Ha!! Excellent. Does she lean towards the "Abby Wambach" or the "Alex Morgan"? |
What bad coaches have come from other clubs to join Arlington? Just generalities. At least here there are credible examples, but hate the rag on Arlington tone in these threads. |
Agreed. McLean and Alexandria have more intensive U8 programs than Arlington - but Arlington gets the bad rap for crazy parents and the U9 tryouts. Arlington has options for parents who do not want the competitive soccer environment through its ADP program, and then there is the entire Rec league. Arlington hosts legitimate Drop-in soccer days for any kids in the region to just come out and play to have fun without parents telling kids what to do - who else has something like that on a regular basis? Arlington gets about 2X as many people trying out for its 6 travel teams as other local clubs, and then can field about 6 - 8 ADP teams in the same age group, and dozens of rec leagues per grade. Soccer is big in Northern VA, it is a popular sport. I'm not saying Arlington is the best, but its top teams are generally always competitive. |
I don't disagree with what you said, but let's be fair. The pool of people that only have Arlington as their travel club option is ENORMOUS. That is why there are so many kids playing soccer for the Club. Arlington is going to have a 4,000 person High School and 3 other High Schools at close to 2,000-3,000 (all feeding into one Club). The schools cannot keep up with the number of children. AC has a population feeding into the Club the size of Iceland. Other Clubs have much, much smaller pool of players and many more clubs right next door. If there was a Fairfax County Soccer Association you would see something along those lines. Again, I'm not saying anything bad. I'm just saying they get a little full of themselves without realizing the reason they can field so many teams---and still have fairly good athletes on even the lowest teams is a sheer numbers game. |
| ^^ true that. My kid's elementary school has 8 additional trailers on the field to house classrooms. Every kid coming out of them is wearing an ASA travel jacket. |
I'd be more impressed with a Club that can turn coal into diamonds.
|
Good post, so finally going to add my 2 cents. Everyone rags on Arlington for the fun of it. We have been at other clubs and are now at Arlington. I think this is one of the most honest accurate posts I have read. The club is huge, and yes you can feel lost in some system, similar to feeling lost at some huge university versus a small college. But that size offers so many great options. It does have the best rec league, ADP is truly one of a kind, and what club does the drop in soccer?, forgot all about that! I think families do get caught up in colors and moving up thinking that somehow Red means your player is great. Probably unavoidable at such a big club. Most parents like that are stupid about soccer anyway ("boot it," "send him," "shoot," etc.), and those can be found at any club. The smart parents focus on the coach, training curriculum, and playing time/roster size issues. Unfortunately, most parents there have never played the game at a competitive level and know how to evaluate this. I disagree that a club like McLean is more intense because it has a U8 Academy. A travel-lite Academy that is tryout based is better way to go then what Arlington is doing by having so many young kids come there in first grade. 2010s at tryouts . . . Really? Letting Type A parents on field to talk to players and coaches at U9 tryouts . . . Really? Training 4 teams on half a field, or 3 teams on a quarter field . . . Really? So, how about constructive criticism here like these sort of statements, versus lobbing hand grenades that the Arlington coaches are other clubs' rejects? Other then this thread's anecdotal examples on Kelser, I have yet to read a post where they identified some coach as a reject, and their basis for the claim. Kelser doesn't sound like a bowl full of cherries, but I guess Arlington will see. But please stop with the generalities. Also, many families would rather be at a small club then feel lost in the middle or lower tiers there. Nothing wrong with that. Usually those types will do U9 or U10 on some middle team where they feel close enough to the top that the become unsatisfied if they don't break in. But that is not a knock on the club, and I don't think Arlington would despise any kid for leaving black or blue for some small club experience. Also, the allegations about corruption ate the biggest crock of shit I have ever read. The place seems run by parents and committees, instead of overpaid entrenched administrators and insiders. The technical staff gets this reputation as playing favorites, but have never experienced that in my many interactions. Have never felt threatened to be black-listed, nor handed some favor. Basically, I feel they try to do best by their many, many players. I am not bullshitting here either. So, my 2 cents. Not paid by the club or work there. Just a parent with experience at several clubs (big, medium, small) trying to recognize finally a post from someone that seems fair on this f#cked up anonymous board. The prior post above is a good post for those trying to navigate the bullshit on these forums, and I would say Arlington is a very good option to consider. No way is it perfect. And every family different. |
Well said--except for the arrogance in bold. Even kids that make the top red/white Arl teams sometimes leave for a different Club. People keep harping that it is just some disgruntled lower team player so I thought that should at least be clarified: not everyone leaving is a kid that did not make a Red/White team (just like at other Clubs, btw). Kids often make top teams at multiple Clubs and make a choice for a variety of different reasons. Often, leaving for another Club often has little to do with the Club per se or the Coaches. Some kids/families just do better/feel more comfortable in a smaller organization. Much like picking a smaller University over a large one. But, you will just keep feeding the stereotype about the Club on these Boards when you categorize the reason that every kid that leaves or doesn't accept an offer is an untalented loser on an lower team. |
yeah, but if you go over the private school boards you'll see the same reports about National Cathedral School.
|
Very defensive. Read the post. It is about families who feel lost. Top tier players (on red/white) leave all the time, but we have yet to meet a parent that said they did so because they felt lost at a big club. I have met plenty of families who privately have told me they felt lost, and can't break into the visibility/limelight afforded in their minds to the top. ALL of them were on middle or lower tier. (And plenty of families on those teams who do not feel lost!) For anyone feeling lost at a big club, like a big school, we have suggested trying a smaller club as a solution. We have also told them they may be misreading things when they feel the age group coach or TD is talking to some Red parent but has never spoken to them. So please get over your bullshit that this is arrogance. It is a fact and we are at the club. You have some chip on your shoulder by that reflex reaction. All red/white families are not arrogant, do not perpetuate this view, and many leave for smaller clubs. Have not been there since the beginning, so maybe you know a family that feels lost in the system on a White/Red Team? That would be a rare find at Arlington. |
We've had kids in Arlington travel soccer for 6 years and the bolded part is absolutely true. I'm glad you haven't run into yet, but it is there with some of the coaches, parents & staff. |
They'll tell you you're doing that every week, not to worry. |
Yeah - the emails and the epic meetings to talk about how incompetent your young children are at soccer. The memories! Before people think we're all nuts - the girls played because the other kids were nice and they liked playing and the parents were typically pretty fun and interesting too. Not sure if you're getting him too but Karen's husband is way better with the little kids. |
Some definitely quit though. One who was cut from one of her teams went straight to a top Bethesda team. |
Keep it coming - this stuff is priceless. |