Rules about double rostering between different clubs

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It’s funny someone is posting on here with the sole purpose of calling people out because they don’t have the balls to do it in real life lol.

One example is a girl who plays for the U15 Solar ECNL team and U15 Michigan Jaguars GA team. This girl is currently ranked #4 overall in the TopDrawerSoccer rankings. If you look at this player's social media and the social media from either club you'll see that both clubs are claiming this player. At any rate, I just figured there was some rules within ECNL and/or GA that would prohibit something like this from happening.

Are you telling me there is a girl who was trained in this area that now plays for teams in both Texas and Michigan?

Who said Michigan?

I assumed the Michigan Jaguars were in Michigan?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:There are players who are playing within the same season on both an ECNL and GA team. In fact, the players will compete with one club team one weekend and go to the other one the following weekend then back and forth. How are there not any rules against this?

I may want to do this with my ds. He currently is a double rostered player within the same club, but I don’t think it will last another year. I think if anything I would keep him in ECNL and then have him tryout out for a top tier CCL team since they are in two different associations. I heard u.s. club soccer and u.s. youth soccer do not communicate frequently

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It’s funny someone is posting on here with the sole purpose of calling people out because they don’t have the balls to do it in real life lol.

Except no one is calling anyone out here. No one.

Not by name, but you're still calling someone out.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It’s funny someone is posting on here with the sole purpose of calling people out because they don’t have the balls to do it in real life lol.

Except no one is calling anyone out here. No one.

Not by name, but you're still calling someone out.

No the point - troll

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:It’s funny someone is posting on here with the sole purpose of calling people out because they don’t have the balls to do it in real life lol.

Except no one is calling anyone out here. No one.

Not by name, but you're still calling someone out.

No the point - troll

Then what is your point?

[Anonymous]

So is there a rule against rostering a girl in ECNL and having her guest play in certain GA events, or not?

Is there a rule against rostering a girl in GA and having her guest play in certain ECNL events, or not? It looks like the Michigan Jaguars (GA) girl guest played an ECNL event for Solar (ECNL).

Hypothetically, could a girl roster as Mclean/Loudoun/VDA/BRYC and then guest play at a GA showcase as a guest player at FCV (assuming FCV wanted the player to do that)?

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So is there a rule against rostering a girl in ECNL and having her guest play in certain GA events, or not? NO

Is there a rule against rostering a girl in GA and having her guest play in certain ECNL events, or not? It looks like the Michigan Jaguars (GA) girl guest played an ECNL event for Solar (ECNL). NO

Hypothetically, could a girl roster as Mclean/Loudoun/VDA/BRYC and then guest play at a GA showcase as a guest player at FCV (assuming FCV wanted the player to do that)? YES

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:So is there a rule against rostering a girl in ECNL and having her guest play in certain GA events, or not? NO

Is there a rule against rostering a girl in GA and having her guest play in certain ECNL events, or not? It looks like the Michigan Jaguars (GA) girl guest played an ECNL event for Solar (ECNL). NO

Hypothetically, could a girl roster as Mclean/Loudoun/VDA/BRYC and then guest play at a GA showcase as a guest player at FCV (assuming FCV wanted the player to do that)? YES

It might be a player who has committed to move to the club with which she is guest playing (in your example, FCV) and her current coach (in your example, one of the ECNL clubs you mentioned) is aware she’s moving and gives the green light. She could do it without telling her current coach since GA and ECNL passsws are different but chances are her coach would find out and there could be repercussions.

[Anonymous]

Anonymous wrote:So is there a rule against rostering a girl in ECNL and having her guest play in certain GA events, or not?

Is there a rule against rostering a girl in GA and having her guest play in certain ECNL events, or not? It looks like the Michigan Jaguars (GA) girl guest played an ECNL event for Solar (ECNL).

Hypothetically, could a girl roster as Mclean/Loudoun/VDA/BRYC and then guest play at a GA showcase as a guest player at FCV (assuming FCV wanted the player to do that)?

I'd call it more than guest play. This girl played in the majority of the Solar ECNL league games too. She's on all their official team roster.

So yeah, this begs the question whether a player from say VDA could also play for FCV? Agree, the respective clubs would have to agree to all this which is unlikely.