|
I was the poster asked to prove...the ones with twins that had the seven point response above. Here is more citations on the matter.
https://www.unigo.com/admissions-advice/do-colleges-look-more-favorably-on-applicants-who-can-pay-full-tuition/51/4 https://www.ivycoach.com/the-ivy-coach-blog/college-admissions/2-reasons-need-blind-admissions-farce/ https://www.fastweb.com/financial-aid/articles/does-applying-for-financial-aid-affect-your-chances-of-admission https://www.huffpost.com/entry/need-blind-admissions-is-_b_5615698 |
| Of course, we'll never know for sure, but my daughter with a 35 ACT, 3.9 UWGPA, very artistic/creative with leadership and interesting related activities, did not get into Wesleyan, not even waitlisted. We needed FA and I do believe that that played into the rejection. She got into all of the other schools that she applied to, with great merit (for the ones that offered it), and was waitlisted at Vassar. I had anticipated that she'd be waitlisted at Wesleyan as well since it is very competitive to get into. The flat out denial was a surprise, but they do say they are need aware, so I do believe that played into it in this case. |
This is the problem. Kids, as in, the applicants themselves who need FA (stop saying we) are disadvantaged by their parents incomes. Which the kids have no control over. A tale as old as time... |
|
My child, like many, isn’t going to finish in 4 years. We are fine with the why of it, but are also very happy she chose one of her less expensive options after aid since it looks like we will be paying for a fifth.
Sometimes the best laid plans just dont work out. |
Sorry to be rough on you here, but you spent all that time typing and not reading. Read the link of need blind schools in the post of mine you quoted. Colby is NOT need blind. So you are correct about that but wrong about the claim that they are lying. Bowdoin IS need blind. You continue to claim they lie but have no evidence that is true, Covid or not. As for full pay being a hook: OF COURSE it is, at schools that are need aware. At schools that are need-blind, it is NOT, This self-determined distinction is NOT a secret and I posted a list for you to see. It’s not a “farce” despite what your “outside college consultants” told you. Schools that claim to be need blind in admissions are need blind in admissions. End period. |
Link 1: Would not load for me Link 2: The most famous article Making this specious claim and one largely responsible for this urban myth. HAS NO FACTS OR EVIDENCE, just a lot of conjecture. Most important: written by Bev Taylor, of IvyCoach, who charges A MILLION DOLLARS for her college consulting services (mostly to very rich internationals). Do you think she has a vested interest in those folks believing her? Link 3: Completely supports the claim that schools that say they are need blind are so: “ Ask the colleges you are considering whether they practice need-blind admissions, and whether that need-blind admissions policy or practice includes students who are wait-listed.” Link 4: Essentially the same article as link 2, also by “Million Dollar” Bev Taylor. https://nypost.com/2018/02/10/mom-agreed-to-give-consultant-1-5m-to-help-kids-college-admissions-suit/ Sorry there is ZERO EVIDENCE here. To repeat: Colleges that claim to be need blind in admissions are in fact need blind in admissions. Please do not hesitate to request financial aid from those colleges thinking it will help your chances of admissions. It will not. |
President Trump stop spreading fake news. You are wrong. You are not answering the bulk of my seven points. |
Articles are good sources. People that know more than you. These people know what they are talking about. |
NP. None of the articles are written by people who work in college admission. They're all by people who make their money by scaring parents. |
You want to get in an ad hominem and then demand I answer all your pointless typing number by number? OK. 1: Has nothing to do with need blind admission and since you don’t mention the schools we can’t even tell if they are applicable 2: You mention a school that doesn’t even claim to be need-blind (Colby) and mention other schools that are AND AGREE THAT THEY ARE!! So thanks for that. 3: Conjecture, no evidence that this shows colleges are lying about need blind admissions policies. Of course if you are from a top HS you have a better chance of admissions - this has nothing to do with need blind policies. 4: Yes, AT NEED AWARE SCHOOLS. Again, no evidence of this at need blind schools. 5: Repetition of your claim, no evidence provided. 6: I addressed your articles above. No evidence therein and in fact one of them (The Atlantic Article) supports the opposite claim. 7: This claim is true but has NOTHING to do with need-blind admissions policies. Happy now? |
| Honey I could care less whether you believe me. You are misleading this poor people that have rising seniors. I got my kids in and I am done so I could care less. The truth is the truth. |
Actually only one was written by a consultant. Huffington Post doesn’t provide consultancy to my knowledge. Again, my kids are in so I could care less. |
Holy cow did you even look at the author of the HP article you posted? Did you? Look now, I will wait. Come back and tell us about it. |
HP wouldn't post it Einstein without checking. |
LOL now I know you are a troll. And for those reading, the article was also written by “Million Dollar Bev” Taylor, the same as the second article. https://nypost.com/2018/02/10/mom-agreed-to-give-consultant-1-5m-to-help-kids-college-admissions-suit/ Please, people with children applying: Do not be afraid to ask for financial aid from need-blind schools. It will not harm your chance of admission at all. Know the difference between “need-blind” and “need aware” schools, unlike this mother of twins. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Need-blind_admission |