
No. I enjoy the spirit of the season. These days we need things that can make us smile.
-Muslim |
+1 and I'm not very religious. No one is trying to drag a person's child to their religious "side" by having a gift sharing event. |
The goal posts appear to be on roller skates. |
PP here. I don't blame the ice rink for jumping right into the winter season. It's their busiest time of year and I totally understand that they want to play it up for as long as possible. I do think that generic winter decorations would feel less out of place for Thanksgiving and throughout the rest of the post-Christmas winter season. But, again, oh well. I'm sure lots of people skate just for the Christmas season, because it's such a popular Christmas activity. As for other businesses doing straight to Christmas, I was at the Dollar Tree yesterday and another customer was looking for Thanksgiving decorations, but they only had Christmas stuff. He asked an employee if there were Thanksgiving decorations in the back that he had missed it something and they said, no, they don't carry any. |
No, those are not the same. Sex Ed is part of health class and is educational. That belongs in the classroom. Gift exchange for a holiday that not everyone celebrates is not. |
Co-mingling religion and gifts (or medical care) for vulnerable/young people is unethical. Share gifts? Great. Keep religion out of it. |
Why? We can’t share our blessings? |
People send school supplies, pencils, paper, clothes, toothpaste and toothbrushes, soccer balls and soccer ball pumps, as well as toys. We take such things for for granted. Religious people can donate the shoebox gifts Atheists can donate the shoebox gifts Any person of any religion or no religion can donate the shoebox gifts Public or private or home school The focus is on sharing your heart with a child in a small way and caring about the child who receives something that will make them smile. If any organization was collecting and coordinating such an event, I would donate. I don’t have to personally support the organization; it’s not the organization I want to make smile. If there is an atheist or humanist organization who collects and arranges for the distribution of something like this- what is it and how can I donate? Would the people here who have issues with Operation christmas child consider supporting that org? |
There’s no doubt you will skip it, have a nice holiday season. |
A school offering jackets and/or small presents to kids who want them during the holiday season is one thing. The shoebox thing is an organized evangelical attempt to bribe young kids around the world to bring their vulnerable families to hear a religious pitch: "Other churches use the boxes as resources for outreach in orphanages and other at-risk areas. In many places, they also offer The Greatest Gift, a Gospel story booklet Samaritan’s Purse developed for shoebox recipients, and invite children to participate in The Greatest Journey discipleship program. As a result of what they learn in The Greatest Journey, boys and girls grow in Christ and share with friends and family. The students also invite others to their graduations where the Gospel is shared. This often brings parents, siblings, and friends to accept Christ and become active members in the local church. Families are reached, churches grow, new churches are started, and communities are transformed. Go Deeper →" https://www.samaritanspurse.org/operation-christmas-child/the-journey-of-a-shoebox/ It's a recruiting effort using unethical practices. You want to do a good thing? Send the gifts and pat yourself on the back. Don't use them to manipulate people. |
Go ahead and send a gift with no strings attached. No pressure to hear a religious pitch. |
Why do you think you have control over people who participate in Operation Christmas Child? Other adults don’t need your permission, nor do other children, to either give or receive gifts. Why do you think you are an active part of other people’s lives? If you don’t want to participate, you don’t have to. |
Honestly it’s up to the giver to either share or not share their religion. The gift recipient can choose to learn more or ignore the religious part. There’s nothing wrong with Operation Christmas Child. Would you prefer this donation campaign not exist? You are so against religion you want to live in a comfortable and safe country and demand children in less than optimal situations not even receive a small box of items because Christians send it? |
I'm just calling it out as unethical and definitely not appropriate for a public school. |
They are doing more than giving out gifts. They are pressuring vulnerable people to listen to their religious spiel. |