Sorry, you are right. I was being hyperbolic. Let's just say she is very unhappy with VL and I have concerns about her mental health. |
You are engaged in some extreme projection here. I'm sorry your child's school is so badly impacted, but the discussion you are responding to is about how every school is different and how treated them as such is the correct policy decision. A PP described in-person schooling using hyperbolic and flat-out untrue language that basically described prison. In response, some of us chimed in to explain that our kids were actually having a pretty normal year, other than masks. Then you came in with this rhetoric about how we are just heartless assholes, just for saying our kids actually like being back in class and doing things like cross country or in-person student government. Why is it so triggering to you that some kids are having a pretty normal educational experience this year? |
I am trying to figure this out. My kids did fine distance learning, but are much happier and more engaged in person. Essentially, from their perspective it does feel back to normal. I have noticed that there are some people who are projecting their anxiety onto their kids (I am not talking about folks on this board) and its resulting in anxious kids who do not want to be in person. This essentially creates an echo chamber and parents only see an anxious child and not their unwitting role in creating the situation. I typically see this in parents with older kids - late middle and high school. |
There is also the very real element of bullying, cliques, and exclusion. For some kids, in-person is awful because of this reason. And maybe the kids have anxiety about returning to that environment. |
PP here. I do not disagree, I am sure that is the case for a number of kids. Those kids are excellent candidates for the virtual academy and I am glad that’s an option. But parents should not utilize those reasons to support the case of distance learning across the board and claim it’s due to Covid spread. |
+4 (I guess). In the exact same boat. After reading all the "schools are hellscapes" posts Mon & Tues, I was embarrassed to find myself grilling my (ES) kids last night at dinner about how many absences there were in their classes. (Only one kid? Are you sure? What about your teachers? All of them there - what about specials?) Basically, school's unchanged in their eyes from last year. So thanks DCUM-catastrophizers! Now my kids (correctly?) think I'm crazy. |
+5 My three elementary schoolers have plenty of classmates there. Their teachers are there (DD’s 4th grade teacher had COVID in early December). The social interaction and learning are there, at least based on reports of quizzes and assignments, so…? That was all true when schools opened in March 2021, by the way. My kids were SO happy to be back for real school. Heck, even though my then third grader had to deal with a revolving cast of subs and Zoom in the room (maternity leave related, less COVID), she was glad to be there. By the way, when people talk about kids being adaptable, these are the kinds of adaptations that are reasonable to expect of them: wearing masks, some limitations on physical distance, etc. They can deal with that. Indefinite remote instruction and minimal peer interaction? Not so much. |
Its a bit ironic you are ranting about someone being selfish when we are in a surge in a serious health pandemic. You don't care about making others miserable when your child brings covid to school and spreads it to others. You don't care about the impact on those kids and their families. You don't care about the school staff. All you care about is yourself. Have you ever thought about the kids whose parents have had to keep them isolated for two years because of people like you who refuse to curb their behavior to stop the spread? Have you thought about their mental health and socialization? You aren't dealing with it the best you can and you are living your life as normal without any care to anyone else. |
Your child isn't "NT" by your definition if they are having mental health issues. Stop complaining about her mental health here, find a way to make VL work if she needs to transition to it and get her mental health treatment. Maybe it isn't VL but your family life. School is boring. Many things in life are boring. She has to learn to deal with it. I don't get people like you who are bitterly complaining about how hard the pandemic is when very little has changed in your home. You have no idea how hard its been on others who have had to go in isolation, especially right now but this is going on two years, because of people like you are are living life as normal and have no consideration to others. Kids at this age struggle. Jumping to the mental health blame is absurd to justify unperson school in a health pandemic. |
I'm not the PP you are responding to, but there is zero evidence from that person's post that they are refusing to "curb their behavior." I am one of the above posters, though, and I have not traveled, or eaten in a restaurant, or been inside another family's home since March 2020. What I have done is send my kids to school, because schools have been open. I've been lucky, but I've also been careful, so please go spew your allegations someone else. |
People with older kids can read the news and look at numbers and understand how serious it is. You may not be taking covid seriously, but then you have no right to complain. |
|
Woza. So you're complaining that people haven't been in absolute complete lockdown? No, we haven't. But zero activities, zero school, and zero family visits is an unreasonable expectation for most people. If that's your metric, then good luck to you friend. |
|
When covid first appeared someone used an image of water lilies in a pond multiplying to visualize exponential growth. I am a visual person. That image worked to me. A few cases here and there, no big deal. But as they beget more, suddenly the lake is full. The point here is, things are normal *now.* They may not stay that way.
Or, they may, for your child and your family. But the real cost of that lies beneath the water, in places you can't see. It lies with people you don't know, will never know. The price of your child's normalcy is surging case rates, hospitals being overwhelmed, and thousands saddled with long-term suffering. I can't make you believe those people are real. That is something perhaps your own parents, or religion, or conscience should have done long ago. We all weigh acceptable risk for ourselves and others every day we get in a car, so don't use that old chestnut as a comparison. Covid isn't driving, and omicron isn't delta. When infection rates were much lower our county was doing a good job, even with a lot of people resuming "normal" life. Now, we seem firmly committed to winnowing out the weak, the infirm, the old... Those who should take on the "responsibility" for saving themselves, apparently, even when we don't have the tools for them to do that. And all so Larla's mental health isn't impacted by not being able to run for student body president. Despite all the purple prose above, I'm not actually a virtual forever person. I am a person who weighs risk to my family and others and makes choices accordingly. At the moment, cases are climbing exponentially at our schools. Based on the examples of other cities (namely New York) we will be where they are soon enough. I don't see the point in putting my kid into that infection chain. It's mostly a matter of conscience, not risk. And I know that seems nuts. Perhaps it is. But I was raised to follow my conscience, even when it tells me what the majority are doing isn't right, and I've tried to live that way through this virus. Do no harm, is, I think, sometimes the best we can do. |
Were your knees okay after climbing down from that soapbox? It's all about being able to run for student body president after all. That's why kids need in-person. |