The "behold the feral baseball sibling" videos are funny! Last spring my older DD's house softball games were played on a field by a really nice bike bath. The younger siblings started bringing their bikes and going off for bike rides together. It just sort of happened. My younger DD loved it, and also really clicked and made friends with another girl. |
I mean the title of this is, "what's wrong with overscheduling?" And i wouldn't call playing or hanging out in the neighborhood random, or say that those friendships aren't real |
The only people complaining here are the unscheduled. |
For my oldest’s baseball games the younger kids brought scooters, soccer balls, and played at the playgrounds a lot of the time. There are always playgrounds at these baseball fields. My 2 younger kids brought paper, markers, bracelet making kits and would make the other kids bracelets in team colors. It’s funny that strangers are worried that kids don’t play enough or don’t know how to be bored. If they only knew what the people they are faux concerned about were really doing. |
I really don't know why the OP adopted the busybodies' language of "over scheduling"; it sounds like she thinks her kids' schedule is fine. And neighborhood friendships are real, and wonderful when they work out (they can be a bit more fleeting than other types of kid friendships, I have noticed, though). I meant random in timing. Just because my kid does not happen to be available at the random times when your kid is does not mean she is over scheduled. You don't even know that her lack of availability is because she is at a structured activity. She could be at a playdate/hangout with teammates or other non-neighborhood friends or our weekly gatherings with cousins, etc. |
I dont think many ppl are totally unscheduled. |
I don't personally know any but there seem to be some here worried about kids they don't know. |
I wouldn't say worried, it is interesting how organized play has seemingly taken over a kids life. I do feel bad, however, for the kids, however many of few of them there are, that do feel overscheduled |
Our high school will have over 120 boys trying out for popular sports. For some sports there is no freshman team, only JV and varsity. So yes, PP’s numbers are correct because the public high schools here are very large (too big IMO). Someone whose kids went to a HS where everyone got to play should probably sit this one out. They have no idea how competitive it is at some of the schools around here. Boys playing on top travel teams for years cannot even make JV sometimes. People whose kids go to private school really shouldn’t comment on what public school parents choose when it comes to sports. It’s not even remotely an apples to oranges comparison. I think we all just want our kids to have a chance to meaningfully participate in things in HS. Unfortunately for many large publics that’s a lot harder and requires a lot more preparation leading up to that point just to have a chance. |
I remember my friend’s son going to 530am Green Days last year for a very popular sport. 100+ kids are trying out for baseball or soccer and as pp stated, some teams have only JV and varsity. At our high school, there is only one varsity tennis team. There are only 1-5 open spots per year so if your kid hasn’t played tennis a lot, your kid has no shot at making the tennis team. The kids who have done clinics once per week in elementary are not making our school tennis team. |
That’s so kewl |
It depends on the kid. My child is rather introverted and needs downtime after being in school the whole day. Also, I don't have money and time to do lots of activities, so we only do one paid activity a week. |
I think way worse than the "over scheduled kid" is the at-home helicopter parent that insists every second of the kids free time at home is doing something to get ahead. They don't let the kid just be and play in the backyard with friends. Instead, they are constantly pushing workbooks and practice for this and that and zero playdates because they want them doing something productive. Those are the truly screwed up parents and kids - (my kids are grown - and had something almost every day and thrived - but we also valued and allowed downtime at home. I knew a more than a few families like described , and it never turned out well ) |
+1 kids really don't get to be kids anymore, they aren't allowed any freedom. |
I don’t know one person like this and I’m Asian American. Even my relatives in Asia who have to study after school in those cram academies still find time to hang out and they have lots of friends. |