intelligent, clearly? I do think the unvaccinated need to be prohibited from accessing publicly funded resources, like any sidewalk or road, not just fired, because losing one's job isn't enough of a deterrent. What the states could do to offset is re-assign teachers from wealthier school districts to those that lose their teachers. Then, to make up for the teachers needing to commute and larger class sizes, cut 80% of extra crap like clubs, sports, parent-teacher conferences from every single school in the state. Don't make them respond to parent emails, deal with parent complaints, or differentiate instruction for white kids whose parents pushed them into honors classes. Get rid of all this online learning BS and having to upload grades/assignments constantly. Administrators should field and handle completely all parent issues. Unless it's a fire-able offense, let. it. go. |
Seek help and for the love of everything, please don't ever run for office. Thanks! |
Aw, did I hit a nerve? How many emails do you average a week to your kid's teachers? |
So basically, punish all the kids in the low-vax areas to make a point? I suspect that most parents who are highly supportive of mandates for teachers live in area where uptake is not a big issue. Kids don't have the same risk profile as LTC facility residents and we need to stop treating them that way. |
No, did you see where I suggested teachers move districts to offset harm to kids? But really I don’t care what happens as long as we agree to stop shutting down schools for anything Covid related and forcing toddlers and little kids to wear masks. Do whatever you need to do to feel comfortable with that but it needs to happen like yesterday. |
So basically you have no rational ideas. No organization is going to risk losing 30% of its workforce especially when they already have a shortage of employees. Additionally you overestimate teacher’s willingness just to be reassigned to another district, not to mention the legality around such as teachers are district employees not state. And you greatly overestimate your neighboring parents willingness to share resources such as teachers. I guarantee they don’t want their class size going up. |
NP. In the child vaccine trial for ages 5-11, the only group with zero covid cases was the previously infected children. The vaccine is great at preventing severe disease in adults (unclear in children as the trial was not powered for that). The mandates would make sense if the vaccine was better at preventing transmission but it’s not. “ Whatever a society chooses to do, and irrespective of how many people get vaccinated and re-vaccinated, it is unlikely to change the fact that eventually essentially everyone, everywhere will get exposed to the virus multiple times in their life time.” - Francois Balloux, Director UCL Genetics Institute |
Exactly! 100% agree with PP. Sit behind your desk and judge. Why don't you go into the field and gather data like a good clinician would. |
Kids are more protected from the severe effects of Covid than we are as vaccinated adults. The FDA decision to approve the vaccine for kids was not a slam dunk. Watch the meeting This is a nuanced medical decision and the vaccine should not be mandated for kids. The FDA is clear about that, as you can see if you watch the Oct. 26 meeting: https://www.fda.gov/advisory-committees/advisory-committee-calendar/vaccines-and-related-biological-products-advisory-committee-october-26-2021-meeting-announcement Kids should have the option to return to school as normal ASAP. In fact, thousands of schools around the country are normal. https://about.burbio.com/school-mask-policies-by-state/ |
| We have gotten off topic. Anyways… I teach third grade and about 60percent of my students are on a kindergarten or first grade level. It is pretty bad. I can honestly say that there is not much hope for them. I will give them lesson for kindergarten and first grade in small groups but whole group is 3rd grade. Students are writing letter backwards and can’t spell sight words. I just want to quit. Not because of the students but because of my own kids that I need to worry about educationally right now. School just isn’t cutting it as far as filling in the gaps. |
NP. My 3rd grader is in AAP. He's bright but we saw a lot of regression last year and I noticed that he started reversing letters and numbers at the start of the school year, something he'd never done before. That has stopped now. Maybe he's finally beginning to catch up. |
Or maybe get a few more degrees… |
!!! Long term impacts of the vaccine are even less known than long term covid effects. |