1. We never saw a VMPI proposal. 2. None of the infographics even mentioned detracking. 3. You are referring to a link from the website as some proof that this VMPI’s top secret mission? Stop pushing BS conspiracy theories. And since there is so much ignorance and misinformation floating around this thread, let’s clarify… The big push from “equity” groups is to have more URM kids in advanced math. |
Settings for this: Select school years 2022-2023, 2021-2022, 2020-2021, 2018-2019. Report level: School Division: fairfax county Grade: 6 Subject area: Mathematics Test Algebra I Leave everything else on default, and then hit submit. Eventually, the bottom of the page will show all of the schools that had a student take the Algebra I SOL in 6th. |
It's 3 years because you read on the internet that Algebra belongs in 9th grade. As I pointed out, there's more and more effort to clarify that it really doesn't and Algebra I should really belong in 8th grade. But why then this hatred of kids who have not "skipped," but studied and learned years of math? I suspect you're one of the ubereager parents of kid who tried and failed. You're certainly not actually in the field working with advanced kids the way I am. Otherwise, you would see their effort and joy at excelling when they combine their talent with hard work, and how they are disappointed when they are put in classes where they have to redo the same stuff over and over because some peer didn't get it or the teacher fell victim to the ideology you pursue. |
So you tutor or teach at AOPS/RSM/etc. You should teach in public schools if you want to reach children. Instead of teaching in a fun, glorified cram school that leads to disappointment in school. |
The test is capped at grade level, so there is no way to see. |
Looking at the State-wide numbers, the pass rate for 6th graders in Algebra 1 is over 98.5% for all of past two decades, and 100% more than half of the those years. Clear evidence that 6th graders are more than capable of taking on Algebra 1. The same cannot be said of 8th grader who waited and then enrolled in Algebra 1, with 10 to 12% failing the basic SOL. |
FTFY. So the only argument you could possibly be legitimately making from this evidence is that FCPS should be only as restrictive as the least restrictive system in Virginia that allows 6th graders to take Algebra 1. Since no system is open enrollment, you cannot be making the OP's argument, which was a fallacious connection between an article about advanced math in Texas and open enrollment for 6th graders into Algebra 1 Honors. |
This is the hilarious logic of the poster who wants more students to take Algebra in 6th grade. Lol |
Statewide data also shows that 6th graders who take Algebra 1, move on to enroll in Geometry in 7th, and Algebra 2 in 8th, have their 8th grade SOL pass rate for Algebra 2 well over 99% for all years (pre pandemic). Another data point showing advanced 8th graders are highly successful enrolling in Algebra 2. |
Do you really need data showing that kids who are academically advanced are going to do well....in academics? This is surprising? |
The entire point of original article and the title of this discussion is URM kids are being excluded from advanced math options that have proven to be overwhelmingly successful with 98% pass rate everywhere (including VA according to above data. ). An open enrollment with an option to step down increases the opportunities in advanced math for URM kids. from article: "We have seen our advanced math enrollment numbers for all demographics increase," McDaniel said. "But specifically with students of poverty and students of color, we have seen an increase in the number of students in advanced math tracks." |
Incorrect. It is adaptive and capped at 3 years above grade level. An advanced 2nd grader can be at level 3,4,or 5. |
There are different settings and FCPS doesn't use it the way you are saying. |
Ironically yes, but URM kids dont get to enjoy the same benefit with advanced math options hidden from them. |
For the very last time, advanced math != Algebra 1 Honors in 6th grade. advanced math == Algebra 1 Honors in 8th grade |