Anonymous wrote:OP here. I guess now I'm one of those annoying people who keep responding to the responders, but here goes.
I did say my daughter noticed each pregnancy. I didn't mean to suggest that I spoke to her about them or let her know she was right. Either she's just one of those sensitive, empaths who can pick up on stuff or what, but she knew. Each time, she knew. And she would tell me I knew. And I would deny. I would deflect. I even tried the whole "it's not polite to point out weigh gain" line once. She winked at me and said something smart-alecky like "it's not polite to lie to your kid about not being pregnant." I know, people are eye-rolling that I think I have a special snowflake. But she's... special. She sees things people don't want seen. She pays attention to everything. And still, I've literally lied to her face about it all. Except for vaguely finally giving in one Christmas day when she was crying while playing with her legos that it was going to be yet another year with no sibling to play with. Maybe it was wrong. But it felt right just to tell her that we were still trying. And I literally had no choice about one of the miscarriages. I wouldn't have told her the truth but a medical professional took that out of my hands.
My gut told me to maybe be vaguely honest about medicine, since she's going to see it and I have no intention of buying a mini fridge and trying to hide it. Our house isn't so huge that she wouldn't notice something like that. I don't have a "walk in closet." And we don't have locks on any doors in the house except the front and the back. But my gut was also telling me not to say anything more because I do want to protect her heart from the ups and downs. I just wanted some thoughts from the community on whether I should actually say more. Other threads have people telling their kids at 3 and 4 that they came from a donor egg, which I get is a different situation, but it still made me at least
wonder whether I should tell my deeply invested pre-teen a little more than what I had been telling her. I'm frankly shocked at all the judgment getting thrown my way. Thanks to those of you who have posted thoughtful suggestions. They are deeply appreciated.